AI summary by TwinMind

Maggie Jackson | Uncertain: The Wisdom and Wonder of Being Unsure | Talks at Google

Talks at Google

32m 3s

Introduction and Definitions

  • Mike Abrams hosts Maggie Jackson at Google
  • Jackson: award-winning author, journalist, former Boston Globe columnist
  • Book: "Uncertain" - explores science of uncertainty
  • Two major types of uncertainty:
    • Aleatoric: unpredictability/volatility of world (stock market fluctuations)
    • Epistemic: human psychological response to unknown
      • Meeting limits of knowledge between assumptions/expectations and new reality
      • Traffic jam example: caught between expectation and reality with sense of possibility

Origins and Research Discovery

  • Book started as chapter on thinking in digital age
  • Initially viewed uncertainty as obstacle to eliminate
  • Three key discoveries:
    • Topic highly understudied until recently
      • Efficiency/outcome-oriented culture overlooked process
      • Even Daniel Kahneman didn't address directly
    • Explosion of new research contradicting popular assumptions
    • Natural human aversion to uncertainty but cultural/individual "allergy" needs pushback

Scientific Benefits of Uncertainty

  • Drives curiosity and human adaptability
  • Foundation for creativity
  • Essential for mental wellbeing and resilience
  • Critical for superior collaboration
  • Skills needed in volatile times

Neuroscience of Uncertainty vs. Anxiety

  • Common misconception: direct link between uncertainty and anxiety
  • Uncertainty triggers stress response but creates "good stress"
  • Brain changes during uncertainty:
    • Working memory bolstered
    • More receptive to new data at neuronal level
    • Focus sharpens and broadens ("curious eyes")
  • University of Washington study: Emergency room physicians report heightened attention when unsure
  • Joseph Kable (University of Pennsylvania): "uncertainty is when your brain is telling itself there's something to be learned here"
  • Arousal vs. fear response use different nervous systems
  • Fear response: blood flows away from extremities (including brain) toward core

Outcome Fixation and Performance

  • Fixating on outcomes diverts cognitive resources from process
  • Tennis study: 100 top professional matches
    • When trophy displayed prominently during finals, favorites struggle and lose points
  • Q-words strategy from professional athletes:
    • Personal mantras to stay present ("be now," "focus here")
    • Keeps athletes in the moment rather than focused on outcome

Digital Age and Technology Impact

  • Personal concerns about digital living undermining uncertainty's potential
  • Online aesthetics: neat, quick, sure - fuels heuristic reactive thinking
  • Search behavior issues:
    • Users take first search result without looking further
    • Daniel Russell (Google search quality lead) warns against this
    • Creates hubris - people think they know more than they do
  • Memory concerns:
    • Technology interfering with natural memory functions
    • Ability to forget/misremember important for meaning-making
    • Outsourcing memory impedes abstraction process
    • Struggle to recall activates synaptic connections and strengthens mind

AI and Uncertainty

  • New movement for "unsure AI" led by Stuart Russell, Yoshua Bengio
  • Traditional AI: rationalist definition pursuing goals at any cost
  • New AI approach:
    • More honest, transparent, reflective about multiple options
    • Admits uncertainty percentages to humans
    • Example: cop robot 30% unsure of suspect identity vs. traditional "shoot" command
  • User studies show unsure AI seen as more intelligent, cooperative, better performer
  • AI developers report cultivating similar qualities in themselves
  • Potential for AI to hold mirror to humans, modeling uncertainty skills

Workplace and Team Dynamics

  • Uncertainty as social phenomenon, not solo act
  • Agreement as "opiate" to teams:
    • Teams think they're more similar than they are
    • Lose sight of diversity
    • Become less accurate and creative
    • Performance declines while thinking they're doing great
  • Discord benefits:
    • Intensifies discussions
    • Unearths "hidden profile" of diverse information
    • Creates skepticism, questioning, learning limits

Mars Exploration Rover Team Case Study

  • Considered most innovative team in space exploration history
  • Faulty command incident: instead of demanding agreement, leaders encouraged questioning
  • One in five conversations were "micro conflicts" - respectful disagreement
  • Expressions of uncertainty: "maybe," "I don't know," "I'm not sure"
  • Hedge words signal receptiveness and acknowledge more to know
  • Listening ritual: every meeting ended with call for countering voices
  • "Holding on to doubt" as key to success

Tolerance of Uncertainty as Personality Trait

  • Intolerance of uncertainty:
    • Rigid thinking, jump to conclusions
    • Black and white thinking
    • See uncertainty as threat
    • During pandemic: more likely to use denial, avoidance, substance abuse
  • Tolerance of uncertainty:
    • Curious, flexible thinking
    • See uncertainty as challenge
  • Targeted interventions proven to improve resilience
  • Used as anxiety treatment (fear of unknown vs. uncertainty itself)

Practical Strategies

  • Delegate more at work (proven tool)
  • Try new dishes, travel to countries where you don't speak language
  • Answer phone without caller ID (terrifying for younger generation)
  • Personal example: ocean swimming in all seasons as "daily dose of uncertainty"
  • "Bite off a little more of the unknown each day"
  • Learning about uncertainty positively described as "liberating"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome