AI summary by TwinMind
Lecture 6: IS-LM, continued
MIT OpenCourseWare
50m 35s
IS-LM Model Foundation
- IS curve represents equilibrium in goods market
- Combinations of output and interest rate consistent with goods market equilibrium
- Investment now function of both output (positive) and interest rate (negative)
- Downward sloping: higher interest rate → lower investment → lower output via multiplier
- LM curve represents equilibrium in financial markets
- Modern LM is horizontal: central bank sets interest rate directly
- Only central bank policy shifts modern LM curve
- Abandoned money supply targeting in favor of interest rate targeting
Policy Analysis Framework
- Movement along curves vs shifts:
- Fiscal policy shifts IS curve (taxes, government expenditure)
- Monetary policy shifts LM curve (interest rate changes)
- Movement along IS occurs when only interest rate changes
- Movement along LM occurs when only output changes
Contractionary Fiscal Policy Effects
- Increase taxes or reduce government expenditure
- Shifts IS curve left
- Results in lower equilibrium output at same interest rate
- Multiplier amplifies initial decline in aggregate demand
- Other contractionary shocks: consumer confidence decline, wealth reduction
Expansionary Monetary Policy Mechanism
- Central bank cuts interest rate (shifts LM down)
- Lower interest rate increases investment
- Creates disequilibrium: aggregate demand > output
- Output rises via multiplier process
- Fed must continuously expand money supply to maintain lower rate as output grows
- Implementation: expansionary open market operations
Policy Mix Scenarios
"All In" Policy (Recession Response)
- Both expansionary fiscal and monetary policy
- Maximum output increase
- Used during deep recessions when single tool insufficient
- Allows targeting specific groups (fiscal) while providing broad stimulus (monetary)
Fiscal Consolidation with Monetary Accommodation
- Contractionary fiscal policy (reduce deficit/debt)
- Expansionary monetary policy (offset recession risk)
- Used when fiscal accounts weak but economy not overheating
- Central bank naturally responds to prevent unnecessary recession
Conflicting Policies
- Fiscal expansion with monetary contraction
- Occurs when fiscal stimulus applied during overheating
- Example: US 2021 fiscal expansion without Fed response led to inflation
- Fed "behind the curve" - should have raised rates to offset fiscal stimulus
Zero Lower Bound and Unconventional Policy
Liquidity Trap
- Occurs when nominal interest rate reaches zero
- No opportunity cost to holding money vs bonds
- Conventional monetary policy loses effectiveness
- Japan's chronic problem since late 1980s financial bubble
Unconventional Monetary Policy
- Quantitative Easing (QE): buying long-term bonds
- Fed balance sheet expansion from ~$1T to $9T during COVID
- Purchased mortgage-backed securities, corporate bonds, "fallen angel" bonds
- Created facilities for various asset purchases
- All major central banks (ECB, Bank of Japan) implemented similar policies
COVID-19 Policy Response
Monetary Response
- Fed immediately cut rates to zero (effective zero lower bound)
- Massive unconventional policy expansion
- Balance sheet grew dramatically through asset purchases
Fiscal Response
- Massive fiscal expansion ~20% of GDP in US
- Comparable across countries globally
- Scale comparable to wartime spending
- Largest peacetime fiscal expansion in modern history
Empirical Evidence and Timing
- Monetary policy works with "long and variable lags"
- Output response takes several quarters to fully materialize
- Employment effects build slowly over time
- Price level adjustment takes longest
- Current Fed challenge: already implemented significant tightening but full effects not yet felt
- Unemployment currently low but may rise as policy effects transmit
