AI summary by TwinMind

Lecture 9: Building Energy Policies

MIT OpenCourseWare

38m 8s

Course Introduction & Policy Framework Context

  • Part of Urban Energy Systems and policy lecture series
  • Focus: cities and building energy policies as representative of Energy Efficiency efforts
  • Reference: Peter May 2003 chapter on Environmental Policy instruments
  • Policy instrument categories:
    • Command control regulation
    • Charges and special taxes (carbon taxes, sulfur dioxide abatement taxes from 1980s-90s)
    • Economic value regulation and standards
    • Incentives/subsidies (tax credits, Inflation Reduction Act)
    • Government insurance (nuclear industry heavily insured)
    • Direct government provision of services
    • Government corporations and enterprises (30% electric utilities, 60-70% water utilities government-owned)
    • Contracting and purchasing power
    • Social regulations, vouchers, tort liability
    • Public information provision (census as constitutional example)

Cities' Building Sector Powers & Opportunities

  • 2017 paper: "Further opportunities to reduce energy use and greenhouse gas emissions of buildings"
  • Cities collect 70% local tax revenue, 30% all state/local taxes
  • Own 50%+ infrastructure, do 75% infrastructure spending
  • Own ~33% electric utilities, ~67% water utilities
  • Key departments with decarbonization leverage:
    • Department of Finance (tax revenue control)
    • Law Department (policy crafting)
    • Fire Department (building codes)
    • Power, Water, Housing authorities
    • Schools (building environment improvement)

NYC Building Sector Characteristics

  • 75% of NYC greenhouse gas emissions from buildings
  • ~1 million total buildings
  • 85% of 2030 buildings already exist, 70% of 2050 buildings already exist
  • Large vs small buildings: 2% buildings >50,000 sq ft = 50% total square footage, ~48% total energy use
  • Building types: commercial, industrial, institutional, multi-family residential, mixed-use
  • Tremendous diversity even within large buildings (university campuses example)

NYC Sustainability Planning History

  • Author wrote "Sustainable New York City" as Design Trust fellow
  • 2003-2005: first internal government sustainability plans
  • 2005-2006: Plan NYC 2030 from Bloomberg Administration
  • 2011: Plan updated
  • McKinsey 2007 greenhouse gas reduction report: marginal abatement curve showed buildings dominate left side (negative cost opportunities)

Information Gap Problem

  • ~15 years ago: no data on building energy use
  • Utility tracked to meter only
  • Tenant-landlord problem: fragmented information landscape
  • Tenants often get electricity bills OR landlords get bills, but not both
  • Large commercial tenants: landlords had no sense of tenant energy costs

Greater Greener Buildings Plan - Policy Suite

  • NYC Energy Efficiency Corporation (NYCEEC) setup
  • Local Law 85 (2009): NYC energy conservation code (nycecc)
  • Local Law 88 (2009): efficient lighting and sub-metering
    • LEDs much more efficient than previous lighting
    • Sub-metering gives building control over sub-areas
    • Rewards owners already doing these things
  • Local Law 84 (2009): benchmarking and disclosure policy
    • Solved landlord-tenant problem
    • Building owners must gather tenant bills, hire consultants
    • Used EPA Energy Star rating system infrastructure
  • Local Law 87 (2009): energy audits and retro-commissioning
    • 10% buildings per year undergo energy audit
    • Retro-commissioning: tuning building performance to design intent
    • Evan Mills 2011: 600 buildings study showed ~25-28% energy savings
  • Local Law 33 (2017): letter grades for building performance (A, B, C like restaurants)
  • Local Law 97 (2019): carbon budgets for buildings (Brand New Deal package)

Policy Implementation Landscape 2009-2013

  • Building codes assistance project: DOE funded aggressive codes development
  • 2009: Green landscape map showed aggressive codes in Florida/Massachusetts
  • 2013: ~15-20 cities/states had disclosure laws but little data yet
  • NYC biggest city with largest datasets for analysis

Benchmarking Theory & Market Transformation

  • Diffusion of innovation curve: innovators (2.5%), early adopters, early majority, late majority, laggards
  • Benchmarking rewards innovators/early adopters
  • Building codes bring up laggards to minimum standards
  • Work on different sides of adoption curve
  • Market transformation heterogeneity cycle:
    • Information identifies innovators vs laggards
    • Building owners learn efficiency comparison
    • Cost-effective investments identified
    • Buyers reward efficient buildings
    • Creates virtuous cycle

Initial Data Results & Findings

  • Tremendous variation across sectors: 5.6x difference retail, 5.8x difference office buildings
  • Different consultants produced different results for same buildings
  • ~10,000 buildings >50,000 sq ft served by ~500 consultants
  • Office buildings: fewer owners, multi-family: many more diverse owners
  • Need different campaigns for different owner types

Benchmarking Law Results

  • 2017 paper findings: 12-14% energy use intensity reduction first 3 years
  • ~3-4% per year reduction (more aggressive than building codes)
  • Urban Green Council 2022: steady decrease site energy use and emissions over 10 years
  • COVID-19 impacts visible: energy decreased Manhattan, increased outer boroughs
  • ~4 million daily Manhattan commuters, some residents left during pandemic

Policy Spread & Current Status

  • 10 years ago: 5-6 cities had benchmarking laws
  • San Francisco first to pass, NYC first major implementation
  • Now: 40-50 cities have benchmarking (Institute for Market Transformation map)
  • Very popular policy spreading rapidly

2050 Carbon Reduction Analysis

  • McKinsey waterfall graph: NYC Pathways to Deep Carbon Reductions (Dec 30, 2013 - Bloomberg's last day)
  • 2050 business as usual: slight reduction from 2005 levels
  • 55.7 million metric tons CO2 equivalent savings needed for 80% by 2050
  • ~50% savings from buildings: existing building efficiency, fuel switching, new building efficiency
  • Power sector: clean power, distributed generation
  • Transportation sector savings
  • Little from solid waste
  • Goals now Net Zero by 2050 (more aggressive than original Paris Agreement 80% by 2050)

Building Sector Marginal Abatement Cost Curve

  • NYC-specific building sector analysis
  • Most interventions negative cost
  • Anything <$150/ton should be implemented (below social cost of carbon)
  • 23 of 28 total metric tons CO2 equivalent/year potential at reasonable cost
  • Residential freezers largest area (unexpected high-impact topic)

Local Law 97 (2019) - Carbon Budgets

  • Buildings >25,000 sq ft affected
  • Increasingly stringent carbon emissions limits per sq ft: 2024 and 2030
  • 2024: first marker (less aggressive), 2030: much tougher target
  • Compliance flexibility: renewable energy credits, emissions offsets
  • Cambridge considering similar but no renewable energy credits allowed
  • Affordable housing: can choose low-cost measures instead of emissions limits
  • New Office of Building Energy and Emissions Performance at DOB
  • Strong Advisory Board for refining metrics
  • Carbon trading study and implementation plan
  • Cap and trade for buildings: spend money on cost-effective upgrades across multiple buildings
  • Stringent penalties for non-compliance
  • Variances for financial hardship

Economic & Employment Analysis (2019)

  • Urban Green Council analysis with author
  • Job creation: 2024 goals ~20,000 jobs, 2030 goals ~180,000 jobs, total ~200,000 jobs
  • Workforce considered biggest obstacle to achieving carbon budgets
  • May increase building values, output, earnings
  • Policy effectiveness depends on finding sufficient workers

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome