AI summary by TwinMind
Lecture 20: Semantics, Part 4
MIT OpenCourseWare
1h 8m 35s
Binding Theory Overview
- Review of binding theory as test for syntactic structure
- Binding theory handles facts about reference patterns in sentences
- Susan likes herself vs Susan likes her - different meanings and constraints
- Herself must refer to Susan, her cannot refer to Susan
- Subscript notation indicates co-reference relationships
C-Command and Structural Relationships
- Languages don't use linear precedence for binding - only care about C-command
- C-command definition: Alpha C-commands beta if every node that dominates alpha also dominates beta
- Susan C-commands herself in "Susan likes herself"
- Susan doesn't C-command herself in "Susan's father likes herself" - explains ungrammaticality
- Remarkable fact: no languages use precedence for binding despite being easily accessible information
- All languages use structural C-command relationships instead
Three Principles of Binding Theory
- Principle A: Anaphors (herself, himself, each other) must be bound within TP
- Must be C-commanded by co-referent NP within same TP
- Includes reflexives (herself, himself) and reciprocals (each other)
- Principle B: Pronouns (her, him) must be free within TP
- Cannot be C-commanded by co-referent NP within same TP
- Principle C: R-expressions (proper names like Susan) must be free everywhere
- Cannot be C-commanded by co-referent NP anywhere in sentence
Locality Requirements and Complex Sentences
- Faith's question about embedded clauses: "Mary thinks Susan must like herself"
- Herself can refer to Susan but not to Mary due to locality
- Anaphors need binders close enough - within smallest TP containing them
- Pronouns show complementary distribution: "Susan thinks I like her" (where her = Susan) is fine
Cross-Linguistic Variation
- English has short-distance anaphors only
- Mandarin has both short-distance (ta-ziji) and long-distance (ziji) anaphors
- Korean has four different anaphors with varying locality requirements
- Universal: all languages have short-distance anaphors; long-distance anaphors are additional option
Evidence for PRO (Invisible Pronouns)
- Sentences like "Mary decided to leave" - how many TPs?
- Evidence for two TPs: "to" in complementary distribution with "will/should"
- Extended Projection Principle requires every TP to have specifier
- Only visible subject is Mary - where's subject of "leave"?
- Binding evidence from control constructions:
- "John promised Mary to defend himself" - himself refers to John
- "John told Mary to defend herself" - herself refers to Mary
- PRO theory explains these patterns: invisible pronoun in embedded subject position
- PRO refers to controller determined by matrix verb (subject control vs object control)
Reconstruction and Movement
- "Which picture of himself did John like best?" - grammatical despite apparent C-command violation
- After wh-movement, John doesn't C-command himself in surface position
- Reconstruction: binding evaluated at underlying position before movement
- Evidence for successive-cyclic movement from binding theory
- "Which picture of himself did John think that Mary bought?"
- If movement in one step: no binding possible (too far/no C-command)
- If successive-cyclic through intermediate CP: binding possible at intermediate position
- Binding theory provides new argument for successive-cyclic movement
Quantifier Scope and Binding Interactions (Preview)
- "Two guards seem to me to be standing in front of every building" - ambiguous
- "Two guards seem to themselves to be standing in front of every building" - unambiguous
- Themselves constrains interpretation, eliminating one scope reading
- Sets up discussion for next class on binding-scope interactions
