AI summary by TwinMind

M4 Max MacBook Pro: I'm Convinced!

Marques Brownlee

12m 31s

Current Setup and Upgrade Motivation

  • Using M1 Max MacBook Pro for 3 years since release
  • Felt no compulsion to upgrade until M4 generation
  • Work mostly light except occasional video editing on-the-go
  • M4 generation first to tempt upgrade due to strategic improvements

M4 Performance Improvements

  • M4 represents first significant leap since M1 generational change
  • M1→M2→M3→M4 incremental improvements now stacking meaningfully
  • Nobody with M2/M3 needs upgrade, but M1→M4 gap now compelling

Hardware Specifications Comparison

  • M1 Max (current): 64GB unified memory, 400GB/s memory bandwidth
  • M4 Max (testing): 128GB unified memory, 546GB/s memory bandwidth
  • 3nm process vs 5nm, all cores better/faster

Apple's Performance Claims

  • Up to 2.2x faster CPU performance vs M1 Max
  • 1.9x faster GPU performance vs M1 Max
  • Roughly 2x performance improvement overall

Synthetic Benchmarks

  • Geekbench 6 CPU single core: 4,000+ (highest single core score ever in Mac)
  • Multicore score tops charts
  • GPU performance approaching M2 Ultra levels (not M2 Max)
  • M4 Max GPU bumping against current Mac Pro M2 Ultra chips

Real-World Video Editing Performance

  • Primary workflow: Final Cut Pro video editing
  • Test project: 8K RED raw footage + action camera footage + comped graphics + Snapchat glasses clips
  • M4 Max opened/navigated Final Cut faster than any previous machine
  • Export times: roughly 2x faster than M1 Max

Final Cut Pro 11 Magnetic Mask Feature

  • New AI-powered subject masking feature
  • Leverages neural engine heavily
  • Replaces manual rotoscoping process
  • Performance comparison (45-second clip):
    • M1 Max: 2 minutes 56 seconds
    • M4 Max: 2 minutes 13 seconds
    • M2 Ultra: 1 minute 30 seconds
    • Intel Mac Pro (dual Radeon Pro GPUs): 6 minutes
  • M4 Ultra expected to be exceptional for video editing

Photography and Other Workflows

  • Referenced Tyler Stallman's M4 Max testing
  • Lightroom and Resolve performance crushes M1 Max
  • Sometimes matches/beats M2 Ultra Mac Studio
  • Apple silicon improving fast enough that laptop chips outperform earlier desktop chips

Design and Display Improvements

Color Options

  • Space Black and Silver (same as M3 generation)
  • Space Black collects fingerprints, wears over time
  • Recommended solution: dbrand skin for scratch protection

Nanotexture Display Option

  • New feature for M4 generation
  • $100 upgrade option (vs $1,000 on Pro Display XDR, $300 on Studio Display)
  • Matte finish eliminates reflections completely
  • Works across all lighting environments (office, coffee shop, airplane)
  • Maintenance concerns addressed since iPad Pro implementation
  • Compelling upgrade reason by itself

Connectivity and Ports

Thunderbolt 5 Implementation

  • Upgraded from Thunderbolt 4 on previous generation
  • Base 14" MacBook Pro gains additional port (all models now have 3x Thunderbolt 5)
  • Genuine capability improvement: 3x 6K displays vs 2x previously
  • Limited accessory ecosystem currently
  • Storage comparison:
    • Samsung X5 Thunderbolt 3: 2,800MB/s, ~$275 for 2TB equivalent
    • OWC Thunderbolt 5: 6,000MB/s read/write, $400 for 2TB
  • Future-proofing benefit as Thunderbolt 5 ecosystem develops

Additional Improvements

Webcam and Battery

  • New center stage ultrawide webcam with person tracking
  • Improved image quality
  • Slightly better battery life due to M4 efficiency improvements
  • Same battery size with better efficiency

Display Enhancements

  • Higher SDR max brightness: 1,000 nits (vs 500-600 nits previously)
  • Better readability in bright environments
  • Quiet upgrade: All MacBook Pros now use quantum dot displays
  • Improved efficiency and responsiveness
  • Still progressing toward OLED future

Upgrade Justification and Recommendations

Cumulative Value Proposition

  • Individual improvements might not justify upgrade alone
  • Combined improvements create compelling case for users pushing laptop limits
  • M1 Max remains perfectly adequate for another year
  • Upgrade justified for users regularly maxing out performance

Apple Intelligence Impact

  • AI requirements driving 16GB unified memory minimum across all Macs
  • Makes base Mac models better value proposition
  • Mac Mini particularly compelling with new specs

Future Outlook

  • More M4 chips coming (M4 Ultra expected)
  • Current M4 generation represents significant milestone in Apple silicon evolution

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome