AI summary by TwinMind

Lisa Piccirillo | How You Too Can Solve 50+ Year Old Problems | Talks at Google

Talks at Google

47m 58s

Introduction and Background

  • Jane introduces Lisa Piccirillo, MIT associate professor specializing in topology
  • Lisa's education: undergrad at Boston College, PhD at University of Texas at Austin
  • Specializes in 3 and 4-dimensional spaces
  • Famous for solving Conway knot problem in under a week after 50+ years unsolved
  • Won Maryam Mirzakhani New Frontiers Prize
  • Named in Wired 25 for making things better

Early Interest in Mathematics

  • Initially interested in math as a child from rural area
  • People suggested engineering career path
  • Attended engineering summer camps but didn't enjoy building bridges from popsicle sticks
  • College calculus professor very encouraging despite poor performance
  • Professor convinced her to take linear algebra for math majors
  • Started progression toward math specialization

Path to Topology

  • Attended undergraduate lecture by visiting researcher end of first year
  • Talk about surfaces embedded in space in interesting ways
  • Visual, "weird smooshy thing" nature appealed to her
  • "If I weren't a topologist I would be a journalist, not a number theorist"
  • Drawn to visual aspects rather than abstract number theory

Hobbies and Interests Outside Math

  • Lives in tiny Cambridge apartment, had to downsize tools
  • Previously owned bandsaw, now focuses on relief carvings with hand tools
  • Loves figure drawing - finds it therapeutic
  • Drawing philosophy: "draw what you see not what you think you see"
  • Allows brain to "go away" - different from normal mathematical thinking
  • Drawing skills help with copying knot diagrams

Introduction to Knot Theory

  • Knot definition: extension cord plugged together at ends forming circle in space
  • Can be knotted in any configuration - all valid knots
  • Boring knot: perfect circle lying flat (unknot)

Slice Knots Concept

  • Disc-bounding in 3D space: unknot bounds disc like tablecloth with lace border
  • Question: does any knot bound a disc in 3-dimensional space?
  • Slice knots: knots that bound disc in 4-dimensional space
  • Knot still lives in 3D but disc uses 4 dimensions of ambient space
  • Disc remains 2-dimensional but embedded in 4D space

Conway Knot Significance

  • Discovered by John Conway late 1960s
  • Created while building pairs of similar knots (mutants)
  • Conway knot is mutant of previously studied knot
  • Change so subtle Conway couldn't prove it was different from original
  • Riley proved they were different few years later
  • 11-crossing knot - sliceness solved for all other 11-crossing knots
  • Mystique comes from extreme similarity to its "friend"

Traditional Approach to Slice Problems

  • Mathematicians use invariants: assign integers to knots
  • If knots same, get same integer; if different integers, knots different
  • Slice invariants: slice knots get 0, non-slice knots get non-zero
  • Many powerful invariants developed over decades
  • Lisa assumed all invariants already tried after 50 years

Lisa's Novel Approach

  • Studies 4-dimensional spaces assigned to knots
  • Key insight: if two knots have same 4D space, both slice or both non-slice
  • Strategy: build different knot with same space as Conway knot
  • Study the easier knot instead of Conway knot directly
  • Avoids pathology of Conway knot's similarity to slice knot
  • Uses completely different "clean" knot with same essential properties

Discovery Process and Impact

  • Initially thought problem wasn't worth publishing
  • First mathematician she told was very excited
  • Slow realization of problem's importance and community interest
  • Led to MIT assistant professor position (faster than typical postdoc path)
  • Pressure shift: from "work hard to do job" to "be excellent all the time"
  • Learning to handle new expectations and occasional failure

Advice for Solving Hard Problems

Philosophical Advice

  • Must love the process, not just solution
  • For incredibly difficult problems, need to enjoy working on them
  • Management should give space to enjoy work without strict deadlines

Practical Advice

  • Work on multiple unrelated problems simultaneously
  • When stuck, switch to different problem for 36 hours
  • Return with fresh eyes - catch many things in first hour back
  • Discuss with others even if they're not experts
  • Explaining out loud to humans (not rubber ducks) forces full sentences
  • Human interaction more valuable than talking to inanimate objects

Women in Mathematics - Barriers

  • Undergrad STEM majors approaching 50% female
  • Major drop from undergrad to PhD level
  • Studying math poor proxy for actual mathematician job
  • People use proxies: "do people like me do this job?"
  • Stereotypes suggest orthogonal personalities
  • Easy to conclude "not for me" and walk away
  • Competitive field where any extra obstacles cause pipeline dropout
  • Small and large acts of harassment create cumulative burden
  • Different reaction styles to trauma affect career prospects
  • Those who don't immediately return to work fall behind

University of Texas Experience

  • Chose UT partly for reputation with female students
  • Very large, diverse program (40+ women, many URM students)
  • Diverse in interests, life backgrounds, not just demographics
  • Culture: "human way before mathematician"
  • Strong community emphasizing healthy, happy humans first
  • Provided essential support and belonging

Mentorship Importance

  • Data supports mentorship helps with retention
  • Similar background mentors understand experiences, assumptions
  • Can communicate more freely and effectively
  • Undergraduate mentor: Ellie Grigsby (calculus professor)
  • UT had many role models slightly older (grad students, postdocs)
  • "Laura's doing great job, I'll just copy Laura"
  • Made decision-making easier, reduced fear

Advice for Aspiring Mathematicians

For Those Feeling Behind

  • Easy to feel others racing past with unfamiliar terminology
  • Only way anyone learns math: slowly, carefully, methodologically
  • Even "fast" people go slowly when actually working
  • Some may be posturing - don't worry about it
  • Just go slowly, carefully, learn thoroughly

General Principles

  • Math is hard, slow, boring - must also be really fun
  • Love the literal math you're doing, not what you "should" learn
  • Choose environments where you work well and happily
  • Choose departments with good culture fit
  • Reject advice to go to hostile environments to "prove yourself"
  • No shame in choosing pleasant places - will prove better theorems there

Current Research Direction

  • 4-dimensional manifold topology has many intractable problems
  • Working in "slightly easier space" where problems can be solved
  • Developing techniques potentially transferable to "hard land"
  • Building tools for eventual application to harder problems

Technical Follow-up Questions

Algorithmic Potential

  • Current technique not always applicable (building same-space knots not always possible)
  • Working on knots with "something in common" (weaker condition)
  • Might enable broader algorithmic approach
  • Research ongoing

Applications Beyond Conway Knot

  • Technique hasn't yet helped other problems directly
  • Central idea (same space implies same sliceness) being used by others
  • Collaborator applying concept to other 4D space problems
  • Observation proving powerful in other contexts

Topological vs Smooth Slicing

  • Conway knot is topologically slice (bounds gnarly, non-smooth disc)
  • Friedman's disc embedding theorem proof involves essential limit
  • Smoothing would require working "out in the limit"
  • Lisa showed this smoothing impossible - limit is essential

Book Recommendations

  • Flatland by Edwin Abbott Abbott (not math book but enjoyable)
  • The Shape of Space by Jeff Weeks (undergraduate text, accessible, colloquial)
    • Covers 3D, 4D, higher dimensional spaces
    • Preferred because focuses on manifolds over knots
  • The Knot Book by Colin Adams
    • Very accessible for non-mathematicians
    • Gets to open problems by page 5

Mental Health and Coping

  • Acknowledges not handling mental health perfectly
  • Technique from high school insomnia: telling brain "this is boring"
  • Applied to current overwhelm: "March already happened, been through this million times"
  • Focus on doing math instead of ruminating
  • Similar to drawing advice: "no brain, just eyes and hands"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome