AI summary by TwinMind

LIVE: Minneapolis - The Madd Gasser of Mattoon | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

1h 1m 14s

Introduction and Setting

  • Live recording of "Stuff You Should Know" podcast at State Theater in Minneapolis, Minnesota
  • Hosts: Josh Clark and Charles "Chuck" Wayne Bryant
  • Topic: The Mad Gasser of Mattoon, Illinois case from 1944
  • Mattoon described as small town (16,000 population) in triangle between Chicago, St. Louis, Indianapolis
  • Claims to fame: Bagel capital of world (Lender Bagels factory opened 1985), Mad Gasser incident

Background Context - Mattoon 1944

  • Small farming community surrounded by corn and soybean fields
  • Railroad junctions provided employment
  • Brown Shoe Company factory present
  • Significant portion of young men away fighting World War II
  • Anxious atmosphere due to wartime conditions
  • Police force understaffed (10 officers instead of needed 20)
  • Police department politically divided between Commissioner Thomas Wright and Chief CE Cole

First Attack - September 1, 1944

  • Occurred at home of Bert and Aileen Kerney
  • Aileen's sister Martha Reidy staying due to husband fighting overseas
  • 11:00 PM: Aileen and toddler daughter Dorothy went to bed
  • Strange sickeningly sweet gardenia-like smell detected
  • Aileen experienced paralysis in legs and arms, dry burning mouth and throat
  • Dorothy became ill but recovered
  • Sister Martha opened window, called neighbor Earl Robertson
  • Police called, found nothing during search
  • 12:30 AM: Bert Kerney returned home, spotted tall thin athletic figure in backyard wearing watch cap
  • Prowler fled when chased
  • Symptoms lasted approximately 90 minutes

Media Coverage and Escalation

  • John Miller from Mattoon Journal Gazette investigated story
  • Saturday paper ran huge headline: "Anesthetic Prowler on the Loose"
  • Subtitle: "Mrs. Kerney and daughter first victims"
  • Journal Gazette reached 97% of town population
  • Story published during Labor Day weekend, creating 2-day information vacuum

Additional Cases Come Forward

  • Mrs. Olive Brown reported similar attack months earlier
  • Urban Raef (softball commissioner) and wife Pauline experienced attack night before Kerneys
  • Initially attributed symptoms to bad hot dogs despite 90-minute paralysis
  • Patrice Ryder family also affected - mother lightheaded, children vomiting

Physical Evidence Discovery

  • Beula Cordes found moist pink cloth on front porch
  • Inhaled deeply from cloth, experienced electrical current sensation
  • Lips cracked, mouth dried, began bleeding
  • Marjorie Burell attacked same night, 18-month-old son unaffected

Peak Activity - September 5th

  • Four more attacks occurred Wednesday night
  • Laura Junkin (Big Four Restaurant owner) attacked
  • Mrs. Viola Spangler attacked hour later
  • 11-year-old Glenda Hendershot (factory manager's daughter) attacked
  • 60-year-old Fred Goble attacked with second tall thin prowler sighting

Town Response and Investigation

  • Anti-theft Association members armed themselves, began vigilante patrols
  • Police Commissioner Wright stated wouldn't cross own backyard for $10,000 ($176,300 in 2024)
  • State investigators arrived: Richard Piper and Francis Barry from Illinois Bureau of Crime Identification
  • FBI agents present as observers
  • State Patrol officers supplemented local force, brought two-way radios

Investigative Profile and Theories

  • Profile suggested mentally imbalanced, intelligent/brilliant individual
  • Assumed well-trained chemist using chloroform, chloropicrin (vomit gas), or custom paralytic agent
  • Chief Cole suggested carbon tetrachloride fumes from Atlas Imperial Diesel Engine Company
  • Company denied theory, hired PhD inspector who confirmed impossibility
  • Journal Gazette published scathing editorial criticizing Chief Cole

Policy Change and Decline

  • September 10th: Chief Cole announced new policy
  • Gas attack victims given choice: hospital examination (stomach tube) or night in jail
  • Calls immediately dropped off due to invasive medical procedure
  • Last recorded attack September 11th at Bertha B's home
  • Third prowler sighting: short, stout, heavy-set figure (not tall/thin)
  • Slashed window screen found with woman's high heel impression in dirt

Investigation Conclusion

  • State Patrol departed, took radios
  • Journal Gazette reduced coverage
  • Newspaper flame war with Decatur, Illinois
  • Total: 24 attacks affecting 36-100+ people
  • No deaths or long-term injuries
  • No arrests made
  • 232 total police calls in September (below 300 average)

Donald Johnson's Study

  • 18-19 year old University of Illinois student arrived post-incident
  • Studied case as mass delusion for psychology paper
  • Created makeshift ABCD socioeconomic scale based on:
    • Education level, age, sex, occupation, income
    • Household conveniences: electricity, refrigerator, telephone, radio
  • Found 93% of victims were women, mostly ages 20-29
  • Below average education and income compared to town population
  • Concluded entirely "psychogenic" caused by mass hysteria
  • Published January 1945 Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology
  • Became textbook case of mass hysteria

Case for Mass Hysteria

  • Wartime anxiety with men fighting overseas
  • Nazi POW escaped nearby prison 150 miles away August 29th
  • Journal Gazette's inflammatory headlines created expectation of more attacks
  • Period of chemical warfare concerns (sarin, mustard gas)
  • No clear motive for attacks
  • No chemical ever isolated from pink cloth
  • Gas dissipated quickly, sometimes undetected by helpers
  • Selective effects (some people in same room unaffected)
  • Attacks stopped when medical examination policy announced

Case Against Mass Hysteria

  • Physical evidence existed: pink cloth, slashed screen, footprint
  • Multiple prowler sightings by different witnesses
  • Real symptoms: bleeding, vomiting, paralysis
  • Police had motive to cover up (history of ignoring crimes they couldn't solve)
  • Johnson's study methodologically flawed:
    • Cherry-picked data, excluded men and children
    • Fabricated socioeconomic scale wouldn't pass modern peer review
    • No psychological testing of victims
  • Geographic/temporal consistency: no overlapping incidents despite 10-day period
  • All attacks could be explained by single person moving between locations

Scott Maruna's Investigation

  • High school chemistry teacher from Charleston (12 miles from Mattoon)
  • Wrote "The Mad Gasser of Mattoon: Dispelling the Hysteria"
  • Interviewed surviving residents
  • Identified suspect: Farley Llewellin
    • Trained chemist, University of Illinois dropout
    • Built professional chemistry lab that exploded week before attacks
    • Tall, slim, athletic build matching witness descriptions
    • Considered strange outsider, possibly gay
    • Previous Peeping Tom incident
    • From prominent grocery store family (father beloved community member)

Farley Llewellin Theory

  • Maruna suggests nitromethane as the gas
  • Symptoms match: limb weakness, cough, drowsiness, headache, nausea, sore throat, vomiting
  • Sickeningly sweet fruity smell
  • Theory: Llewellin attempted to blow up neighbors' bedrooms, not just gas them
  • Motivation: revenge against town for ostracism due to being gay chemistry loner
  • Problems with theory:
    • Was likely under 24-hour police surveillance during some attacks
    • Information based on decades-old resident interviews
    • Speculation about family sending him to state hospital
    • No verifiable records found
  • Maruna suggests first three attacks were Llewellin, later ones were mass hysteria or his sisters covering for him

Cultural Impact

  • Story spread worldwide, reached soldiers in Papua New Guinea
  • International media attention and ridicule
  • Matchbox Toys created Mad Gasser figure (Monster in My Pocket series)
  • Rated 80/100 on "evilness scale"
  • Green monster with lobster pincers, gas tank, orange mask, tentacles
  • Case remains unsolved mystery

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome