AI summary by TwinMind

Lecture 20: Semantics, Part 4

MIT OpenCourseWare

1h 8m 35s

Binding Theory Overview

  • Review of binding theory as test for syntactic structure
  • Binding theory handles facts about reference patterns in sentences
  • Susan likes herself vs Susan likes her - different meanings and constraints
  • Herself must refer to Susan, her cannot refer to Susan
  • Subscript notation indicates co-reference relationships

C-Command and Structural Relationships

  • Languages don't use linear precedence for binding - only care about C-command
  • C-command definition: Alpha C-commands beta if every node that dominates alpha also dominates beta
  • Susan C-commands herself in "Susan likes herself"
  • Susan doesn't C-command herself in "Susan's father likes herself" - explains ungrammaticality
  • Remarkable fact: no languages use precedence for binding despite being easily accessible information
  • All languages use structural C-command relationships instead

Three Principles of Binding Theory

  • Principle A: Anaphors (herself, himself, each other) must be bound within TP
    • Must be C-commanded by co-referent NP within same TP
    • Includes reflexives (herself, himself) and reciprocals (each other)
  • Principle B: Pronouns (her, him) must be free within TP
    • Cannot be C-commanded by co-referent NP within same TP
  • Principle C: R-expressions (proper names like Susan) must be free everywhere
    • Cannot be C-commanded by co-referent NP anywhere in sentence

Locality Requirements and Complex Sentences

  • Faith's question about embedded clauses: "Mary thinks Susan must like herself"
  • Herself can refer to Susan but not to Mary due to locality
  • Anaphors need binders close enough - within smallest TP containing them
  • Pronouns show complementary distribution: "Susan thinks I like her" (where her = Susan) is fine

Cross-Linguistic Variation

  • English has short-distance anaphors only
  • Mandarin has both short-distance (ta-ziji) and long-distance (ziji) anaphors
  • Korean has four different anaphors with varying locality requirements
  • Universal: all languages have short-distance anaphors; long-distance anaphors are additional option

Evidence for PRO (Invisible Pronouns)

  • Sentences like "Mary decided to leave" - how many TPs?
  • Evidence for two TPs: "to" in complementary distribution with "will/should"
  • Extended Projection Principle requires every TP to have specifier
  • Only visible subject is Mary - where's subject of "leave"?
  • Binding evidence from control constructions:
    • "John promised Mary to defend himself" - himself refers to John
    • "John told Mary to defend herself" - herself refers to Mary
  • PRO theory explains these patterns: invisible pronoun in embedded subject position
  • PRO refers to controller determined by matrix verb (subject control vs object control)

Reconstruction and Movement

  • "Which picture of himself did John like best?" - grammatical despite apparent C-command violation
  • After wh-movement, John doesn't C-command himself in surface position
  • Reconstruction: binding evaluated at underlying position before movement
  • Evidence for successive-cyclic movement from binding theory
  • "Which picture of himself did John think that Mary bought?"
  • If movement in one step: no binding possible (too far/no C-command)
  • If successive-cyclic through intermediate CP: binding possible at intermediate position
  • Binding theory provides new argument for successive-cyclic movement

Quantifier Scope and Binding Interactions (Preview)

  • "Two guards seem to me to be standing in front of every building" - ambiguous
  • "Two guards seem to themselves to be standing in front of every building" - unambiguous
  • Themselves constrains interpretation, eliminating one scope reading
  • Sets up discussion for next class on binding-scope interactions

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome