AI summary by TwinMind
Lecture 7: A Political History of Gravity
MIT OpenCourseWare
1h 19m 34s
Einstein's Path to General Relativity (1907-1915)
- Einstein worked nearly 10 years between special relativity (1905) and general relativity (November 25, 1915)
- Started in 1907 when Johannes Stark invited him to write review article on relativity
- The Happiest Thought: Observed window washer falling from scaffolding - everything fell at same rate, suggesting acceleration cancels gravity effects
- Developed equivalence principle: gravity and acceleration interchangeable
- Thought experiments with elevators:
- Person at rest in elevator vs. elevator in free fall
- Person in accelerating spaceship vs. spaceship at rest in space
- Only two phenomena: ball hits floor or doesn't
- Light bending prediction from equivalence principle:
- Light beam enters accelerating spaceship at top, exits at bottom
- If acceleration = gravity, then gravity must bend light
- Light maps shortest distances, so bent light = curved spacetime
Mathematical Development and Collaboration
- Einstein cut most math courses as student, borrowed notes from girlfriend (later wife) and Marcel Grossman
- By 1912, hired back to Zurich where Grossman taught mathematics
- Grossman tutored Einstein in non-euclidean geometry (1912-1913)
- Geometry on curved surfaces (spheres, hyperbolic surfaces)
- Parallel lines converge, triangle angles sum >180°
- Einstein moved to Berlin, continued work alone using Grossman's techniques
- November 25, 1915: Presented field equations at Prussian Academy of Sciences
- Field Equations: R_μν - ½gR = 8πT_μν
- Left side: curvature of spacetime (learned from Grossman)
- Right side: distribution of matter and energy
- "Matter tells spacetime how to curve, curved spacetime tells matter how to move" - John Wheeler
Wartime Spread of Relativity Knowledge (1914-1919)
Eastward Transmission
- Vsevolod Fredericks (Russian mathematician):
- Working with David Hilbert in Göttingen when war broke out
- Einstein visited Hilbert multiple times, befriended Fredericks
- Fredericks detained as civilian prisoner (Russian in Germany)
- Released after war, returned to Petrograd/Leningrad
- Taught first relativity classes in Russia, trained Friedman, Gamow, Landau
- Carl Schwarzschild:
- Astronomer/mathematical physicist, learned relativity directly from Einstein
- Age 40, volunteered for infantry, sent to Russian front
- Derived first exact solution to Einstein's field equations while fighting
- Schwarzschild solution: spacetime curvature around spherical mass
- Died weeks after submitting paper from rare skin disease
- Erwin Freundlich:
- Young astronomer in Berlin, Einstein's informal assistant
- Planned eclipse expedition to measure light bending (August 1914, Crimea)
- Team captured as prisoners of war when Germany/Russia declared war
- Equipment confiscated, observation impossible
Westward Transmission
- Paul Ehrenfest (Netherlands):
- Einstein made multiple trips to neutral Netherlands during war
- Met Willem de Sitter in Leiden through Ehrenfest
- De Sitter learned relativity directly from Einstein
- Arthur Eddington (England):
- Mathematical physicist/astronomer, Cambridge Wrangler
- No direct contact with Einstein due to war blockade
- Learned relativity through correspondence course from de Sitter
- Conscientious objector (Quaker), faced jail or dangerous ambulance duty
- Saved by Frank Dyson's arrangement: wartime service = eclipse expedition preparation
1919 Eclipse Expeditions
- Next total eclipse: May 29, 1919
- Path of totality: West Africa to Brazil
- Two teams: Principe Island (off Morocco) and Sobral, Brazil
- War ended November 11, 1918, but travel still difficult
- Expeditions successful despite equipment problems:
- Brazil team: larger telescope warped by heat, used smaller backup
- Principe team: clouds, but got usable data
- Data analysis took 6 months in London/Cambridge
November 1919 Announcement and Global Fame
- November 6, 1919: Joint meeting Royal Society & Royal Astronomical Society
- Eddington announced: "Einstein was right"
- New York Times headline: "Lights All Askew in the Heavens, Men of Science More or Less Agog"
- Einstein becomes worldwide celebrity, not just scientific figure
- World tours, meets Charlie Chaplin, parades in New York
- Einstein's comment: "Today I'm described in Germany as German savant, in England as Swiss Jew... this is yet another application of theory of relativity"
Rise of Deutsche Physik Movement (1920)
- Spring 1920: Political rallies denouncing general relativity
- Johannes Stark and Philipp Lenard (both Nobel laureates) led movement
- Two-pronged attack:
- Einstein's work "disgusting" to Aryan sensibility
- Force concept comes from manual labor, working the land
- Only "cosmopolitan Jew" would dispense with force
- Key results plagiarized from Aryan scientists
- Johann Soldner (1803) calculated light bending using Newton's gravity
- Result was exactly half Einstein's value (didn't match eclipse data)
- Einstein's work "disgusting" to Aryan sensibility
- Lenard's book "Great Men of Science" included racial physiognomy
- Portraits of Newton showing "proper Aryan facial features"
- Early proto-Nazi movement using Einstein as political target
Technical Details and Controversies
- Einstein initially convinced no exact solutions possible (highly non-linear equations)
- Schwarzschild's exact solution surprised Einstein
- 1912-1913: Einstein's predictions off by factor of 2
- If 1914 eclipse had succeeded, wouldn't have matched Einstein's then-current theory
- 1919 data analysis: Frank Dyson discarded warped telescope data from Brazil
- Later controversy over data selection, but Dan Kennefick's analysis shows proper scientific procedure
- Modern consensus: 1919 results legitimate confirmation of general relativity
