AI summary by TwinMind
Little Bay: Why This Island Was Abandoned on December 31st, 2019
Wendover Productions
22m 54s
Channel Introduction & Video Context
- New channel "Extremities" launched - first new channel in 2 years
- Focus: why/how world's most remote settlements exist with stunning visuals and exclusive interviews
- This episode about Little Bay Islands - town that ceased to exist after December 31, 2019
- Only episode of Extremities that will appear on Wendover Productions
Final Ferry Departure - December 31, 2019
- 5 PM: MV Hazel Mc-Isaac pulled away from Little Bay Islands with last holdouts
- Final ferry service from rustic collection of snow-dusted crimson, off-white and beige saltbox homes
- Permanent population plummeted from 54 to just 2 (Mike Parsons and wife Georgina stayed)
- Mike Parsons: "palpable sadness had enveloped the islands"
- Quote: "there's nothing else there you know that but the steel people got uh for the love of the land where they're born on"
- Electricity shut off - powered HL Strong Academy, Edna's B&B, two churches, dozens of homes
- Little Bay Islands became 8th remote community in Newfoundland and Labrador this century to permanently relocate
Historical Foundation - Cod Fishing Industry
- Settlement name plural to acknowledge community straddling Little Bay and Mack Islands
- Peak population: over 500 residents
- Founded on proximity to cod fishing grounds, not land resources
Indigenous Peoples & Early Settlement
- Paleo Eskimo peoples arrived ~1000 BCE
- Little Passage peoples followed 2000 years later
- Indigenous hunter-gatherer societies first recognized wealth of Newfoundland's coasts
European Arrival & Cod Industry Development
- Northern/Western Europeans identified oceanic potential
- Norse sailors landed hundreds of years before Columbus
- British and Basque fishing ventures kept favorite spots secret
- Enterprising vessels likely crossed Atlantic alongside/before Columbus and John Cabot (1490s)
- Cabot: waters so well-stocked "all one had to do was stick a basket in the ocean and it fill with fish"
Cod Characteristics & Processing
- Atlantic cod: omnivorous bottom feeder, perpetually lethargic, ceaselessly hungry
- Gladly take bait, don't fight much once hooked
- Could be kept 2-3 years when salt-cured, split and salted
- Exported to England, Portugal, Spain
- Catholic countries sought alternatives to warm-blooded meats during Lent
- Appeared in literature: Cervantes' Don Quixote, Zola's Belly of Paris, Dumas's Le Grand Dictionnaire Cuisine
Little Bay Islands Settlement Details
- Earliest census: 1825 (some believe British fishers established year-round habitation decades prior)
- Only accessible by boat, angling out to Notre Dame Bay and Grand Banks
- Quintessential outport - built on/around water
- Strictly ocean-oriented economy from inception
- No abiding climate or arable land for agriculture
Mid-20th Century Stability (1950s)
- 1950: Newfoundland became part of Canada
- Added saltbox homes, processing plants, modern boats
- Daily routine: cod fishing, kids from schoolhouse, union meetings, Poacher's Lounge
- Weekend: grocery stores, two churches
- Seasonal cycle: root vegetable gardens, peak summer fishing season
- Generational knowledge transfer from parents to children
- Community still happily revolved around same industry
Industrial Transformation & Threat (1951)
- 280-foot British factory trawling vessel appeared off Newfoundland coast 1951
- Invading fleet: smaller trawlers from Europe, Soviet Union, Japan
- Technology shift from traditional methods (hook/line, nets, cod traps) to draggers
- Side trawlers could "drag the bottom" - taking everything in net's path
- Not only cod but significant bycatch thrown back dead
- Floating cities capable of hauling tons, flash-freezing at sea
- Traditional methods used by local fishers for generations superseded in just one decade
Government Consolidation Programs
- Centralization Program 1954
- Fisheries Household Resettlement Program 1965
- Goal: save on expensive government services (ferries, power, healthcare)
- Moved thousands from remote outports to population centers
- 1950s-60s: waters around Little Bay Islands overcrowded
- Similar towns felt pressure to relocate
- Little Bay Islands not only persisted but thrived during this period
- Docks, shops, processing plants, churches, school hummed with activity
- Enough fish to support both industrial trawlers and small-scale operations
Cod Stock Collapse
- 1970s: annual fish hauls tripling tonnage from three decades prior
- Cod populations couldn't keep up
- Canadian officials turned back foreign vessels, placed quotas
- "Far too little, far too late"
- 1990: in some spots could hardly find fish at all
- Wilford's account: fished 500 miles north in Labrador coast for two years, "couldn't get a cod to eat"
1992 Cod Moratorium
- Canadian government banned nearly all cod fishing
- Aimed to revive stock over few years
- Nearly 30 years later: moratorium still in place
- Put Little Bay Islands in "impossible position"
Community Characteristics & Challenges
- Wilford: "one of the most beautiful communities around"
- Beautiful harbor with two inlets: "small ball one end and big bust for the other"
- Sheltered harbor regardless of weather
- Small island - people had to go off-island for wood (stoves, shipbuilding)
- Located close to fishing grounds - "that was the main thing"
- Fishing didn't create massive wealth but supported unique way of life
- Nurtured small town camaraderie, family bonds, rural rugged lifestyle
- No backup plan, no alternative industry
- "Cod was king and now cod was dead"
Post-Moratorium Adaptation Attempts
- Little Bay Islanders turned to crab fishing and capelin
- These species kept Newfoundland's economy afloat through to today
- Still billion-dollar industry despite cod collapse
- Decade following 1992: 10% of Newfoundland Labrador population moved away
- Institutions began to falter: grocery stores, churches, school
2009 Processing Plant Closure
- Crab processing plant (town's last major employer) shuttered
- Women workers had little choice: relocate or rely on unemployment programs
- Few decades: bustling town became melancholy quiet
- Families "peeled out of town one by one"
- Murmurs of whole-scale resettlement gained momentum
Resettlement Program Revival
- "Resettlement is a bad word" - reference to "Joey's father's day" (mid-century forced relocations)
- Government revived unpopular mid-century policy in 2010
- New terms: larger payout, prohibited provincial government from initiating process
- Required 90% community approval if viable
- More amenable terms but still emotionally difficult
Cultural & Emotional Impact
- "Feels like the death of this way of life"
- Physical link to ancestry tied up for hundreds of years
- Loss of connection to place, culture, heritage, tradition
- More than changing vacation plans - fundamental loss of identity
Youth Migration & Family Decisions
- Outport youth began looking west for opportunity
- No jobs: "even summertime when you're out of school" - used to work fish plants or boats
- "Now there's nothing fun to do come out of school"
- Families urged youth to move on
- Grandfather was "last fisherman in family" - "by design"
- Wanted four boys to have classroom education, careers allowing them to leave outports
- Hope that fishery would recover faded
Final Years & Resettlement Vote
2015 Conditions
- 95 aging full-timers
- 45 minutes from medical facilities and grocery stores (assuming fair weather)
- Processing plant shuttered, school empty, local bar dry, fire department closed, town doctor gone
- Shell of former self
First Vote (2015)
- Result: 85 votes for, 10 against
- Missed required 90% benchmark by 0.5%
Second Vote (Four Years Later)
- Unanimous decision
- Little Bay Islands would resettle
Resettlement Implementation
- Residents planned next move, packed belongings
- Some converted homes to operate off-grid for summer visits
- $250,000 Canadian per resident for relocating
- Retained property ownership
- Lost government-supplied amenities: power, snow plowing, ferry service
Current Status & Future
December 31, 2019 Transition
- MV Hazel Mc-Isaac disappeared into December night
- Parsons returned to newly off-grid home
- Era both foreign and familiar:
- Over: centuries of permanent settlement, decades of direct connection to mainland Canada
- Returning: remoteness and self-sufficiency of outports' earliest days
Tourism vs. Authentic Community
- Recent years: seasonal visitors (sea kayakers, photographers, authors, artists)
- Jen Thornhill Verma: "as much as I'm proud that people go there to visit, I want people to go and stay for a long time not just a good time"
- Staying long-term requires healthy fishery
- Healthy fishery requires stringent protective fishing policy at national/international level
Broader Implications
- Outports built on enterprising/independent spirits bend to global forces
- Always been at mercy of economics and politics beyond their wharfs
- Lesson: not that rural small town lifestyle can't exist, but "can't exist in a vacuum"
- While proudly independent and peripheral, survival hinges on relationships/ties to center
- People decide when they resettle, but larger forces decide if they have to
