AI summary by TwinMind
Lecture 9: Building Energy Policies
MIT OpenCourseWare
38m 8s
Course Introduction & Policy Framework Context
- Part of Urban Energy Systems and policy lecture series
- Focus: cities and building energy policies as representative of Energy Efficiency efforts
- Reference: Peter May 2003 chapter on Environmental Policy instruments
- Policy instrument categories:
- Command control regulation
- Charges and special taxes (carbon taxes, sulfur dioxide abatement taxes from 1980s-90s)
- Economic value regulation and standards
- Incentives/subsidies (tax credits, Inflation Reduction Act)
- Government insurance (nuclear industry heavily insured)
- Direct government provision of services
- Government corporations and enterprises (30% electric utilities, 60-70% water utilities government-owned)
- Contracting and purchasing power
- Social regulations, vouchers, tort liability
- Public information provision (census as constitutional example)
Cities' Building Sector Powers & Opportunities
- 2017 paper: "Further opportunities to reduce energy use and greenhouse gas emissions of buildings"
- Cities collect 70% local tax revenue, 30% all state/local taxes
- Own 50%+ infrastructure, do 75% infrastructure spending
- Own ~33% electric utilities, ~67% water utilities
- Key departments with decarbonization leverage:
- Department of Finance (tax revenue control)
- Law Department (policy crafting)
- Fire Department (building codes)
- Power, Water, Housing authorities
- Schools (building environment improvement)
NYC Building Sector Characteristics
- 75% of NYC greenhouse gas emissions from buildings
- ~1 million total buildings
- 85% of 2030 buildings already exist, 70% of 2050 buildings already exist
- Large vs small buildings: 2% buildings >50,000 sq ft = 50% total square footage, ~48% total energy use
- Building types: commercial, industrial, institutional, multi-family residential, mixed-use
- Tremendous diversity even within large buildings (university campuses example)
NYC Sustainability Planning History
- Author wrote "Sustainable New York City" as Design Trust fellow
- 2003-2005: first internal government sustainability plans
- 2005-2006: Plan NYC 2030 from Bloomberg Administration
- 2011: Plan updated
- McKinsey 2007 greenhouse gas reduction report: marginal abatement curve showed buildings dominate left side (negative cost opportunities)
Information Gap Problem
- ~15 years ago: no data on building energy use
- Utility tracked to meter only
- Tenant-landlord problem: fragmented information landscape
- Tenants often get electricity bills OR landlords get bills, but not both
- Large commercial tenants: landlords had no sense of tenant energy costs
Greater Greener Buildings Plan - Policy Suite
- NYC Energy Efficiency Corporation (NYCEEC) setup
- Local Law 85 (2009): NYC energy conservation code (nycecc)
- Local Law 88 (2009): efficient lighting and sub-metering
- LEDs much more efficient than previous lighting
- Sub-metering gives building control over sub-areas
- Rewards owners already doing these things
- Local Law 84 (2009): benchmarking and disclosure policy
- Solved landlord-tenant problem
- Building owners must gather tenant bills, hire consultants
- Used EPA Energy Star rating system infrastructure
- Local Law 87 (2009): energy audits and retro-commissioning
- 10% buildings per year undergo energy audit
- Retro-commissioning: tuning building performance to design intent
- Evan Mills 2011: 600 buildings study showed ~25-28% energy savings
- Local Law 33 (2017): letter grades for building performance (A, B, C like restaurants)
- Local Law 97 (2019): carbon budgets for buildings (Brand New Deal package)
Policy Implementation Landscape 2009-2013
- Building codes assistance project: DOE funded aggressive codes development
- 2009: Green landscape map showed aggressive codes in Florida/Massachusetts
- 2013: ~15-20 cities/states had disclosure laws but little data yet
- NYC biggest city with largest datasets for analysis
Benchmarking Theory & Market Transformation
- Diffusion of innovation curve: innovators (2.5%), early adopters, early majority, late majority, laggards
- Benchmarking rewards innovators/early adopters
- Building codes bring up laggards to minimum standards
- Work on different sides of adoption curve
- Market transformation heterogeneity cycle:
- Information identifies innovators vs laggards
- Building owners learn efficiency comparison
- Cost-effective investments identified
- Buyers reward efficient buildings
- Creates virtuous cycle
Initial Data Results & Findings
- Tremendous variation across sectors: 5.6x difference retail, 5.8x difference office buildings
- Different consultants produced different results for same buildings
- ~10,000 buildings >50,000 sq ft served by ~500 consultants
- Office buildings: fewer owners, multi-family: many more diverse owners
- Need different campaigns for different owner types
Benchmarking Law Results
- 2017 paper findings: 12-14% energy use intensity reduction first 3 years
- ~3-4% per year reduction (more aggressive than building codes)
- Urban Green Council 2022: steady decrease site energy use and emissions over 10 years
- COVID-19 impacts visible: energy decreased Manhattan, increased outer boroughs
- ~4 million daily Manhattan commuters, some residents left during pandemic
Policy Spread & Current Status
- 10 years ago: 5-6 cities had benchmarking laws
- San Francisco first to pass, NYC first major implementation
- Now: 40-50 cities have benchmarking (Institute for Market Transformation map)
- Very popular policy spreading rapidly
2050 Carbon Reduction Analysis
- McKinsey waterfall graph: NYC Pathways to Deep Carbon Reductions (Dec 30, 2013 - Bloomberg's last day)
- 2050 business as usual: slight reduction from 2005 levels
- 55.7 million metric tons CO2 equivalent savings needed for 80% by 2050
- ~50% savings from buildings: existing building efficiency, fuel switching, new building efficiency
- Power sector: clean power, distributed generation
- Transportation sector savings
- Little from solid waste
- Goals now Net Zero by 2050 (more aggressive than original Paris Agreement 80% by 2050)
Building Sector Marginal Abatement Cost Curve
- NYC-specific building sector analysis
- Most interventions negative cost
- Anything <$150/ton should be implemented (below social cost of carbon)
- 23 of 28 total metric tons CO2 equivalent/year potential at reasonable cost
- Residential freezers largest area (unexpected high-impact topic)
Local Law 97 (2019) - Carbon Budgets
- Buildings >25,000 sq ft affected
- Increasingly stringent carbon emissions limits per sq ft: 2024 and 2030
- 2024: first marker (less aggressive), 2030: much tougher target
- Compliance flexibility: renewable energy credits, emissions offsets
- Cambridge considering similar but no renewable energy credits allowed
- Affordable housing: can choose low-cost measures instead of emissions limits
- New Office of Building Energy and Emissions Performance at DOB
- Strong Advisory Board for refining metrics
- Carbon trading study and implementation plan
- Cap and trade for buildings: spend money on cost-effective upgrades across multiple buildings
- Stringent penalties for non-compliance
- Variances for financial hardship
Economic & Employment Analysis (2019)
- Urban Green Council analysis with author
- Job creation: 2024 goals ~20,000 jobs, 2030 goals ~180,000 jobs, total ~200,000 jobs
- Workforce considered biggest obstacle to achieving carbon budgets
- May increase building values, output, earnings
- Policy effectiveness depends on finding sufficient workers
