AI summary by TwinMind
Lecture 15: Gender and the Labor Market
MIT OpenCourseWare
1h 26m 8s
Failure of Efficient Household Models
- Basic household models fail in both production and consumption space
- Need alternative frameworks to understand family dynamics
- Recent literature provides clues but no satisfactory alternative framework yet
Information Flows Within Households
- Assumption: family members should outperform strangers due to better communication
- Gottem Rao, Matthew Ridley, Frank Sinbach experiment:
- Social learning experiment with 400 couples and 500 strangers
- Guessing share of red balls in urn for monetary rewards
- Three treatments: own signal, spouse discussion, direct spouse signal communication
- Key findings:
- Husbands heavily discount wife's information even when perfectly communicated
- Wives pay equal attention to husband's and own information (rational behavior)
- With strangers: both men and women pay little attention to others' information
- Women's attention to husbands is household-specific, not gender-general trait
- Puts "clear wrench" in theory of perfect information communication within households
Information Manipulation and Contraception
- Nabash, Erica Fields, Jennifer Lee study in Zambia:
- Injectable contraceptive vouchers (3-month validity)
- Men want more children than women (don't internalize childbirth mortality risk)
- Two treatments: individual woman gets voucher vs couple gets voucher
- Results:
- Couple treatment: 26 percentage point decline in voucher redemption (65% baseline)
- Injectable receipt: 30% individual treatment vs 7% couple treatment
- Women likely suppressed information and got contraception alone
Training Program Access Study
- Same researchers, opposite information flow:
- Women's training program vouchers given to: men privately, women privately, or couples with forced discussion
- Men prefer wives don't work, women want to work
- Findings:
- Husband-only voucher = same enrollment as when wife unaware
- No loss from husband never discussing with wife
- Forced discussion actually decreased enrollment
- Suggests zero bargaining power for wives or husbands ignore wives' preferences
Legal Framework and Gender Rights
- Penny Goldberg's World Bank database on gender rights:
- Global average: women have 75/100 rights compared to men
- Middle East/North Africa: 40% of men's rights
- South Asia: 60% of men's rights
- Strong correlation between legal rights and female labor force participation
- Legal framework determines negotiation context, not just social norms
Cultural Origins of Gender Norms
- Alesina, Giuliano, Nunn "plow hypothesis" study:
- Regions with historical plow agriculture have lower female labor force participation
- Plow agriculture required male strength, reducing women's agricultural role
- FAO crop suitability data used to predict historical plow use
- Cross-country evidence shows negative correlation between plow suitability and current female labor participation
- Example: North India (plow/wheat) vs South India (rice/hand cultivation) - women better treated in South
Social Norm Misperception
- Leo Bursztyn experiment with 500 young Saudi men:
- 87% personally agree women should work outside home
- Most underestimate how many other men agree (think <80% when reality is 87%)
- Debiasing experiment:
- Half told correct percentage of supportive men
- Choice: $5 Amazon certificate vs sign wife up for job platform
- Debiased men: 32% vs 23% signed wives up for job platform
- Effect comes specifically from men who initially underestimated social support
- Second experiment: Real marketing jobs, home vs office choice
- Office jobs pay more but require leaving home
- Similar debiasing effects on actual employment decisions
Acting Wife Phenomenon in US
- Bursztyn, Fujiwara, Pallais MBA study:
- Career preferences stated publicly vs privately
- Single women in mixed-gender groups less ambitious when preferences made public
- Effect only for single women (not married), only in mixed groups
- Suggests women hide ambition to remain marriageable
- Consistent with limited commitment household model where higher earnings = higher bargaining power
US Historical Context
- Hsieh et al. study: 1960: 94% doctors/lawyers were white men; 2010: 62%
- Reallocation of talent explains 20-40% of US growth during this period
- Shows economic importance of reducing gender/racial barriers
Social Norms Persistence and Change
- TV and Social Change:
- Eliana La Ferrara Brazil soap opera study: Cable TV access reduced fertility rates, names given to children matched soap opera characters
- Abhijit MTV Nigeria study: Randomized MTV programming affected risky sexual behavior and respectful attitudes
Educational Interventions
- Seema Jayachandran North India study:
- 45-minute classroom discussions every 3 weeks for 2 years in 314 schools
- 0.25 standard deviation improvement in gender norms
- Effects persist several years post-intervention
- Behavioral changes especially among boys
- Addresses demand effects through social desirability bias testing
Women's Agency and Self-Efficacy
- Maddie McElroy India carpet manufacturer study:
- Two interventions: Generalized Self-Efficacy (GSE) training + husband/in-law promotion video
- GSE training: Bandura's concept, building agency through case studies (no labor market examples)
- Results:
- GSE alone: increased female labor force participation
- Promotion alone: increased firm program signup
- Combined treatment: smaller/no effect (negative interaction)
- Suggests women resist jobs when both empowered and pushed by husbands
Financial Control and Bargaining Power
- Rohini Pandey et al. Madhya Pradesh study:
- NREGA payments directly to women's bank accounts vs through husbands
- Short-term effects: Increased labor supply in NREGA and other work
- Increased women's empowerment measures (mobility, decision-making)
- Mechanism: Direct payment → retained earnings → more bargaining power → more work
Long-term Employment Challenges
- Maddie McElroy follow-up:
- Short-term: women work more but same household chores (less leisure)
- 4 months: women think they have more decision power, families disagree
- Long-term: Women drop out due to incompatibility with other responsibilities
- Links to Claudia Goldin's point about inflexible full-time work requirements
Female Business Productivity Puzzle
- McKenzie-Woodruff finding: Same-sized grants to female businesses show no profitability impact; large effects for male businesses
- Ringold, Pandey, Field reanalysis:
- Money given to women invested in male businesses instead
- Family income increases equally regardless of grant recipient gender
- Female businesses appear unproductive because they never receive investment
Experimental Evidence on Business Capability
- Vegetable vendor experiment:
- Women-owned stalls appear less productive than men's
- Controlled experiment: Same vegetable endowments given to both genders
- Women make same profits as men with equal starting inputs
- Problem is lower initial endowment, not ability or customer discrimination
Child Care Constraint Hypothesis
- Female businesses designed as activities compatible with child care
- Can't scale up because would interfere with child care responsibilities
- Bangladesh factory study: Women tailors equally productive but promoted less
- Higher female turnover anticipated
- Related to child care obligations
- Child care norms may be strongest constraint on women's economic participation
