AI summary by TwinMind

Lecture 5: Limits of Technologies

MIT OpenCourseWare

1h 0m 57s

Introduction to Technology Limitations

  • Following Zach's enthusiastic microwave technology talk from 1-2 weeks ago
  • New technologies initially generate optimism that all problems will be solved within years
    • Reasons: need investors, public funding
    • Eventually realistic expectations emerge requiring consideration of actual limitations
  • Science aims to make predictions about systems
    • Limitations affect predictive power in terms of accuracy, sensitivity, completeness

Noise Definition and Characteristics

  • Noise defined as irrelevant/meaningless data occurring with desired information (Webster definition)
  • Noise not always bad - can be important signal
    • Cosmic background radiation discovery: two radio astronomers 50 years ago found "noise" from all directions, won Nobel Prize
    • Cisplatin discovery: platinum electrodes created unexpected cell effects, led to chemotherapeutic agent
  • Biological noise examples:
    • Mutations crucial for evolution
    • "Junk DNA" in genome sequencing - unknown function but may determine spatial gene distances
    • Asymmetric cell division during differentiation - RNA/proteins distributed by chance between daughter cells
    • Stochastic fluctuations important for complex system stability

Stochasticity in Biological Systems

  • Genetic networks are stochastic systems
    • Few hundred transcription factor copies per nucleus (sometimes only 50)
    • Intracellular environment not free solution
    • Slow reaction kinetics
  • Experimental evidence from E. coli study (2 years ago, similar in yeast):
    • Two proteins under same promoter with different fluorescent tags
    • Expected same expression ratio if deterministic
    • Found variable ratios (red, green, yellow cells) due to stochasticity
  • Population average measurements add noise
    • Grind millions/thousands of cells for genomics/proteomics
    • Even single cell measurements interfere with/kill cells
    • End up with population averages again

Measurement Accuracy and Statistics

  • No measurement without noise - accuracy/sensitivity limitations expected
  • Triplicates with identical numbers indicate systematic error (photometer miscalibration)
  • Continuous variables expected to have spread around true value
  • Statistics invented for biological measurements, addresses:
    • True parameter values
    • Bayesian analysis (most frequent in biology) - updating beliefs through repeated experiments
    • Normalization to correct systematic errors
    • Pattern recognition in large datasets to avoid chance correlations

Microarray Measurement Noise Sources

Affymetrix Chip Process

  • Tissue → RNA extraction → RT (reverse transcriptase) → cDNA/cRNA production → hybridization
  • RT step limitations:
    • Stochastic initiation requiring primer
    • Enzyme drops off during transcription
    • Stronger signal from 3' end than 5' end
    • Uses poly-A tail as initiator (random primers for bacteria)
  • cRNA production issues:
    • Dye incorporation not linear
    • Different transcription efficiencies for different messages
    • cRNA fragmentation not uniform
    • Cross-hybridization problems

Two-Color Microarray Issues

  • Equal amounts of labeled cDNA samples mixed
  • Ratio measurements problematic:
    • No truly blank spots - background noise creates false signals
    • Complete down-regulation appears as ~100-fold change instead of infinite
    • Signal compression from -infinity to +infinity range caught at ±100-fold

Affymetrix Probe Design Problems

  • 25 base pair probes, 11-16 probes per gene
  • Expected: all probes for same gene show equal intensity
  • Reality: 4-5 orders of magnitude variation between probes for same gene
    • Due to cRNA secondary structure, other factors
    • Must estimate true expression from highly variable probe set

Normalization Approaches

Systematic Error Correction

  • Intensity distribution analysis across samples
  • Assumption: most measurements should have similar distributions
  • One outlier sample suggests systematic error (dye incorporation, reader miscalibration)
  • Solution: shift curves to same mean/median, renormalize all numbers
  • Two methods:
    • Assume most things don't change
    • Use error model (additive at low concentrations, multiplicative at high)

Two-Color Array Normalization

  • Red vs green ratios shouldn't show intensity dependence
  • Reality: curved relationship due to different dye incorporation efficiencies
  • Correction: straighten curve assuming equal red/green incorporation
  • Can use housekeeping genes (shaky concept) or special control genes
  • Normalization functions: global mean/median or more complex approaches

Noise Impact on Information Content

  • Reliable detection limit: 2-fold differences (optimistic, non-cross-platform)
  • Time series experiment design considerations:
    • Yeast: no point measuring more often than 5-10 minutes
    • Mammalian cells: 15-30 minute intervals
    • More frequent measurements just capture noise

Sensitivity and Completeness Issues

Network Size Estimates

  • ~5,000 proteins in yeast interaction network
  • Conservative estimate: few hundred thousand bionodes per cell
    • 10-20,000 genes × <10 post-translational modifications
  • Current technology far from complete coverage

Dynamic Range Problems

  • Holland's yeast study (few years ago):
    • Gene expression over 6 orders of magnitude (0.01 to >10,000 copies/cell)
    • Microarray correlation with RT-PCR only starts at 2 copies/cell
    • Many important genes (transcription factors) below microarray sensitivity
    • Entire low-expression range invisible to microarray

Inherent Predictive Limitations

Chaos Theory Example

  • Edward Lorenz at MIT (1960s) - weather prediction with deterministic differential equations
  • Small initial condition changes → completely different outcomes
  • Even perfect measurements may not enable prediction due to sensitivity to initial conditions
  • Biology robust (we're sitting here talking) - likely at edge between deterministic and chaotic

Statistical Analysis Challenges

  • Cancer gene example: finding consistently misregulated genes across samples
  • Combinatorics problem: 6 cell lines, 13 consistently misregulated genes
  • Gene co-regulation destroys independence assumption
  • Permutation analysis must preserve correlation structure
  • Statistical confidence can differ by 5-6 orders of magnitude depending on method

Discrete Measurement Noise (DNA Sequencing)

Basic Sequencing Issues

  • 0.1% error rate (previously higher)
  • Single vs multiple individual sequencing for SNP vs error determination
  • Solution: sequence extensively to determine true sequence

Gene Finding Challenges

  • 3 billion base pairs in human genome
  • Must find genes, introns, exons, transcription factor binding sites in "sea of letters"
  • Problem: abundant "junk DNA" or intergenic regions
  • False positives appear by chance in non-coding regions
  • Gene prediction algorithms tend toward liberal side (overpredict)
  • Require cDNA libraries for validation, but only expressed genes captured

Unexpected Biological Complexity

  • 1,600 antisense transcription units in human genome (much higher than expected)
  • Chromosome 21/22 transcription analysis: ~10× more transcription than expected based on exons
  • Cannot predict from primary sequence alone

Transcription Factor Binding Site Discovery

  • Looking for sequences like TGGACT (variable: TGCACT, etc.)
  • Constraints help: within 500 bp of start codon, tend to cluster
  • Still very weak signal in noisy background
  • Many obvious binding sequences don't function (higher-order DNA organization)

Cross-Species Conservation Solution

  • Combine information from multiple species (human, chimp, mouse, rat, yeast)
  • Assumption: important sequences conserved across species
  • Alexander's group yeast study: 4 closely related species
    • High synteny (same gene, same location)
    • 100% nucleotide conservation for important genes
    • Variable conservation for others
  • Method: generate all random sequences (XYZ with 0-21 random bases between)
  • Statistical significance tests:
    • Intergenic vs genic conservation
    • Upstream vs downstream conservation
  • Conserved sequences found in front of functionally related genes
  • Many computationally predicted sites confirmed experimentally

Key Conclusions

  • Important biological information hidden in sea of irrelevant information
  • Computational approaches alone usually insufficient
  • Cross-species conservation provides crucial biological context
  • "Gold nuggets" emerge when combining computational and biological approaches
  • Biological organisms built long ago - blueprints lost, everything experimental

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome