AI summary by TwinMind
Lecture 15: Switching Losses and Snubbers
MIT OpenCourseWare
42m 17s
Device Review and Switch Characteristics
- Power electronics circuits use transistors as switches (bipolar, FET)
- Ideal switches:
- Instantaneous turn on/off
- Zero voltage drop when on (zero resistance)
- Carry positive/negative current
- Infinite resistance when off, no leakage
- Block positive/negative voltage
- No parasitics, no losses
- Practical switches (BJT, IGBT, SCR/CSR, diode, MOSFET, wide bandgap GaN FET):
- Finite turn on/off time
- Finite voltage drop/small resistance when on
- Current polarity restrictions (BJT: positive only, MOSFET: bidirectional)
- Large off resistance with some leakage
- Voltage blocking polarity limitations
- Parallel capacitance parasitics
- Anti-parallel diode in some switches
- Non-zero losses: conduction, switching, gating
Buck Converter Analysis and Conduction Loss
- Basic circuit: input voltage source, MOSFET, diode, L-C filter, resistor load
- Constant inductor current assumption (large L, no ripple)
- Equivalent model: voltage source, MOSFET, diode, constant current source
- Switching pattern: 0 to DTs (duty cycle) - switch on, DTs to Ts - diode conducts
- Conduction loss calculations:
- MOSFET: P = I²RMS × RDS(on) = D × IL² × RDS(on)
- Diode: P = Iavg × Vdrop = (1-D) × IL × Vdrop
- MOSFET/GaN FET: use RMS² × RDS(on)
- BJT/IGBT/SCR/diode: use average current × voltage drop
Switching Loss Analysis
- Occurs during turn on/off transitions
- Assumptions:
- Linear vsw and isw during transients
- Ideal diode characteristics
- KCL equation: IL = isw + ID
- KVL equation: Vin = vsw - VD
- Turn off sequence:
- Voltage increases first to Vin maximum
- Then current decreases (diode cannot conduct until VD = 0)
- Turn on sequence:
- Current increases first to IL maximum
- Then voltage decreases (diode cannot block until ID = 0)
- Time intervals: TF (fall time), TR (rise time)
- Switching loss: Psw = vsw × isw (triangular power waveforms)
- Energy loss: Eoff = ½TF×Vin×IL, Eon = ½TR×Vin×IL
- Total switching loss: Psw = (Eoff + Eon) × fsw = ½(TF + TR)×Vin×IL×fsw
Switching Loss Limitations and Motivations
- Parasitic limitations:
- Parallel capacitance + stray inductance → resonance/overshoot
- Can destroy switches
- EMI issues:
- High di/dt, dv/dt create voltage/current spikes
- L×di/dt voltage spikes, C×dv/dt current spikes
- Interfere with control circuits
- Device limitations:
- High di/dt: current spreading issues in large devices, die/wire bond failure
- High dv/dt: can trigger SCR back on
- Safe Operating Area (SOA):
- VI curve boundaries for device operation
- Maximum current, voltage, power, thermal limits
- Hard switching can exceed instantaneous SOA limits
Snubber Circuit Motivations
- Two main goals:
- Maintain instantaneous current/voltage within SOA (low di/dt, dv/dt)
- Decrease switching loss inside switches
- Note: Total system energy loss may increase, but switch protection achieved
Turn-off Snubber Analysis
- Basic concept: Parallel capacitor with switch
- Modified KCL: IL = ID + isw + IC
- Current flow: Capacitor provides alternate path during transition
- Waveform analysis:
- Switch current: isw = IL - t/TF (linear decrease)
- Capacitor current: IC = IL×t/TF (linear increase)
- Capacitor voltage: VC = IL×t²/(2C×TF) (quadratic)
- Turn-off energy: Eoff = IL²×TF³/(24C)
- Energy control: Increase C to decrease switching loss
- Energy storage penalty: ½CV² stored in capacitor must be dissipated
Practical Turn-off Snubber
- Components: Diode in parallel with resistor, in series with capacitor
- Operation:
- Turn off: Current flows through capacitor
- Turn on: Capacitor discharges through resistor (not through switch)
- Advantage: Controls energy dissipation location and current limiting
Turn-on Snubber Analysis
- Dual circuit concept: Series inductor with switch
- Modified KVL: Vin = vsw + VL - VD
- Inductor provides voltage sustaining capability
- Waveform analysis:
- Switch voltage: linear decrease
- Inductor voltage: linear increase
- Switch current: quadratic increase (VL = L×di/dt)
- Energy storage: ½LI² in inductor
Practical Turn-on Snubber
- Components: Diode in series with resistor, in parallel with inductor
- Dual relationship:
- Turn-off: parallel capacitor concept
- Turn-on: series inductor concept
- Energy dissipation: Through resistor when switch turns off
Gate Drive Optimization
- TR and TF depend on: Device characteristics and driver capability
- Asymmetric gate drive:
- Turn on: larger resistor (slower, controlled)
- Turn off: smaller resistor (faster switching)
- Trade-off: Speed vs. control vs. EMI
