AI summary by TwinMind

Lecture 16: Convergence and Cross-Country Variation

MIT OpenCourseWare

47m 1s

Completing Previous Growth Theory Analysis

  • Wrapping up growth theory section of course
  • Showing what current models can/cannot explain regarding global income disparities
  • Need to identify gaps to explain "great dispersion" in income per capita worldwide

Balanced Growth Path Review

  • Complete model: productivity growth + unemployment + population growth
  • Balanced growth normalization: effective workers (productivity × population)
  • Zero growth for normalized variables in steady state
  • Capital per worker grows at rate GA; output per worker grows at rate GA
  • Exogenous drivers: GA (technological progress) and GN (population growth)
  • In steady state: capital grows at GA + GN, output grows at GA + GN

Cobb-Douglas Production Function Example

  • Production function: K^(1-α) × (A×N)^α
  • Constant returns to scale (exponents sum to 1)
  • Growth accounting: output growth = (1-α) × capital growth + α × effective worker growth
  • Balanced growth: GK = GA + GN, therefore GY = GA + GN
  • Capital/output per worker: subtract GN to get GA

Measuring Technological Progress - Solow Residual

  • Challenge: measuring GA (technological progress rate)
  • Bob Solow's approach: competitive model assumption
  • Worker payment = marginal productivity ($30,000/year example)
  • Labor share contribution: α × GN (wage bill/total revenue × population growth)
  • Capital share contribution: (1-α) × GK
  • Solow residual: GA = GY - α×GN - (1-α)×GK
  • Technological progress = output growth minus factor contributions

China Growth Accounting Example (1978-2017)

  • Average growth: 7.2% per year
  • Population growth: 1.7% per year
  • Capital stock growth: 9.2% per year
  • Solow residual (technological progress): 4.2% per year
  • Analysis shows non-balanced growth (transitional growth)
  • Capital growing faster than output (9.2% vs 7.2%)
  • Indicates economy below steady state with rapid capital accumulation
  • Balanced growth rate would be: GA + GN = 4.2% + 1.7% = 5.9%
  • Transitional growth due to initial low capital stock

Human Capital Extension

  • Modified production function: Y = K^(1-α) × (A×H)^α
  • H = effective labor = N × e^(φ×S) where S = years of schooling
  • φ ≈ 0.1 (one extra year schooling raises human capital ~10%)
  • Huge cross-country differences in education levels
  • Normalization by population (N) rather than effective workers

Balanced Growth with Human Capital

  • Eventually GH = 0 (education cannot increase indefinitely)
  • Same balanced growth characteristics as basic model
  • Capital per person grows at GA, output per person grows at GA
  • Human capital affects steady state income level, not growth rate

Steady State Capital-Labor Ratio

  • Capital accumulation equation with human capital
  • Steady state: K/H = [s/(δ + n + GA)]^(1/(1-α))
  • Positive relationship with saving rate
  • Negative relationship with population growth
  • Output in balanced growth: function of technology, human capital, and structural parameters

Cross-Country Income Comparisons

  • Comparing countries to US baseline
  • Relative income: yi = (Hi/Hus) × (si/sus)^((1-α)/α) × other factors
  • Assumption: same technology across countries initially
  • Higher saving rates → higher income per capita
  • Higher population growth → lower income per capita

Technology Differences Across Countries

  • Initial assumption of equal technology worldwide = bad assumption
  • Measuring relative technology levels across countries
  • Technology differences explain 50-67% of cross-country income differences
  • Much more important than saving rates, education, population growth

Conditional Convergence

  • Models work well for countries with similar technology (A) and human capital (H)
  • Example: US, UK, Japan convergence 1870-present
  • Negative relationship between initial income and growth rate (for similar countries)
  • Countries with similar fundamentals converge to each other

Unconditional vs Conditional Convergence

  • Without controlling for A and H: convergence unclear
  • With controls for A and H: strong convergence patterns
  • Some countries (especially Africa) have persistently low technology levels
  • Each country converges to its own steady state, not universal steady state

Technology Disparity Trends

  • Growing inequality in technology levels worldwide
  • Ratio of 90th to 10th percentile GDP per worker increasing over time
  • Different rates of technological progress across countries
  • Recent decline possibly due to China's rapid growth and large size

Model Limitations

  • Good at explaining convergence to country-specific steady states
  • Poor at explaining why countries have different technology levels
  • Gap in understanding what drives technology adoption disparities
  • Institutions literature provides some explanations but incomplete

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome