AI summary by TwinMind

Lecture 26: Control, Part 3

MIT OpenCourseWare

51m 16s

Control Design Overview and Example Setup

  • Presenter introducing control design tradeoffs for general converter example
  • Garden variety boost converter example (not extreme in any dimension)
  • Circuit components:
    • Input voltage U, inductor L, switch (modulating with q(t)), diode, output capacitor C, resistive load R
    • Output voltage V across load
  • Example parameters chosen:
    • L = 10 microhenries
    • C = 50 microfarads
    • Switching frequency = 100 kHz (pretty low)
    • Output reference Vref = 24 volts (fixed)
    • Nominal input voltage = 9V, range: 8V < U < 10V (narrow 25% range)
    • Load resistance range: 2Ω < R < 10Ω (5:1 power range, heavy to light load)

State Space Modeling Progression

  • Started with switched equations of state:
    • dIL/dt = U/L * q + (U-V)/L * (1-q)
    • dV/dt = -1/(RC) * V + (1/C) * IL * (1-q)
  • Applied state space averaging to remove switching ripple:
    • Average model eliminates switching function, uses duty ratio D
    • dIL_bar/dt = (1/L) * U - (1/L) * V_bar * D'
    • dV_bar/dt = -(1/RC) * V_bar + (1/C) * IL_bar * D'
    • Where D' = (1-D)
  • Average model captures low frequency dynamics, kills ripple
  • Nonlinear due to products of duty cycle with state variables

Linearization Process

  • Linearized around operating point for small signal analysis
  • Perturbation variables: I_tilde, V_tilde, D_tilde (deviations from DC steady state)
  • Linear constant coefficient differential equations:
    • dI_tilde/dt = (1/L) * U_tilde - (D'/L) * V_tilde + (V/L) * D_tilde
    • dV_tilde/dt = -(1/RC) * V_tilde + (D'/C) * I_tilde - (I/C) * D_tilde
  • Constants depend on operating point (load current, input voltage, duty ratio)
  • Valid for limited range but surprisingly good for switching converters

Transfer Function Derivation

  • Laplace transform of linearized equations
  • Transfer function H(s) = V_tilde(s)/D_tilde(s) with U_tilde = 0:
    • H(s) = [-s * V/(RCD') + VD'/(LC)] / [s² + (1/RC)*s + D'²/LC]
  • Second order system with right half plane zero and complex pole pair

Pole-Zero Analysis and Stability Challenges

  • Right half plane zero location: s = V/(RC*D')
  • Complex pole pair in left half plane (lightly damped)
  • Pole locations depend on operating point (D' squared term)
  • Right half plane zeros problematic for control:
    • Poles move toward zeros as gain increases
    • Can easily cause instability
    • Physical behavior: output initially moves wrong direction before settling

Physical Explanation of Right Half Plane Zero

  • When duty ratio increases to raise output voltage:
    • Initially less current feeds output (more time to ground)
    • Output voltage droops temporarily
    • Eventually inductor current builds up and output rises
  • Mathematical model reflects actual converter physics
  • Not artifact of modeling - intrinsic system behavior

Control Design Approaches

  • Proportional controller (GC(s) = KP):
    • Root locus shows poles move toward right half plane zero
    • Limited gain before instability
    • High steady state error with low gains
  • Integral controller (GC(s) = KI/s):
    • Zero steady state error capability
    • Still limited by right half plane zero
    • Can achieve stability with careful gain selection

Operating Point Variation Effects

  • Transfer function poles and zeros vary with:
    • Load resistance R (affects damping - larger R = less damped)
    • Input voltage (changes duty ratio D')
  • Design challenge: single compensator must work across all operating conditions
  • Poles move closer to jω axis as R increases (less damping)

Closed Loop Analysis with Integral Control

  • KI = 5 example across load range
  • Heavy load (2Ω): reasonably damped response
  • Light load (10Ω): very lightly damped poles
  • All operating points stable (poles in left half plane)
  • Gain margin = 17 dB, phase margin ≈ 90° at worst case

Load Step Response Analysis

  • Light to heavy load step: acceptable settling behavior
  • Heavy to light load step: problematic response
    • Large voltage overshoot (energy from inductor dumps into capacitor)
    • Converter enters discontinuous conduction mode temporarily
    • Highly oscillatory response despite good stability margins
  • Average model accuracy remains good even for large transients

Control Performance vs Stability Metrics

  • Classical stability metrics (gain/phase margins) indicate very stable system
  • Actual response shows unacceptable oscillatory behavior
  • Lightly damped poles cause persistent voltage ripple (10-30mV on 24V output)
  • Application dependent: instrumentation vs resistive loads
  • Need to consider pole damping, not just stability

Design Improvement Strategies

  • Plant modification approaches:
    • Larger output capacitor for energy absorption
    • Damping networks (RC snubber across output)
    • Component value optimization for better damping
  • Control modification approaches:
    • Current mode control (full state feedback)
    • Monitor both inductor current and output voltage
    • Improves pole placement and damping

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome