AI summary by TwinMind
Lisa Piccirillo | How You Too Can Solve 50+ Year Old Problems | Talks at Google
Talks at Google
47m 58s
Introduction and Background
- Jane introduces Lisa Piccirillo, MIT associate professor specializing in topology
- Lisa's education: undergrad at Boston College, PhD at University of Texas at Austin
- Specializes in 3 and 4-dimensional spaces
- Famous for solving Conway knot problem in under a week after 50+ years unsolved
- Won Maryam Mirzakhani New Frontiers Prize
- Named in Wired 25 for making things better
Early Interest in Mathematics
- Initially interested in math as a child from rural area
- People suggested engineering career path
- Attended engineering summer camps but didn't enjoy building bridges from popsicle sticks
- College calculus professor very encouraging despite poor performance
- Professor convinced her to take linear algebra for math majors
- Started progression toward math specialization
Path to Topology
- Attended undergraduate lecture by visiting researcher end of first year
- Talk about surfaces embedded in space in interesting ways
- Visual, "weird smooshy thing" nature appealed to her
- "If I weren't a topologist I would be a journalist, not a number theorist"
- Drawn to visual aspects rather than abstract number theory
Hobbies and Interests Outside Math
- Lives in tiny Cambridge apartment, had to downsize tools
- Previously owned bandsaw, now focuses on relief carvings with hand tools
- Loves figure drawing - finds it therapeutic
- Drawing philosophy: "draw what you see not what you think you see"
- Allows brain to "go away" - different from normal mathematical thinking
- Drawing skills help with copying knot diagrams
Introduction to Knot Theory
- Knot definition: extension cord plugged together at ends forming circle in space
- Can be knotted in any configuration - all valid knots
- Boring knot: perfect circle lying flat (unknot)
Slice Knots Concept
- Disc-bounding in 3D space: unknot bounds disc like tablecloth with lace border
- Question: does any knot bound a disc in 3-dimensional space?
- Slice knots: knots that bound disc in 4-dimensional space
- Knot still lives in 3D but disc uses 4 dimensions of ambient space
- Disc remains 2-dimensional but embedded in 4D space
Conway Knot Significance
- Discovered by John Conway late 1960s
- Created while building pairs of similar knots (mutants)
- Conway knot is mutant of previously studied knot
- Change so subtle Conway couldn't prove it was different from original
- Riley proved they were different few years later
- 11-crossing knot - sliceness solved for all other 11-crossing knots
- Mystique comes from extreme similarity to its "friend"
Traditional Approach to Slice Problems
- Mathematicians use invariants: assign integers to knots
- If knots same, get same integer; if different integers, knots different
- Slice invariants: slice knots get 0, non-slice knots get non-zero
- Many powerful invariants developed over decades
- Lisa assumed all invariants already tried after 50 years
Lisa's Novel Approach
- Studies 4-dimensional spaces assigned to knots
- Key insight: if two knots have same 4D space, both slice or both non-slice
- Strategy: build different knot with same space as Conway knot
- Study the easier knot instead of Conway knot directly
- Avoids pathology of Conway knot's similarity to slice knot
- Uses completely different "clean" knot with same essential properties
Discovery Process and Impact
- Initially thought problem wasn't worth publishing
- First mathematician she told was very excited
- Slow realization of problem's importance and community interest
- Led to MIT assistant professor position (faster than typical postdoc path)
- Pressure shift: from "work hard to do job" to "be excellent all the time"
- Learning to handle new expectations and occasional failure
Advice for Solving Hard Problems
Philosophical Advice
- Must love the process, not just solution
- For incredibly difficult problems, need to enjoy working on them
- Management should give space to enjoy work without strict deadlines
Practical Advice
- Work on multiple unrelated problems simultaneously
- When stuck, switch to different problem for 36 hours
- Return with fresh eyes - catch many things in first hour back
- Discuss with others even if they're not experts
- Explaining out loud to humans (not rubber ducks) forces full sentences
- Human interaction more valuable than talking to inanimate objects
Women in Mathematics - Barriers
- Undergrad STEM majors approaching 50% female
- Major drop from undergrad to PhD level
- Studying math poor proxy for actual mathematician job
- People use proxies: "do people like me do this job?"
- Stereotypes suggest orthogonal personalities
- Easy to conclude "not for me" and walk away
- Competitive field where any extra obstacles cause pipeline dropout
- Small and large acts of harassment create cumulative burden
- Different reaction styles to trauma affect career prospects
- Those who don't immediately return to work fall behind
University of Texas Experience
- Chose UT partly for reputation with female students
- Very large, diverse program (40+ women, many URM students)
- Diverse in interests, life backgrounds, not just demographics
- Culture: "human way before mathematician"
- Strong community emphasizing healthy, happy humans first
- Provided essential support and belonging
Mentorship Importance
- Data supports mentorship helps with retention
- Similar background mentors understand experiences, assumptions
- Can communicate more freely and effectively
- Undergraduate mentor: Ellie Grigsby (calculus professor)
- UT had many role models slightly older (grad students, postdocs)
- "Laura's doing great job, I'll just copy Laura"
- Made decision-making easier, reduced fear
Advice for Aspiring Mathematicians
For Those Feeling Behind
- Easy to feel others racing past with unfamiliar terminology
- Only way anyone learns math: slowly, carefully, methodologically
- Even "fast" people go slowly when actually working
- Some may be posturing - don't worry about it
- Just go slowly, carefully, learn thoroughly
General Principles
- Math is hard, slow, boring - must also be really fun
- Love the literal math you're doing, not what you "should" learn
- Choose environments where you work well and happily
- Choose departments with good culture fit
- Reject advice to go to hostile environments to "prove yourself"
- No shame in choosing pleasant places - will prove better theorems there
Current Research Direction
- 4-dimensional manifold topology has many intractable problems
- Working in "slightly easier space" where problems can be solved
- Developing techniques potentially transferable to "hard land"
- Building tools for eventual application to harder problems
Technical Follow-up Questions
Algorithmic Potential
- Current technique not always applicable (building same-space knots not always possible)
- Working on knots with "something in common" (weaker condition)
- Might enable broader algorithmic approach
- Research ongoing
Applications Beyond Conway Knot
- Technique hasn't yet helped other problems directly
- Central idea (same space implies same sliceness) being used by others
- Collaborator applying concept to other 4D space problems
- Observation proving powerful in other contexts
Topological vs Smooth Slicing
- Conway knot is topologically slice (bounds gnarly, non-smooth disc)
- Friedman's disc embedding theorem proof involves essential limit
- Smoothing would require working "out in the limit"
- Lisa showed this smoothing impossible - limit is essential
Book Recommendations
- Flatland by Edwin Abbott Abbott (not math book but enjoyable)
- The Shape of Space by Jeff Weeks (undergraduate text, accessible, colloquial)
- Covers 3D, 4D, higher dimensional spaces
- Preferred because focuses on manifolds over knots
- The Knot Book by Colin Adams
- Very accessible for non-mathematicians
- Gets to open problems by page 5
Mental Health and Coping
- Acknowledges not handling mental health perfectly
- Technique from high school insomnia: telling brain "this is boring"
- Applied to current overwhelm: "March already happened, been through this million times"
- Focus on doing math instead of ruminating
- Similar to drawing advice: "no brain, just eyes and hands"
