AI summary by TwinMind

Lecture 7: A Political History of Gravity

MIT OpenCourseWare

1h 19m 34s

Einstein's Path to General Relativity (1907-1915)

  • Einstein worked nearly 10 years between special relativity (1905) and general relativity (November 25, 1915)
  • Started in 1907 when Johannes Stark invited him to write review article on relativity
  • The Happiest Thought: Observed window washer falling from scaffolding - everything fell at same rate, suggesting acceleration cancels gravity effects
  • Developed equivalence principle: gravity and acceleration interchangeable
  • Thought experiments with elevators:
    • Person at rest in elevator vs. elevator in free fall
    • Person in accelerating spaceship vs. spaceship at rest in space
    • Only two phenomena: ball hits floor or doesn't
  • Light bending prediction from equivalence principle:
    • Light beam enters accelerating spaceship at top, exits at bottom
    • If acceleration = gravity, then gravity must bend light
    • Light maps shortest distances, so bent light = curved spacetime

Mathematical Development and Collaboration

  • Einstein cut most math courses as student, borrowed notes from girlfriend (later wife) and Marcel Grossman
  • By 1912, hired back to Zurich where Grossman taught mathematics
  • Grossman tutored Einstein in non-euclidean geometry (1912-1913)
    • Geometry on curved surfaces (spheres, hyperbolic surfaces)
    • Parallel lines converge, triangle angles sum >180°
  • Einstein moved to Berlin, continued work alone using Grossman's techniques
  • November 25, 1915: Presented field equations at Prussian Academy of Sciences
  • Field Equations: R_μν - ½gR = 8πT_μν
    • Left side: curvature of spacetime (learned from Grossman)
    • Right side: distribution of matter and energy
  • "Matter tells spacetime how to curve, curved spacetime tells matter how to move" - John Wheeler

Wartime Spread of Relativity Knowledge (1914-1919)

Eastward Transmission

  • Vsevolod Fredericks (Russian mathematician):
    • Working with David Hilbert in Göttingen when war broke out
    • Einstein visited Hilbert multiple times, befriended Fredericks
    • Fredericks detained as civilian prisoner (Russian in Germany)
    • Released after war, returned to Petrograd/Leningrad
    • Taught first relativity classes in Russia, trained Friedman, Gamow, Landau
  • Carl Schwarzschild:
    • Astronomer/mathematical physicist, learned relativity directly from Einstein
    • Age 40, volunteered for infantry, sent to Russian front
    • Derived first exact solution to Einstein's field equations while fighting
    • Schwarzschild solution: spacetime curvature around spherical mass
    • Died weeks after submitting paper from rare skin disease
  • Erwin Freundlich:
    • Young astronomer in Berlin, Einstein's informal assistant
    • Planned eclipse expedition to measure light bending (August 1914, Crimea)
    • Team captured as prisoners of war when Germany/Russia declared war
    • Equipment confiscated, observation impossible

Westward Transmission

  • Paul Ehrenfest (Netherlands):
    • Einstein made multiple trips to neutral Netherlands during war
    • Met Willem de Sitter in Leiden through Ehrenfest
    • De Sitter learned relativity directly from Einstein
  • Arthur Eddington (England):
    • Mathematical physicist/astronomer, Cambridge Wrangler
    • No direct contact with Einstein due to war blockade
    • Learned relativity through correspondence course from de Sitter
    • Conscientious objector (Quaker), faced jail or dangerous ambulance duty
    • Saved by Frank Dyson's arrangement: wartime service = eclipse expedition preparation

1919 Eclipse Expeditions

  • Next total eclipse: May 29, 1919
  • Path of totality: West Africa to Brazil
  • Two teams: Principe Island (off Morocco) and Sobral, Brazil
  • War ended November 11, 1918, but travel still difficult
  • Expeditions successful despite equipment problems:
    • Brazil team: larger telescope warped by heat, used smaller backup
    • Principe team: clouds, but got usable data
  • Data analysis took 6 months in London/Cambridge

November 1919 Announcement and Global Fame

  • November 6, 1919: Joint meeting Royal Society & Royal Astronomical Society
  • Eddington announced: "Einstein was right"
  • New York Times headline: "Lights All Askew in the Heavens, Men of Science More or Less Agog"
  • Einstein becomes worldwide celebrity, not just scientific figure
  • World tours, meets Charlie Chaplin, parades in New York
  • Einstein's comment: "Today I'm described in Germany as German savant, in England as Swiss Jew... this is yet another application of theory of relativity"

Rise of Deutsche Physik Movement (1920)

  • Spring 1920: Political rallies denouncing general relativity
  • Johannes Stark and Philipp Lenard (both Nobel laureates) led movement
  • Two-pronged attack:
    1. Einstein's work "disgusting" to Aryan sensibility
      • Force concept comes from manual labor, working the land
      • Only "cosmopolitan Jew" would dispense with force
    2. Key results plagiarized from Aryan scientists
      • Johann Soldner (1803) calculated light bending using Newton's gravity
      • Result was exactly half Einstein's value (didn't match eclipse data)
  • Lenard's book "Great Men of Science" included racial physiognomy
  • Portraits of Newton showing "proper Aryan facial features"
  • Early proto-Nazi movement using Einstein as political target

Technical Details and Controversies

  • Einstein initially convinced no exact solutions possible (highly non-linear equations)
  • Schwarzschild's exact solution surprised Einstein
  • 1912-1913: Einstein's predictions off by factor of 2
  • If 1914 eclipse had succeeded, wouldn't have matched Einstein's then-current theory
  • 1919 data analysis: Frank Dyson discarded warped telescope data from Brazil
  • Later controversy over data selection, but Dan Kennefick's analysis shows proper scientific procedure
  • Modern consensus: 1919 results legitimate confirmation of general relativity

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome