AI summary by TwinMind
Lecture 34: Soft Switching, Part 2
MIT OpenCourseWare
50m 53s
Soft Switching Fundamentals Review
- Soft switching concepts: Zero Voltage Switching (ZVS) and Zero Current Switching (ZCS)
- Switch transitions: turn-off and turn-on operations
- Turn-off transition: switch current falls from max to zero in finite time
- Hard switching: voltage rises then current falls
- Soft switching: delay voltage rise using capacitor across device
- ZVS turn-on: make voltage zero before turning switch on
- Best for high frequency designs
- Addresses switch capacitance discharge issues
- ZCS turn-on: delay current rise using series inductor
- Inductor takes up voltage during turn-on
- ZCS turn-off: ensure current is zero before turning switch off
Benefits of Soft Switching
- Reduced switching loss (P_switching decreases)
- Enable higher switching frequency with smaller components
- Improve efficiency or combination thereof
- Reduced EMI through lower dV/dt slopes
- Smoother waveforms vs sharp square wave transitions
- Easier filtering requirements
EMI Analysis - Square Wave vs Soft Switching
- Square wave current/voltage waveforms generate high frequency content
- Fourier analysis of trapezoidal waveforms:
- Magnitude: 2ID*sin(nπD)/(πnD) * sin(nπt_rise/T)/(nπt_rise/T)
- Two sync functions: duty ratio and rise time percentage
- Square wave (instantaneous transitions):
- Constant amplitude at low frequencies
- Falls off as 1/f (20 dB/decade) at high frequencies
- Trapezoidal wave (finite rise time):
- Additional 20 dB/decade rolloff at higher frequencies
- Significantly reduced high frequency content
- Experimental verification: 100 μs period (10 kHz) waveforms
- 40 ns rise time → some high frequency reduction
- 360 ns rise time (3.6%) → significant high frequency reduction
- 10% rise time → major high frequency content elimination
Device Matching and Implementation Categories
- Soft switching technique must match semiconductor device characteristics
- Some devices don't work well with ZVS
- Circuit implementation depends on:
- Voltage range requirements
- Power range requirements
- Application constraints
- Two broad implementation categories:
- Whole circuit designed around soft switching requirements
- Auxiliary circuits added to standard PWM converters
Resonant Pole Inverter (Category 1 - Integrated Design)
- DC-AC converter with split DC bus (±VDC/2)
- Capacitors across each switch for ZVS operation
- Hysteretic current control operation:
- Turn on S1, ramp inductor current to +I_peak
- Turn off S1 (ZVS), voltage rings down, bottom diode conducts
- Turn on S2 (ZVS), ramp inductor current to -I_peak
- Turn off S2 (ZVS), voltage rings up, top diode conducts
- Requirements for proper operation:
- Minimum positive current needed to ring voltage down
- Minimum negative current needed to ring voltage up
- Both currents are functions of capacitor voltage VCF
- Average output current = average of peak positive and negative currents
- Characteristics:
- Variable switching frequency
- Variable duty ratio
- High ripple current requirement
- Very constrained control (can't do harmonic elimination PWM)
- Compact and efficient design
Auxiliary Resonant Commutated Pole (ARCP) Inverter (Category 2 - Auxiliary Circuit)
- Standard PWM inverter with auxiliary soft switching circuit
- Main devices: capacitors across switches for ZVS
- Auxiliary circuit: resonant inductor LR + bidirectional switch for ZCS
- Invented early 1990s by Rick Divan at GE (extension of McMurray snubber)
- Operation principle:
- Auxiliary circuit operates transiently during main switch transitions
- Can transition between any main switch states regardless of load current
- Complex control but maintains PWM flexibility
- Example transition sequence (bottom diode to top switch):
- Close auxiliary switch at zero current
- Current ramps up in resonant inductor
- Turn on bottom switch at zero voltage
- Turn off bottom switch, voltage rings with capacitors
- Top diode conducts, turn on top switch at zero voltage
- Wait for auxiliary current to return to zero
- Auxiliary switch opens at zero current
- Benefits:
- Reduced switching loss in main devices
- Reduced dV/dt for lower EMI
- Maintains full PWM control capability
- Suitable for motor drives and complex control schemes
Applications and Performance
- High power motor drives demonstrated
- Laptop adapter power supplies use resonant converter techniques
- Next topic: Resonant converters as subset of soft switching converters
