AI summary by TwinMind
LIVE: Minneapolis - The Madd Gasser of Mattoon | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
1h 1m 14s
Introduction and Setting
- Live recording of "Stuff You Should Know" podcast at State Theater in Minneapolis, Minnesota
- Hosts: Josh Clark and Charles "Chuck" Wayne Bryant
- Topic: The Mad Gasser of Mattoon, Illinois case from 1944
- Mattoon described as small town (16,000 population) in triangle between Chicago, St. Louis, Indianapolis
- Claims to fame: Bagel capital of world (Lender Bagels factory opened 1985), Mad Gasser incident
Background Context - Mattoon 1944
- Small farming community surrounded by corn and soybean fields
- Railroad junctions provided employment
- Brown Shoe Company factory present
- Significant portion of young men away fighting World War II
- Anxious atmosphere due to wartime conditions
- Police force understaffed (10 officers instead of needed 20)
- Police department politically divided between Commissioner Thomas Wright and Chief CE Cole
First Attack - September 1, 1944
- Occurred at home of Bert and Aileen Kerney
- Aileen's sister Martha Reidy staying due to husband fighting overseas
- 11:00 PM: Aileen and toddler daughter Dorothy went to bed
- Strange sickeningly sweet gardenia-like smell detected
- Aileen experienced paralysis in legs and arms, dry burning mouth and throat
- Dorothy became ill but recovered
- Sister Martha opened window, called neighbor Earl Robertson
- Police called, found nothing during search
- 12:30 AM: Bert Kerney returned home, spotted tall thin athletic figure in backyard wearing watch cap
- Prowler fled when chased
- Symptoms lasted approximately 90 minutes
Media Coverage and Escalation
- John Miller from Mattoon Journal Gazette investigated story
- Saturday paper ran huge headline: "Anesthetic Prowler on the Loose"
- Subtitle: "Mrs. Kerney and daughter first victims"
- Journal Gazette reached 97% of town population
- Story published during Labor Day weekend, creating 2-day information vacuum
Additional Cases Come Forward
- Mrs. Olive Brown reported similar attack months earlier
- Urban Raef (softball commissioner) and wife Pauline experienced attack night before Kerneys
- Initially attributed symptoms to bad hot dogs despite 90-minute paralysis
- Patrice Ryder family also affected - mother lightheaded, children vomiting
Physical Evidence Discovery
- Beula Cordes found moist pink cloth on front porch
- Inhaled deeply from cloth, experienced electrical current sensation
- Lips cracked, mouth dried, began bleeding
- Marjorie Burell attacked same night, 18-month-old son unaffected
Peak Activity - September 5th
- Four more attacks occurred Wednesday night
- Laura Junkin (Big Four Restaurant owner) attacked
- Mrs. Viola Spangler attacked hour later
- 11-year-old Glenda Hendershot (factory manager's daughter) attacked
- 60-year-old Fred Goble attacked with second tall thin prowler sighting
Town Response and Investigation
- Anti-theft Association members armed themselves, began vigilante patrols
- Police Commissioner Wright stated wouldn't cross own backyard for $10,000 ($176,300 in 2024)
- State investigators arrived: Richard Piper and Francis Barry from Illinois Bureau of Crime Identification
- FBI agents present as observers
- State Patrol officers supplemented local force, brought two-way radios
Investigative Profile and Theories
- Profile suggested mentally imbalanced, intelligent/brilliant individual
- Assumed well-trained chemist using chloroform, chloropicrin (vomit gas), or custom paralytic agent
- Chief Cole suggested carbon tetrachloride fumes from Atlas Imperial Diesel Engine Company
- Company denied theory, hired PhD inspector who confirmed impossibility
- Journal Gazette published scathing editorial criticizing Chief Cole
Policy Change and Decline
- September 10th: Chief Cole announced new policy
- Gas attack victims given choice: hospital examination (stomach tube) or night in jail
- Calls immediately dropped off due to invasive medical procedure
- Last recorded attack September 11th at Bertha B's home
- Third prowler sighting: short, stout, heavy-set figure (not tall/thin)
- Slashed window screen found with woman's high heel impression in dirt
Investigation Conclusion
- State Patrol departed, took radios
- Journal Gazette reduced coverage
- Newspaper flame war with Decatur, Illinois
- Total: 24 attacks affecting 36-100+ people
- No deaths or long-term injuries
- No arrests made
- 232 total police calls in September (below 300 average)
Donald Johnson's Study
- 18-19 year old University of Illinois student arrived post-incident
- Studied case as mass delusion for psychology paper
- Created makeshift ABCD socioeconomic scale based on:
- Education level, age, sex, occupation, income
- Household conveniences: electricity, refrigerator, telephone, radio
- Found 93% of victims were women, mostly ages 20-29
- Below average education and income compared to town population
- Concluded entirely "psychogenic" caused by mass hysteria
- Published January 1945 Journal of Abnormal and Social Psychology
- Became textbook case of mass hysteria
Case for Mass Hysteria
- Wartime anxiety with men fighting overseas
- Nazi POW escaped nearby prison 150 miles away August 29th
- Journal Gazette's inflammatory headlines created expectation of more attacks
- Period of chemical warfare concerns (sarin, mustard gas)
- No clear motive for attacks
- No chemical ever isolated from pink cloth
- Gas dissipated quickly, sometimes undetected by helpers
- Selective effects (some people in same room unaffected)
- Attacks stopped when medical examination policy announced
Case Against Mass Hysteria
- Physical evidence existed: pink cloth, slashed screen, footprint
- Multiple prowler sightings by different witnesses
- Real symptoms: bleeding, vomiting, paralysis
- Police had motive to cover up (history of ignoring crimes they couldn't solve)
- Johnson's study methodologically flawed:
- Cherry-picked data, excluded men and children
- Fabricated socioeconomic scale wouldn't pass modern peer review
- No psychological testing of victims
- Geographic/temporal consistency: no overlapping incidents despite 10-day period
- All attacks could be explained by single person moving between locations
Scott Maruna's Investigation
- High school chemistry teacher from Charleston (12 miles from Mattoon)
- Wrote "The Mad Gasser of Mattoon: Dispelling the Hysteria"
- Interviewed surviving residents
- Identified suspect: Farley Llewellin
- Trained chemist, University of Illinois dropout
- Built professional chemistry lab that exploded week before attacks
- Tall, slim, athletic build matching witness descriptions
- Considered strange outsider, possibly gay
- Previous Peeping Tom incident
- From prominent grocery store family (father beloved community member)
Farley Llewellin Theory
- Maruna suggests nitromethane as the gas
- Symptoms match: limb weakness, cough, drowsiness, headache, nausea, sore throat, vomiting
- Sickeningly sweet fruity smell
- Theory: Llewellin attempted to blow up neighbors' bedrooms, not just gas them
- Motivation: revenge against town for ostracism due to being gay chemistry loner
- Problems with theory:
- Was likely under 24-hour police surveillance during some attacks
- Information based on decades-old resident interviews
- Speculation about family sending him to state hospital
- No verifiable records found
- Maruna suggests first three attacks were Llewellin, later ones were mass hysteria or his sisters covering for him
Cultural Impact
- Story spread worldwide, reached soldiers in Papua New Guinea
- International media attention and ridicule
- Matchbox Toys created Mad Gasser figure (Monster in My Pocket series)
- Rated 80/100 on "evilness scale"
- Green monster with lobster pincers, gas tank, orange mask, tentacles
- Case remains unsolved mystery
