AI summary by TwinMind

Lecture 25: Language Acquisition

MIT OpenCourseWare

58m 15s

Review of Binding Theory and Pronoun Reference

  • Reviewed semester opening examples: "Who did Biden ask to see him?" vs "Why did Biden ask to see him?"
    • First example: "him" can refer to Biden (outside bracketed domain)
    • Second example: "him" cannot refer to Biden due to PRO binding
  • Student Faith noted wh-movement from islands concern - professor confirmed students now "warped" by syntax training
  • Explained complex pronoun reference patterns through:
    • Wh-movement of "who" from object position of "ask"
    • Null PRO subjects in infinitival clauses
    • Object control vs subject control with verb "ask"
    • Principle B: pronouns must be free in local domain

Plato's Problem in Language Acquisition

  • Central question: How do children acquire complex grammatical knowledge without explicit instruction?
  • Evidence against parental teaching:
    • Actual parent-child dialogue examples showing parents focus on truth, not grammar
    • "Mama isn't a boy he a girl" / "That's right" - mother ignores pronoun error
    • Failed correction attempts: "nobody don't like me" dialogue repeated 6 times unsuccessfully
    • "Give me other one spoon" correction attempts fail despite word-by-word instruction
  • Universal Grammar hypothesis:
    • Humans preset to build languages in certain ways
    • Need data to determine which specific language being learned
    • Core grammatical principles (Control, PRO, Principle B) are universal defaults

Critical Period Evidence

  • Anecdotal evidence: Adults struggle with second language acquisition compared to childhood ease
  • Case studies of language deprivation:

Genie Case (discovered LA 1970)

  • Isolated first 13 years: strapped to chair, punished for sounds, no linguistic input
  • Father paranoid schizophrenic who hated noise
  • One sibling died from exposure in garage
  • After rescue: learned individual words but never grammar/sentence structure
  • Scored normal intelligence on tests but never developed syntactic abilities

Chelsea Case (Northern California)

  • Parents believed she was developmentally disabled
  • Actually profoundly deaf - discovered at age 12-13
  • No exposure to spoken language or sign language
  • After cochlear implants: learned words but not sentence construction
  • Happier case than Genie (loving parents, no abuse)
  • Now better screening prevents such cases

Counter-evidence: Hyperpolyglots

  • Ken Hale example: MIT professor who learned languages extremely rapidly
  • Spent 1960s in Australia learning Aboriginal languages
  • Could become fluent in one week
  • Some communities complained later linguists were "slow" compared to Hale

Experimental Methods in Language Acquisition Research

Sucking Rate Tasks

  • Infants suck rapidly initially, then slow down
  • Speed increases when presented with novel/interesting stimuli
  • Japanese infants distinguish R vs L sounds (adults cannot)
  • English infants distinguish aspirated vs unaspirated stops
  • 50 millisecond cutoff for aspiration distinction
  • Theory: babies born ready to distinguish all possible sound contrasts, then lose unused distinctions

Speech Segmentation Research

  • Children make segmentation errors: "I am being have" (from "behave"), "your Amy" (from "Miami")
  • Use statistical learning for word boundaries
  • Saffran et al. (1996) experiment with artificial CV.CV.CV words
  • Children learned transitional probabilities quickly (e.g., if hear "to" expect "la" next)
  • Performance varies with syllable number and prosodic cues
  • Result: 13,000 words by age 6 (6-7 words/day learning rate)

Syntactic Development Patterns

Japanese Child Phonology (3;2 years old)

  • Changed K→T in all contexts (mikang→mitang, poketto→potetto)
  • BUT maintained adult Japanese T-allomorphy rules:
    • T→tsu before /u/ (matsu not *matu)
    • T→chi before /e/ (machi not *mati)
  • K-derived T did NOT undergo allomorphy (aki→ati not *achi)
  • Shows underlying K/T distinction despite surface neutralization

Root Infinitive Stage

  • Common cross-linguistically (Danish, Dutch, French, German)
  • Children use infinitive verbs in main clauses where adults require finite verbs
  • German example: V2 vs verb-final positioning
    • Finite verbs correctly placed in second position
    • Infinitive verbs correctly placed clause-finally
  • Andreas (German 2-year-old): 281 utterances analyzed
    • Finite verbs mostly V2 position
    • Infinitives mostly clause-final position
  • Children confused about infinitive licensing but not verb placement rules

Experimental Methods: Truth Value Judgment Tasks

  • Puppet methodology: easier for children to correct puppet than adult
  • Quantifier interpretation differences between adults and children
  • "Every rabbit is riding an elephant" experiment:
    • Picture: 3 elephants, 2 rabbits (rabbits on 2 elephants)
    • Adults: "Yes" (every rabbit is indeed riding)
    • Children: "No" (point to elephant without rabbit)
  • Children appear to have bidirectional quantifier interpretation
  • Active research area investigating quantifier acquisition patterns

Research Methods Summary

  • Naturalistic recordings: CHILDES database of transcribed child speech
  • Consultant work with children (like field work but with cookies and crying)
  • MIT lab conducts this research, seeks volunteers
  • Undergraduate language acquisition course available

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome