AI summary by TwinMind
Liberal democracy might already be dead | The Gray Area
Vox
50m 59s
Introduction and Context
- Sean Elling hosts The Gray Area podcast, former philosophy teacher
- Episode featuring British philosopher John Gray discussing his book "The New Leviathans: Thoughts After Liberalism"
- Gray argues liberalism has already passed away, not just dying
- Focus on Thomas Hobbes as foundational liberal thinker and relevance to current politics
Historical Foundation of Liberalism
- Hobbes's Leviathan (1651) as founding text of modern political philosophy
- Core challenge to divine right of kings and religious authority
- Foundation: consent of governed, state exists to protect individuals
- Hobbes's famous description: life as "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short"
- Political philosophy dominated Western world from Enlightenment onward
Gray's Argument: Liberalism Has Already Died
- Visible signs of liberal order collapse over past 30+ years since 1990
- Failed transitions: Russia and China didn't become liberal democracies
- Failed "wars of choice": Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, Libya - all failures
- Damaged US and British credibility globally
- Liberal West in "steep retreat" geopolitically
- Within Western societies: curtailment of liberal freedoms (speech, inquiry, expression)
- Curtailment not by dictatorial state but by civil institutions themselves
- Universities, museums, publishers, media, charities self-imposing limits
- "Cancel culture" - policing expression, excluding those deviating from progressive orthodoxy
Definition of Liberalism
- Core principle: no one has natural right to rule
- All rulers/regimes serve those they govern
- Differs from Plato (philosopher-kings), divine right, virtue-based rule
- Fundamental equality between ruler and ruled
- When sovereign fails to protect individuals, obligations dissolved
- Individual can leave or even kill sovereign
- Hobbes as "first and last great liberal philosopher"
- Supported by scholars: Michael Oakeshott, CB Macpherson, Leo Strauss
Hobbes's Tragic Vision vs Modern Liberalism
- Hobbes's dark, gloomy worldview appeals due to tragic dimension
- Anarchy never transcended, only staved off - permanent possibility
- State of nature always lurking beneath civilization
- Modern liberalism went astray by losing sight of limited state purpose
- Hobbes: state has very limited purpose (security) but unlimited means
- No rights constraints on sovereign action if it serves peace
- State can't intervene for social justice/progress/virtue promotion
- Default human condition is conflict, not harmony
- Order is fragile in human life
Contemporary Threats: States vs Anarchy
- 20th century: main destroyers were states (totalitarian regimes)
- 21st century: terrorist organizations, criminal gangs as threats
- Anarchy now equal threat to totalitarian states
- Hobbes more topical now - states often collapsed/destroyed
- Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya destroyed by attempts to create "better" states
- Liberal error: assuming nothing worse than tyranny
- Hobbes's insight: anarchy can be worse than tyranny
- Once in anarchical condition, very difficult to reconstruct state
Politicization of Judicial Institutions
- Gray predicted 30 years ago: judicial institutions would be politicized
- As rights extended to morally disputed areas (e.g., abortion)
- Supreme Court would become object of political capture
- Liberal colleagues incredulous then, now reality
- Private life sphere much smaller - private conversations actionable
- Defining features of liberalism as practicing institutions largely gone
Liberalism as Political Religion
- Nietzsche's view: liberalism rooted in Christian ideas (human equality, value)
- Modern liberals rejected religious roots while preserving values on secular grounds
- Destined to fail according to Nietzsche
- Hobbesian liberalism intended as political atheism
- Shapeshifted into political religion without recognizing itself as such
- John Stuart Mill explicitly adopted "religion of humanity" from Auguste Comte
- Mill: anyone inheriting identity from society lacks individuality
- Liberalism secularized monotheistic assumptions/values
The Problem of Self-Creation
- West "possessed by idea of freedom" as self-creation
- Freedom means creating yourself as person you want to be
- Not in Hobbes, but present in Mill's concept of individuality
- Mill: inheriting way of life from conventions/traditions lacks individuality
- Being "author of your own life" - fashioning it like work of art
- Impossible ideal: identity meaningless unless accepted by others
- Provokes deep conflict - underlying autonomy as self-creation
- Traditional liberal toleration: don't need full validation from others
- Can "rub along" as different, miscellaneous personalities
Identity Politics and Rights Conflicts
- Pursuit of individual freedom good, but problematic if pursued too far
- Self-definition doesn't end with self - becomes political contest for recognition
- Liberal politics not equipped to handle this well or long
- When framed as rights: perpetual conflict between rival groups
- Recipe for unending conflict if identities antagonistic/polarized
- Some people want to free themselves from traditional identities
- Others happy with inherited identities - should have equal respect
Economic Model Failures
- Main challenges to liberal societies: economic model adopted after Cold War
- Left large parts of society behind - working communities abandoned
- Middle classes haven't seen income/standard improvements in 30 years
- Societies as whole gotten considerably better, but unevenly distributed
- Post-WWII social democracy model: state intervention to smooth market capitalism
- Abandonment of this model after Cold War led to deep contradictions
- "Populism" is political blowback against social disruption from liberal policies
- Not demonic force from nowhere, but response to policy failures
- Demagogues successful in 2016+ because of social democratic period absence
America's Legitimacy Crisis
- America become "Schmittian" - law indistinguishable from politics
- Trump pushed past threshold into full legitimacy crisis
- Doesn't matter who wins elections - ~30% will consider illegitimate
- Friend-enemy relations replacing liberal discourse
- Very hard to return from this situation
- Both sides want to win - creates downward spiral
- Gray's prediction: continued disintegration, not new order emerging
Future Projections
Europe:
- No European superstate emerging
- Variety of nation-states with internal problems
- Shifting toward hard-right policy influence
- Far-right substantial political blocks in France, Germany
America:
- Not expecting state fragmentation by secession
- More likely: semi-stable semi-anarchy
- Regions, cities semi-anarchical (like parts of Mexico, Latin America)
- Could continue for long time
- Declining capacity to project power globally
- Enormous hard firepower but limited intelligent use
- Possible decades/generations of civil warfare
- Different identity groups, ideologies, states going own ways
- High-tech oligarchy preserving position, rest of society abandoned
Tragic View of Politics
- Politics inherently tragic - recurring situations with deep losses attached
- Whatever action taken has enduring losses
- Tragedy isn't imperfectability or reversible progress
- Deeper: unchosen choices humans must make
- Preference for politics accepting tragedy as primordial, omnipresent
- Occam's razor approach: minimize tragedies beyond strictly necessary
- Don't multiply tragedies by creating new regimes everywhere
- Revolutionary attempts always result in most ruthless prevailing
- To reach supposedly post-tragic world requires ruthless tragic decisions
- Need to return to pre-Christian tragic sense (Greek tragedy, Book of Job)
- Human beings not autonomous - cannot shape choices they must make
