AI summary by TwinMind
Loretta J. Ross: Don't call people out -- call them in | TED
TED
14m 19s
Speaker Background & Motivation
- Black woman who monitored hate groups, attended KKK rallies for work
- Survivor of racial violence, rape, incest
- Mentored by Rev. C.T. Vivian (MLK aide) who said: "When you ask people to give up hate, you need to be there for them when they do"
- Initially wanted to hate Klan members back, but job helping people leave hate groups changed perspective
- Shifted moral compass from hate to love
Calling-In Culture Philosophy
- Goal: build culture that invites people in instead of pushing them out
- Movement vs cult distinction:
- Movement: many different people, different thoughts, same direction
- Cult: many different people, one thought, same direction
- Treating potential allies like enemies = cult behavior, not human rights movement
- Friend Dázon Dixon Diallo's prediction: calling in will be to 21st century digital human rights movement what nonviolence was to 20th century civil rights movement
Calling Out (Cancel Culture) Analysis
- Definition: public accountability through blame/shame
- Example response: "I can't believe you just said that. You're racist, sexist, toxic, manipulative"
- Problems:
- Invites fight, not conversation
- Public humiliation
- Creates fear of becoming next target
- People stay silent even when things feel unfair
- Creates "unexploded gotcha bomb" anxiety
- Motivations often problematic:
- Fear
- Need to belong
- Feeling better by putting others down
- Seeking fame through defaming others
- Student quote: "A call-out is not an invitation for growth. It's the expectation that you've already grown"
Calling In Method
- Phrase invented by Loan Tran
- Definition: "call-out done with love"
- Technique: remain calm, respond "That's an interesting viewpoint. Tell me more"
- Results:
- Invites conversation instead of fight
- Don't need to agree to offer loving attention
- Acknowledges everyone's complexity and deserves respect
- Benefits:
- Lead with love instead of anger
- Affirm inner empathy/compassion
- Feel good about personal growth
- Can reconnect with friends/family previously given up on
Calling On Alternative
- Phrase created by Sonya Renee Taylor
- Method: "call on them to be a better person"
- Speaker's favorite response: look dead in eye, cock head, say "I beg your pardon" and wait
- Often causes people to walk back their words
Personal Examples
Student Misgendering Incident
- Speaker misgendered student in class
- Expected harsh reaction
- Student showed grace: "Oh, that's all right, professor. I misgender myself sometimes"
- 18-year-old demonstrating forgiveness
Uncle Frank Family Reunion
- Uncle Frank made racist comments about Mexican Americans stealing jobs
- Room went silent, people buried faces in plates
- Speaker's response strategy:
- Acknowledged love and respect for him
- Highlighted his good qualities (would save anyone from burning building regardless of race/sexuality/immigration status)
- Asked: "How can I reconcile that good Uncle Frank with the words that just came out of your mouth?"
- Results:
- Less defensive (no direct attack)
- Affirmed his options for how to be
- Challenged bigotry without hate/argument
- Demonstrated to family how to stand up to bigotry peacefully
Forgiveness as Calling In
- Most effective expression of calling in
- Charleston church massacre 2015 example:
- 9 people killed
- Chris Singleton (victim's son) forgave his mother's killer
- Said forgiveness is powerful, provides freedom from revenge and anger
- Was called out for offering forgiveness
Implementation Requirements
- Self-assessment needed before calling in
- Must know your motives
- Must be in "healed enough space" for someone else's feelings
- Taught to eighth-graders, college students, C-suite executives
- All participants felt better about themselves, reaffirmed optimism
Core Message
- People deserve chance to redeem themselves from mistakes
- Someone gave us chance to grow, we can offer same to others
- Risk only losing pain
- Key lesson from 5 decades of social justice activism: "fighting hate should be fun"
- "It's being a hater that sucks"
