AI summary by TwinMind

Lecture 15: Switching Losses and Snubbers

MIT OpenCourseWare

42m 17s

Device Review and Switch Characteristics

  • Power electronics circuits use transistors as switches (bipolar, FET)
  • Ideal switches:
    • Instantaneous turn on/off
    • Zero voltage drop when on (zero resistance)
    • Carry positive/negative current
    • Infinite resistance when off, no leakage
    • Block positive/negative voltage
    • No parasitics, no losses
  • Practical switches (BJT, IGBT, SCR/CSR, diode, MOSFET, wide bandgap GaN FET):
    • Finite turn on/off time
    • Finite voltage drop/small resistance when on
    • Current polarity restrictions (BJT: positive only, MOSFET: bidirectional)
    • Large off resistance with some leakage
    • Voltage blocking polarity limitations
    • Parallel capacitance parasitics
    • Anti-parallel diode in some switches
    • Non-zero losses: conduction, switching, gating

Buck Converter Analysis and Conduction Loss

  • Basic circuit: input voltage source, MOSFET, diode, L-C filter, resistor load
  • Constant inductor current assumption (large L, no ripple)
  • Equivalent model: voltage source, MOSFET, diode, constant current source
  • Switching pattern: 0 to DTs (duty cycle) - switch on, DTs to Ts - diode conducts
  • Conduction loss calculations:
    • MOSFET: P = I²RMS × RDS(on) = D × IL² × RDS(on)
    • Diode: P = Iavg × Vdrop = (1-D) × IL × Vdrop
    • MOSFET/GaN FET: use RMS² × RDS(on)
    • BJT/IGBT/SCR/diode: use average current × voltage drop

Switching Loss Analysis

  • Occurs during turn on/off transitions
  • Assumptions:
    • Linear vsw and isw during transients
    • Ideal diode characteristics
  • KCL equation: IL = isw + ID
  • KVL equation: Vin = vsw - VD
  • Turn off sequence:
    • Voltage increases first to Vin maximum
    • Then current decreases (diode cannot conduct until VD = 0)
  • Turn on sequence:
    • Current increases first to IL maximum
    • Then voltage decreases (diode cannot block until ID = 0)
  • Time intervals: TF (fall time), TR (rise time)
  • Switching loss: Psw = vsw × isw (triangular power waveforms)
  • Energy loss: Eoff = ½TF×Vin×IL, Eon = ½TR×Vin×IL
  • Total switching loss: Psw = (Eoff + Eon) × fsw = ½(TF + TR)×Vin×IL×fsw

Switching Loss Limitations and Motivations

  • Parasitic limitations:
    • Parallel capacitance + stray inductance → resonance/overshoot
    • Can destroy switches
  • EMI issues:
    • High di/dt, dv/dt create voltage/current spikes
    • L×di/dt voltage spikes, C×dv/dt current spikes
    • Interfere with control circuits
  • Device limitations:
    • High di/dt: current spreading issues in large devices, die/wire bond failure
    • High dv/dt: can trigger SCR back on
  • Safe Operating Area (SOA):
    • VI curve boundaries for device operation
    • Maximum current, voltage, power, thermal limits
    • Hard switching can exceed instantaneous SOA limits

Snubber Circuit Motivations

  • Two main goals:
    1. Maintain instantaneous current/voltage within SOA (low di/dt, dv/dt)
    2. Decrease switching loss inside switches
  • Note: Total system energy loss may increase, but switch protection achieved

Turn-off Snubber Analysis

  • Basic concept: Parallel capacitor with switch
  • Modified KCL: IL = ID + isw + IC
  • Current flow: Capacitor provides alternate path during transition
  • Waveform analysis:
    • Switch current: isw = IL - t/TF (linear decrease)
    • Capacitor current: IC = IL×t/TF (linear increase)
    • Capacitor voltage: VC = IL×t²/(2C×TF) (quadratic)
  • Turn-off energy: Eoff = IL²×TF³/(24C)
  • Energy control: Increase C to decrease switching loss
  • Energy storage penalty: ½CV² stored in capacitor must be dissipated

Practical Turn-off Snubber

  • Components: Diode in parallel with resistor, in series with capacitor
  • Operation:
    • Turn off: Current flows through capacitor
    • Turn on: Capacitor discharges through resistor (not through switch)
  • Advantage: Controls energy dissipation location and current limiting

Turn-on Snubber Analysis

  • Dual circuit concept: Series inductor with switch
  • Modified KVL: Vin = vsw + VL - VD
  • Inductor provides voltage sustaining capability
  • Waveform analysis:
    • Switch voltage: linear decrease
    • Inductor voltage: linear increase
    • Switch current: quadratic increase (VL = L×di/dt)
  • Energy storage: ½LI² in inductor

Practical Turn-on Snubber

  • Components: Diode in series with resistor, in parallel with inductor
  • Dual relationship:
    • Turn-off: parallel capacitor concept
    • Turn-on: series inductor concept
  • Energy dissipation: Through resistor when switch turns off

Gate Drive Optimization

  • TR and TF depend on: Device characteristics and driver capability
  • Asymmetric gate drive:
    • Turn on: larger resistor (slower, controlled)
    • Turn off: smaller resistor (faster switching)
  • Trade-off: Speed vs. control vs. EMI

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome