AI summary by TwinMind

Lecture 12: Syntax, Part 2

MIT OpenCourseWare

1h 10m 49s

Syntax Tree Construction Review

  • Started with morphology example "unlockable" - three morphemes composed in pairs
  • Two ways to construct: [un + lock] + able vs. [lock + able] + un with different meanings
  • Applied same pairwise merge operation concept to syntax
  • Sentences are strings of words composed via pairwise merge operation
  • Example sentence: "I will find the book in the garage" (8 words)

Tree Building and Labeling Conventions

  • Merge determiners "the" with nouns "book" and "garage" to form larger objects
  • Labeling rules for nodes created by merge:
    • In morphology: affixes provide instructions (un + verb → verb, able + verb → adjective)
    • In syntax: label of result is always label of one of the two merged items
    • Label reflects what syntactic rules care about (nouns can be modified various ways)
  • Phrase notation conventions:
    • P (phrase) = highest node with given label from specific word
    • Unmarked = lowest thing with label (just the word)
    • Everything between = bar notation (V-bar, N-bar, etc.)
    • Bar notation originated from typewriter era with actual bars over letters
    • Never called "V Prime" - always "V bar"

Prepositional Phrase Attachment and Ambiguity

  • Prepositional phrases can modify both noun phrases and verb phrases
  • Creates recursive structures: NPs can contain PPs, PPs can contain NPs
  • Allows arbitrarily long phrases (competence vs. performance distinction)
  • Classic ambiguity example: "I shot an elephant in my pajamas"
    • Two interpretations: elephant wearing pajamas vs. speaker wearing pajamas
    • Two different tree structures based on PP attachment point

Constituency Tests - Topicalization

  • Topicalization: moving constituents to sentence beginning for emphasis
  • Test reveals which structures are possible:
    • "The elephant I shot in my pajamas" - only speaker wearing pajamas reading
    • "The elephant in my pajamas I shot" - only elephant wearing pajamas reading
  • Topicalization collapses ambiguity by forcing specific tree structure
  • Only constituents can be topicalized
  • Additional constraint: may require phrases (not just bars) for topicalization

Multiple Prepositional Phrases

  • Example: "I shot the elephant in my pajamas in a tuxedo"
  • Only one interpretation possible due to structural constraints
  • Elephant wearing pajamas, speaker wearing tuxedo
  • No line-crossing allowed in trees (Ghostbusters rule)

Complete Sentence Structure

  • Added tense phrase (TP) for complete sentences
  • "Will" labeled as T (tense) - covers auxiliaries like "can," "might"
  • Different from adverbs like "quickly" based on:
    • Question formation: "Will the girl find it?" vs. "*Quickly the girl found it?"
    • Ellipsis patterns: "The girl will" vs. "*The girl quickly"
  • Sentence structure: [The girl [will [find the book in the garage]]]
  • Merge T with VP first, then merge subject with result

VP Ellipsis Phenomenon

  • Process of silencing verb phrases in certain contexts
  • Examples: "Who will find the book? The girl will [VP]"
  • Distinguished from constituency structure
  • Allows omission of repeated VP content

Additional Ambiguity Examples

  • "I will tickle the child with the feather"
  • Same PP attachment ambiguity pattern
  • Child has feather vs. using feather to tickle
  • Topicalization tests confirm different structures

Tree Terminology

  • Sister: two nodes merged together to create larger node
  • Mother: node created by merging two nodes
  • Daughter: nodes that were merged to create mother node
  • Immediate domination: direct mother-daughter relationship
  • Domination: transitive closure of immediate domination
  • Constituent: words dominated by single node

Pronoun Reference Constraints (Preview)

  • "She thinks I like Mary" - she cannot refer to Mary
  • "Mary thinks I like her" - her can refer to Mary
  • "Everyone who knows her likes Mary" - her can refer to Mary
  • Not simply about linear order in sentence
  • Structural relationship determines pronoun reference possibilities
  • Will provide additional constituency tests

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome