AI summary by TwinMind

Lecture 24: Advertising

MIT OpenCourseWare

1h 24m 43s

Course Introduction and Marketing Field Overview

  • Lecturer resuming advertising topic with gap between sessions
  • Marketing field overview: empirical-focused with many practitioners demanding ROI measurement
  • Multiple consulting firms help measure advertising effectiveness
  • Academic interest in basic economic questions: taste changes vs information provision vs signaling
  • Different welfare effects depending on advertising mechanism
  • Methodological approaches: experimental work, structural demand models, recent rise in causal inference techniques

Milyo and Waldfogel Rhode Island Liquor Study (1996)

  • Background: Rhode Island banned alcohol price advertising 1956-1996
  • Supreme Court overturned ban May 13, 1996 as free speech violation (44 Liquor Mart case)
  • Built on Benham's 1970s eyeglass study showing 20% lower prices in advertising-allowed states

Data Collection Methods

  • Manual price collection at 115 liquor stores for 33 alcoholic beverages
  • Started June 1995 (gambling on Supreme Court decision)
  • Control group: Massachusetts stores near/far from Rhode Island border
  • Creative collection techniques: memorization, voice recorders, bringing children as cover
  • Additional data: wholesale prices, print/window advertising usage, lottery ticket sales as quantity proxy

Key Findings

  • Minimal price effects: 0.5-1% average price decline after advertising allowed
  • Advertising adoption: <10% of stores chose to advertise post-ban
  • Advertised vs non-advertised prices: Advertising stores set 20% lower prices on advertised items
  • No loss-leader effect: Non-advertised prices at advertising stores unchanged or slightly lower
  • Limited competitive response: Non-advertising stores only 0.2% price reduction
  • Quantity effects: Advertising stores' lottery ticket share increased 16.4% to 18.4%
  • Pre-existing differences: Advertising stores were already 7% cheaper before ban lifted

Implications

  • Search costs for alcohol may not be major markup determinant
  • Advertising effectiveness limited in changing consumer costs
  • Small aggregate consumer welfare effects

Lewis and Riley Yahoo Advertising Experiment (2000s)

  • Company background: Yahoo had 25% of internet page views in 2000
  • Ad types: Large rectangle (LRE) ads on front page, various targeted ads on inside pages
  • Ad sales methods: Daily front page ads, demographic targeting, content targeting, retargeting

Experimental Design

  • Large offline retailer (department store-type) with 1.5M customer database
  • Matched retailer database to Yahoo user accounts
  • 80/20 treatment/control split (80% shown ads, 20% control group)
  • Intent-to-treat design: treatment group had ads bid for them, but display depended on auction outcomes

Campaign Scale and Results

  • Early fall campaign: 32M ads displayed to 814K people (average 39.6 ads per viewer)
  • Click-through rate: 0.28%
  • Ad engagement: 7.2% of viewers clicked at least one ad during campaign
  • Sales measurement: Both online and offline purchases tracked via credit card matching

Key Challenges and Findings

  • Statistical power issues: Sales standard deviation ($1,900) 10x higher than mean ($189)
  • Campaign cost 1% of sales, requiring precise estimates to measure ROI
  • Selection bias: Ad viewers were lower-value customers (pre-period sales $172 vs $181)
  • Intent-to-treat estimates: $5.30 treatment effect, $3.80 standard error (40% ROI ± 100%)
  • Difference-in-differences: $8.30 ± $5.90 effect accounting for pre-period differences
  • Long-term effects: Potential benefits extending weeks after campaign end

Methodological Lessons

  • Estimating advertising ROI extremely difficult even with massive scale
  • Viewing ads not exogenous treatment - browsing behavior correlated with purchase likelihood
  • Need tens/hundreds of millions of observations for precise estimates
  • Individual fixed effects problematic when people are "different people" at different times

Aridor, Che, and Saeedi GDPR Study (2018)

  • Regulation background: EU General Data Protection Regulation adopted April 2016, effective May 2018
  • Required explicit opt-in consent for tracking European consumers
  • Privacy vs business model tension: Targeted ads sell for orders of magnitude more than untargeted

Data and Methodology

  • Travel industry intermediary with contracts with "almost all top EU and US travel sites"
  • Company function: Machine learning algorithm predicts purchase probability, runs auctions for low-probability users
  • Clickstream data aggregated to website-country-week level
  • Treatment countries: UK, France, Germany, Italy, Spain
  • Control countries: US, Canada, Russia
  • Difference-in-differences with website, country, and time fixed effects

Key Findings

  • Consumer behavior: Most consumers accept all cookies despite privacy concerns
  • Tracking reduction: 12% drop in unique cookies, 11% drop in recorded searches
  • Selection effects: Consumers opting out were often using cookie-blocking technology (fewer "first-time" visitors)
  • Revenue impact: Initial 13.3% drop in clicks, 16% drop in revenue
  • Bid price recovery: Steady increase in auction bids over 7 weeks, offsetting ~50% of revenue loss
  • Data quality improvement: Better prediction accuracy on remaining users after algorithm adjustment

Economic Implications

  • GDPR removes consumers who don't want tracking and those obfuscating data
  • Remaining users more valuable and easier to predict
  • Demonstrates potential offsetting effects of privacy regulation on business models

Shapiro Border Discontinuity Study: Antidepressant Advertising (1999-2003)

  • Background: SSRI antidepressants under patent protection, TV advertising began 1999 after FDA rule changes
  • Previous restriction: No prescription drug TV ads in US before 1997

Data and Identification Strategy

  • Prescription data: 5% random sample of physicians prescribing antidepressants with exact office addresses
  • Advertising data: TV expenditures by brand across 101 US markets (DMAs), September 1999-December 2003
  • Border design: Analysis limited to counties along DMA borders to ensure similar populations
  • Fixed effects: product-border-quarter and product-border-DMA to control for unobserved heterogeneity

Key Results

  • Own advertising effects: 1 cent per person spending increases sales 2.4%
  • Spillover effects: Rival advertising increases own sales by 1.6% (2/3 of own effect)
  • Decreasing returns: Quadratic terms negative, optimal advertising levels above observed
  • Strategic interactions: Marginal return to advertising decreases when rivals advertise more

Structural Model Results

  • Three-level nested logit: Inside/outside good choice, category choice, brand choice within category
  • Advertising persistence: Effects die out quickly - 90% gone within 3 months at brand level, 6 months at aggregate level
  • Spillover magnitudes: Other firms gain 2.5-5.5x more prescriptions than advertiser from single campaign
  • Optimization analysis: Firms advertising 4x less than optimal level in early period
  • Cooperative potential: Industry cooperative would advertise 10x current levels, increase profits 15%

Economic Insights

  • Substantial positive spillovers create free-rider problems
  • Firms greatly under-advertise relative to collective interest
  • New advertising medium leads to learning period before optimal strategies

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome