AI summary by TwinMind
Lecture 22: Financial Markets and Expectations
MIT OpenCourseWare
49m 49s
Banking Crisis Update
- First Republic Bank collapsed over weekend, became second largest bank collapse in US history (after Silicon Valley Bank)
- Bank liquidated and sold to JP Morgan early morning
- Lost ~$100 billion in deposits in last few days of previous week
- Similar collapse mechanism to Silicon Valley Bank: vulnerable investments to fast interest rate hikes
- Depositor panic/run caused collapse - all about expectations of what others would do
Market Volatility and Expectations
- S&P 500 movements demonstrate expectation-driven volatility:
- COVID crash: 35% decline in short period
- Policy support rally: 114% increase through end 2021
- Inflation/Fed hiking period: 25-30% decline from peak to bottom
- Recovery since October: ~16% increase
- NASDAQ shows even larger swings due to technology company concentration
- Long-term Treasury bond ETF (20+ year maturity) price movements:
- 45% increase, then 20% decline, 15% increase, then 40% decline
- Major decline caused by monetary policy tightening/rising interest rates
- Even "safe" Treasury bonds experience significant price volatility despite no default risk
Expected Present Discounted Value Concept
- Key framework for comparing present payments with future cash flows
- Three components: Expectations (E), Present value, Discounting
- Fundamental question: How to value $1 received in future vs. $1 today
- If interest rate = 10%, $1 future = ~$0.90 today (discounted by interest rate)
Present Value Mathematics
- Basic principle: With $1 today at interest rate i, can generate $(1+i) next year
- Therefore: $1 next year worth $1/(1+i) today
- Two-year discounting: $1 two years from now worth $1/[(1+i_t)(1+i_{t+1})] today
- General formula for asset paying Z_t today, Z_{t+1} next year, etc.:
- PV = Z_t + Z_{t+1}/(1+i_t) + Z_{t+2}/[(1+i_t)(1+i_{t+1})] + ...
Special Case Formulas
- Constant interest rate: Powers of (1+i) in denominators
- Constant payments: Geometric series formula applies
- Perpetuity (constant payment forever): PV = Z/i
- As interest rate approaches zero, perpetuity value approaches infinity
- This explains asset price increases during low interest rate periods
Yield Curve and Term Structure
- Yield curve plots relationship between bond maturity and yield to maturity
- Term structure of interest rates = same concept
- Example curves:
- November 2000: Steep upward sloping curve
- June 2001: Flat/inverted curve (recession, Fed cutting rates)
- Current: Very inverted (Fed hiking due to inflation)
- Fed controls short end of curve; long end reflects long-term expectations
- Steep curve typical in recession (Fed cutting short rates)
- Inverted curve typical when Fed fighting inflation (hiking short rates)
Bond Pricing Mechanics
- One-year bond paying $100: Price = $100/(1+i_{1t})
- Price inversely related to interest rate
- Two-year bond: Price = $100/[(1+i_{1t})(1+E_t i_{1,t+1})]
- Price inversely related to both current and expected future rates
Arbitrage Approach
- Alternative to expected present value: Compare similar investment strategies
- Example: $1 investment for one year
- Strategy 1: Buy one-year bond
- Strategy 2: Buy two-year bond, sell after one year
- Arbitrage condition: Both strategies must yield same expected return
- Results in same pricing formula as expected present value approach
Yield to Maturity
- Defined as constant annual interest rate making bond price equal to present discounted value
- For two-year bond: P_{2t} = $100/(1+i_{2t})^2
- Expectation hypothesis: Two-year rate ≈ average of current one-year rate and expected future one-year rate
- i_{2t} ≈ (i_{1t} + E_t i_{1,t+1})/2
Policy Implications
- US debt ceiling negotiations create systemic risk
- Treasury bonds used as pricing reference for all financial assets
- Instability in Treasury market would disrupt all financial markets
- Low interest rates increase asset values through discounting mechanism
- Monetary policy works partly through asset price channel (wealth effects)
