AI summary by TwinMind
M4 Max MacBook Pro: I'm Convinced!
Marques Brownlee
12m 31s
Current Setup and Upgrade Motivation
- Using M1 Max MacBook Pro for 3 years since release
- Felt no compulsion to upgrade until M4 generation
- Work mostly light except occasional video editing on-the-go
- M4 generation first to tempt upgrade due to strategic improvements
M4 Performance Improvements
- M4 represents first significant leap since M1 generational change
- M1→M2→M3→M4 incremental improvements now stacking meaningfully
- Nobody with M2/M3 needs upgrade, but M1→M4 gap now compelling
Hardware Specifications Comparison
- M1 Max (current): 64GB unified memory, 400GB/s memory bandwidth
- M4 Max (testing): 128GB unified memory, 546GB/s memory bandwidth
- 3nm process vs 5nm, all cores better/faster
Apple's Performance Claims
- Up to 2.2x faster CPU performance vs M1 Max
- 1.9x faster GPU performance vs M1 Max
- Roughly 2x performance improvement overall
Synthetic Benchmarks
- Geekbench 6 CPU single core: 4,000+ (highest single core score ever in Mac)
- Multicore score tops charts
- GPU performance approaching M2 Ultra levels (not M2 Max)
- M4 Max GPU bumping against current Mac Pro M2 Ultra chips
Real-World Video Editing Performance
- Primary workflow: Final Cut Pro video editing
- Test project: 8K RED raw footage + action camera footage + comped graphics + Snapchat glasses clips
- M4 Max opened/navigated Final Cut faster than any previous machine
- Export times: roughly 2x faster than M1 Max
Final Cut Pro 11 Magnetic Mask Feature
- New AI-powered subject masking feature
- Leverages neural engine heavily
- Replaces manual rotoscoping process
- Performance comparison (45-second clip):
- M1 Max: 2 minutes 56 seconds
- M4 Max: 2 minutes 13 seconds
- M2 Ultra: 1 minute 30 seconds
- Intel Mac Pro (dual Radeon Pro GPUs): 6 minutes
- M4 Ultra expected to be exceptional for video editing
Photography and Other Workflows
- Referenced Tyler Stallman's M4 Max testing
- Lightroom and Resolve performance crushes M1 Max
- Sometimes matches/beats M2 Ultra Mac Studio
- Apple silicon improving fast enough that laptop chips outperform earlier desktop chips
Design and Display Improvements
Color Options
- Space Black and Silver (same as M3 generation)
- Space Black collects fingerprints, wears over time
- Recommended solution: dbrand skin for scratch protection
Nanotexture Display Option
- New feature for M4 generation
- $100 upgrade option (vs $1,000 on Pro Display XDR, $300 on Studio Display)
- Matte finish eliminates reflections completely
- Works across all lighting environments (office, coffee shop, airplane)
- Maintenance concerns addressed since iPad Pro implementation
- Compelling upgrade reason by itself
Connectivity and Ports
Thunderbolt 5 Implementation
- Upgraded from Thunderbolt 4 on previous generation
- Base 14" MacBook Pro gains additional port (all models now have 3x Thunderbolt 5)
- Genuine capability improvement: 3x 6K displays vs 2x previously
- Limited accessory ecosystem currently
- Storage comparison:
- Samsung X5 Thunderbolt 3: 2,800MB/s, ~$275 for 2TB equivalent
- OWC Thunderbolt 5: 6,000MB/s read/write, $400 for 2TB
- Future-proofing benefit as Thunderbolt 5 ecosystem develops
Additional Improvements
Webcam and Battery
- New center stage ultrawide webcam with person tracking
- Improved image quality
- Slightly better battery life due to M4 efficiency improvements
- Same battery size with better efficiency
Display Enhancements
- Higher SDR max brightness: 1,000 nits (vs 500-600 nits previously)
- Better readability in bright environments
- Quiet upgrade: All MacBook Pros now use quantum dot displays
- Improved efficiency and responsiveness
- Still progressing toward OLED future
Upgrade Justification and Recommendations
Cumulative Value Proposition
- Individual improvements might not justify upgrade alone
- Combined improvements create compelling case for users pushing laptop limits
- M1 Max remains perfectly adequate for another year
- Upgrade justified for users regularly maxing out performance
Apple Intelligence Impact
- AI requirements driving 16GB unified memory minimum across all Macs
- Makes base Mac models better value proposition
- Mac Mini particularly compelling with new specs
Future Outlook
- More M4 chips coming (M4 Ultra expected)
- Current M4 generation represents significant milestone in Apple silicon evolution
