AI summary by TwinMind
Mariana Mazzucato | Mission Economy: A Moonshot Guide to Changing Capitalism | Talks at Google
Talks at Google
46m 49s
Introduction and Background
- Matt Bon Jovi hosts Mariana Mazzucato, Professor of Economics at UCL
- Mazzucato: founding director UCL Institute for Innovation and Public Purpose
- Advisory roles: Chair WHO Council on Economics of Health for All, Scottish Government Council of Economic Advisors
- Author: "The Entrepreneurial State," "The Value of Everything," "Mission Economy: A Moonshot Guide to Changing Capitalism"
- Book inspired by Apollo program's coordination of public-private sectors
Mission-Oriented Government Approach
- Instead of handing out subsidies/guarantees to sectors/companies without clear purpose
- Start with problem identification: what mission/targeted outcome needed
- Transform 17 UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) into specific missions
- Examples: 90% plastic removal from oceans, 100 carbon neutral cities across Europe, zero knife crime among London teenagers
- Reframe policy instruments (industrial strategy, procurement, loans/grants) to galvanize bottom-up experimentation
- Requires stakeholder engagement beyond top-down approach
- Resident associations, social housing groups, policymakers, businesses collaborating
- Example: sustainability strategies including retrofitting housing, urban food systems
Public Sector Risk-Taking and Innovation
- Challenge: public sector not taught/encouraged to think outside box or take calculated risks
- Private sector myth: not all companies take risks, many prefer status quo
- Need entrepreneurial ecosystem, not individual company focus
- Current bureaucracy problems:
- Civil servant mistakes become front-page news
- "Picking winners" criticism leads to horizontal background conditions only
- Faulty approach: would never have had internet, biotech, nanotech, green tech revolutions
- Required: investment, risk-taking, portfolio thinking, market shaping
- Need strategic decisions to train civil servants differently
- Frame policy as co-creation/co-shaping, not just fixing market failures
Apollo Program Lessons
- Clear outcome direction, open on methodology
- Massive innovation across sectors: camera phones, athletic shoes, home insulation, foil blankets, scratch-resistant lenses, software
- Multiple sectors involved: nutrition, electronics, software
- NASA procurement strategy changes:
- From vague cost-plus contracts to fixed-price contracts with quality/innovation incentives
- No excess profits clause (collective investment principle)
- Avoided "gambling casino" approach
- Ernest Brackett (NASA procurement head): warned against "brochuremanship" - need internal capabilities to avoid capture by sexy brochures/PowerPoints
- Example of current problem: UK government outsourcing test and trace to Deloitte without relevant expertise
Organizational Design and Capabilities
- Apollo 1 fire (January 27, 1967): communication breakdown between buildings
- George Mueller from Bell Labs created agile, flexible teams
- Project managers with ambitious goals and inter-team communication
- Mission-oriented approach requires organizational redesign, not just policy changes
- UCL Institute for Innovation and Public Purpose: new training/curriculum like MBA for public sector
- Strategic management, organizational behavior, decision sciences
- Focus: value creation understanding, creative bureaucracies, design thinking for platform governance
- Obama quote: "last time we rethought government was in age of black and white TV"
Technology Investment and Value Creation
- 75% of smartphone tech (internet, GPS, touchscreen, Siri) came from government investment
- Health: 75% new molecular entities with priority rating from NIH funding
- Energy: similar government early-stage risk-taking
- Problem: socializing risks but privatizing rewards
- Digital platforms, health system: intellectual property rights too wide, strong, upstream
- Drug prices don't reflect $40 billion annual NIH investment
- Need design changes in IP rights, public-private partnerships, access, pricing
Bell Labs Historical Example
- AT&T monopoly came with conditions: reinvest profits into economy/innovation
- Bell Labs was AT&T's response to conditionality requirement
- Concept: conditionality/social contract should be embedded across sectors
- NIH has margin rights to set drug prices but never implemented
- Narrative problem: health innovation seen as private sector-led with government as regulator/redistributor
- Need recognition of state as active investor, risk-taker, co-investor
Google Algorithm and Public Investment
- Google algorithm initially funded by National Science Foundation grants to Brin and colleagues
- Could have had conditions: grant yours if things go wrong, but if earn over X billion, percentage returns to public innovation fund
- Tesla vs Solyndra case study:
- Both received similar DOE guaranteed loans (~$465 million to Tesla)
- Solyndra failed, became symbol of government failure
- Tesla succeeded, paid back 2013
- Tesla share price: $9 (2009) to $90 (2013)
- 3 million shares difference would have covered Solyndra loss plus next investment round
- Lesson: socialize rewards, not just risks (standard venture capitalist approach)
Narrative and Storytelling Importance
- Solyndra widely known as government failure
- Tesla's government investment largely unknown
- Storytelling crucial for:
- Attracting top talent to government
- Creating "skin in the game" feeling
- Co-creating better world vs. just facilitating others
- Kennedy speech: "doing it because it's hard, not because it's easy"
- Taking on difficulties together vs. facilitating/making easier for others
- Current health sector: often parasitic vs. mutualistic partnerships
Progressive Politics and Wealth Creation
- Obama healthcare narrative problem: didn't debunk "intervention" criticism
- Should have emphasized: 75% of drugs invested by government
- Left/progressives globally: can't have agenda just about redistribution
- Need narrative about wealth creation, not just redistribution
- Historical understanding plus future vision for green economy
- Portfolio investment analysis understanding lacking
Stakeholder Value and Business Model Changes
- Business Roundtable, BlackRock discussions on purpose-driven investment
- Stakeholder value vs. shareholder value maximization
- Current approach: mostly internal corporate governance, ESG metrics
- Need design changes in:
- Ecosystem structure
- Public-private partnerships
- Digital platform governance
- Health systems
- Intellectual property rights
- Benefit sharing mechanisms
- COVID-19 vaccine example: huge public-private investment but "vaccine apartheid"
- 80% doses hoarded by 10% of countries
- Can't be resolved by charity alone
- Need business model designed around common good
- Health pandemic requires common good approach to prevent mutation
Inflation and Government Spending
- Historical data (200 years US): constant deflation until WWII, regular economic crashes
- Keynesian revolution: counter-cyclical government spending
- Post-WWII: stable output growth, moderate inflation (normal for healthy economy)
- Recent years: deflation, zero interest rates (opposite of inflation)
- Current inflation concerns as economy picks up post-COVID
- Key distinction: healthy vs. excessive inflation
- Government investment expanding productive capacity prevents problematic inflation
- Problem occurs when money supply increases without expanding GDP/productive capacity
- Recovery mechanisms must land in more productive, innovative economy
- Not just "helicopter money from sky"
Hamilton vs. Jefferson Paradox
- US: "acts Hamilton but talks Jefferson"
- Hamilton: industrial strategy proponent
- Jefferson: free market advocate
- US actually does industrial strategy (NIH, SBIR, DOD, DARPA) but talks free market
- Europe: talks Hamiltonian but walks Jeffersonian
- Learning problem: without proper discourse, no organizational learning
- Mission-Oriented Innovation Network: global platform for public organizations
- Examples: CORFO (Chile), Yozma (Israel), Sitra (Finland), Vinnova (Sweden), BNDES (Brazil), KfW (Germany)
- Hewlett Foundation funding for US network launch
- Need open conversation vs. behind-scenes discussions
Long-term Mission Sustainability
- Electoral cycle challenge: 4-5 year terms vs. long-term missions
- Organizational level solutions:
- DARPA model: 5-year terms, independent of electoral cycles
- Career advancement based on risk-taking, not safe bets
- Need societal consensus on missions (e.g., climate change)
- Communication challenges: avoid condescending approach
- Citizen assemblies, town halls for SDG discussions
- Local level implementation: Camden Renewal Commission example
- Public spaces for safe disagreement vs. social media hate
- Organizations like DARPA needed in health, energy (not just defense)
- Adequate funding for politically independent programs
Italy Development Example
- IRI (state-owned enterprise): three phases
- Public, non-politicized: honor to work there, created Autostrada del Sole (8 years)
- Public, super-politicized: all parties involved, failure
- Privatization: complete failure
- Lesson: not public vs. private, but how programs organized
- Public programs: purpose-oriented but de-politicized
- DARPA model applicable to social concerns, not just defense
Developing Countries Application
- Mission approach even more important for countries with weak states
- Weak states produce corruption, capture, mafias
- Historical example: Italian mafia originated from weak state governance
- "La Società de Berti Paoli" mutual self-help group became modern mafia seed
- Need: metrics, principles around public value/purpose
- Accountability with strength, not strength for its own sake
- South Africa example: advisor to Cyril Ramaphosa
- Eskom (state-owned energy company): public but problematic
- Public-public conditionality: what conditions for Eskom to exist?
- Role in energy transition vs. holding incumbent monopoly positions
Women Economists and Research
- Research built on work by women economists
- Historical pattern: women thinkers often ignored across disciplines
- Women economists often put life at center of theory:
- Eleanor Ostrom: common good approaches
- Stephanie Kelton: ask what problem is first, then create money (like with war funding)
- Kate Raworth: circular economy
- Carlota Perez: long waves of technological change, intersection of finance/productive capacity/state
- Need new theory to guide new practice
- Uncover "useless economic theory" currently guiding policy making
