AI summary by TwinMind

Mariana Mazzucato | Mission Economy: A Moonshot Guide to Changing Capitalism | Talks at Google

Talks at Google

46m 49s

Introduction and Background

  • Matt Bon Jovi hosts Mariana Mazzucato, Professor of Economics at UCL
  • Mazzucato: founding director UCL Institute for Innovation and Public Purpose
  • Advisory roles: Chair WHO Council on Economics of Health for All, Scottish Government Council of Economic Advisors
  • Author: "The Entrepreneurial State," "The Value of Everything," "Mission Economy: A Moonshot Guide to Changing Capitalism"
  • Book inspired by Apollo program's coordination of public-private sectors

Mission-Oriented Government Approach

  • Instead of handing out subsidies/guarantees to sectors/companies without clear purpose
  • Start with problem identification: what mission/targeted outcome needed
  • Transform 17 UN Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) into specific missions
    • Examples: 90% plastic removal from oceans, 100 carbon neutral cities across Europe, zero knife crime among London teenagers
  • Reframe policy instruments (industrial strategy, procurement, loans/grants) to galvanize bottom-up experimentation
  • Requires stakeholder engagement beyond top-down approach
    • Resident associations, social housing groups, policymakers, businesses collaborating
    • Example: sustainability strategies including retrofitting housing, urban food systems

Public Sector Risk-Taking and Innovation

  • Challenge: public sector not taught/encouraged to think outside box or take calculated risks
  • Private sector myth: not all companies take risks, many prefer status quo
  • Need entrepreneurial ecosystem, not individual company focus
  • Current bureaucracy problems:
    • Civil servant mistakes become front-page news
    • "Picking winners" criticism leads to horizontal background conditions only
    • Faulty approach: would never have had internet, biotech, nanotech, green tech revolutions
  • Required: investment, risk-taking, portfolio thinking, market shaping
  • Need strategic decisions to train civil servants differently
  • Frame policy as co-creation/co-shaping, not just fixing market failures

Apollo Program Lessons

  • Clear outcome direction, open on methodology
  • Massive innovation across sectors: camera phones, athletic shoes, home insulation, foil blankets, scratch-resistant lenses, software
  • Multiple sectors involved: nutrition, electronics, software
  • NASA procurement strategy changes:
    • From vague cost-plus contracts to fixed-price contracts with quality/innovation incentives
    • No excess profits clause (collective investment principle)
    • Avoided "gambling casino" approach
  • Ernest Brackett (NASA procurement head): warned against "brochuremanship" - need internal capabilities to avoid capture by sexy brochures/PowerPoints
  • Example of current problem: UK government outsourcing test and trace to Deloitte without relevant expertise

Organizational Design and Capabilities

  • Apollo 1 fire (January 27, 1967): communication breakdown between buildings
  • George Mueller from Bell Labs created agile, flexible teams
  • Project managers with ambitious goals and inter-team communication
  • Mission-oriented approach requires organizational redesign, not just policy changes
  • UCL Institute for Innovation and Public Purpose: new training/curriculum like MBA for public sector
    • Strategic management, organizational behavior, decision sciences
    • Focus: value creation understanding, creative bureaucracies, design thinking for platform governance
  • Obama quote: "last time we rethought government was in age of black and white TV"

Technology Investment and Value Creation

  • 75% of smartphone tech (internet, GPS, touchscreen, Siri) came from government investment
  • Health: 75% new molecular entities with priority rating from NIH funding
  • Energy: similar government early-stage risk-taking
  • Problem: socializing risks but privatizing rewards
  • Digital platforms, health system: intellectual property rights too wide, strong, upstream
  • Drug prices don't reflect $40 billion annual NIH investment
  • Need design changes in IP rights, public-private partnerships, access, pricing

Bell Labs Historical Example

  • AT&T monopoly came with conditions: reinvest profits into economy/innovation
  • Bell Labs was AT&T's response to conditionality requirement
  • Concept: conditionality/social contract should be embedded across sectors
  • NIH has margin rights to set drug prices but never implemented
  • Narrative problem: health innovation seen as private sector-led with government as regulator/redistributor
  • Need recognition of state as active investor, risk-taker, co-investor

Google Algorithm and Public Investment

  • Google algorithm initially funded by National Science Foundation grants to Brin and colleagues
  • Could have had conditions: grant yours if things go wrong, but if earn over X billion, percentage returns to public innovation fund
  • Tesla vs Solyndra case study:
    • Both received similar DOE guaranteed loans (~$465 million to Tesla)
    • Solyndra failed, became symbol of government failure
    • Tesla succeeded, paid back 2013
    • Tesla share price: $9 (2009) to $90 (2013)
    • 3 million shares difference would have covered Solyndra loss plus next investment round
    • Lesson: socialize rewards, not just risks (standard venture capitalist approach)

Narrative and Storytelling Importance

  • Solyndra widely known as government failure
  • Tesla's government investment largely unknown
  • Storytelling crucial for:
    • Attracting top talent to government
    • Creating "skin in the game" feeling
    • Co-creating better world vs. just facilitating others
  • Kennedy speech: "doing it because it's hard, not because it's easy"
  • Taking on difficulties together vs. facilitating/making easier for others
  • Current health sector: often parasitic vs. mutualistic partnerships

Progressive Politics and Wealth Creation

  • Obama healthcare narrative problem: didn't debunk "intervention" criticism
  • Should have emphasized: 75% of drugs invested by government
  • Left/progressives globally: can't have agenda just about redistribution
  • Need narrative about wealth creation, not just redistribution
  • Historical understanding plus future vision for green economy
  • Portfolio investment analysis understanding lacking

Stakeholder Value and Business Model Changes

  • Business Roundtable, BlackRock discussions on purpose-driven investment
  • Stakeholder value vs. shareholder value maximization
  • Current approach: mostly internal corporate governance, ESG metrics
  • Need design changes in:
    • Ecosystem structure
    • Public-private partnerships
    • Digital platform governance
    • Health systems
    • Intellectual property rights
    • Benefit sharing mechanisms
  • COVID-19 vaccine example: huge public-private investment but "vaccine apartheid"
    • 80% doses hoarded by 10% of countries
    • Can't be resolved by charity alone
    • Need business model designed around common good
    • Health pandemic requires common good approach to prevent mutation

Inflation and Government Spending

  • Historical data (200 years US): constant deflation until WWII, regular economic crashes
  • Keynesian revolution: counter-cyclical government spending
  • Post-WWII: stable output growth, moderate inflation (normal for healthy economy)
  • Recent years: deflation, zero interest rates (opposite of inflation)
  • Current inflation concerns as economy picks up post-COVID
  • Key distinction: healthy vs. excessive inflation
  • Government investment expanding productive capacity prevents problematic inflation
  • Problem occurs when money supply increases without expanding GDP/productive capacity
  • Recovery mechanisms must land in more productive, innovative economy
  • Not just "helicopter money from sky"

Hamilton vs. Jefferson Paradox

  • US: "acts Hamilton but talks Jefferson"
  • Hamilton: industrial strategy proponent
  • Jefferson: free market advocate
  • US actually does industrial strategy (NIH, SBIR, DOD, DARPA) but talks free market
  • Europe: talks Hamiltonian but walks Jeffersonian
  • Learning problem: without proper discourse, no organizational learning
  • Mission-Oriented Innovation Network: global platform for public organizations
    • Examples: CORFO (Chile), Yozma (Israel), Sitra (Finland), Vinnova (Sweden), BNDES (Brazil), KfW (Germany)
  • Hewlett Foundation funding for US network launch
  • Need open conversation vs. behind-scenes discussions

Long-term Mission Sustainability

  • Electoral cycle challenge: 4-5 year terms vs. long-term missions
  • Organizational level solutions:
    • DARPA model: 5-year terms, independent of electoral cycles
    • Career advancement based on risk-taking, not safe bets
  • Need societal consensus on missions (e.g., climate change)
  • Communication challenges: avoid condescending approach
  • Citizen assemblies, town halls for SDG discussions
  • Local level implementation: Camden Renewal Commission example
  • Public spaces for safe disagreement vs. social media hate
  • Organizations like DARPA needed in health, energy (not just defense)
  • Adequate funding for politically independent programs

Italy Development Example

  • IRI (state-owned enterprise): three phases
    1. Public, non-politicized: honor to work there, created Autostrada del Sole (8 years)
    2. Public, super-politicized: all parties involved, failure
    3. Privatization: complete failure
  • Lesson: not public vs. private, but how programs organized
  • Public programs: purpose-oriented but de-politicized
  • DARPA model applicable to social concerns, not just defense

Developing Countries Application

  • Mission approach even more important for countries with weak states
  • Weak states produce corruption, capture, mafias
  • Historical example: Italian mafia originated from weak state governance
  • "La Società de Berti Paoli" mutual self-help group became modern mafia seed
  • Need: metrics, principles around public value/purpose
  • Accountability with strength, not strength for its own sake
  • South Africa example: advisor to Cyril Ramaphosa
  • Eskom (state-owned energy company): public but problematic
  • Public-public conditionality: what conditions for Eskom to exist?
  • Role in energy transition vs. holding incumbent monopoly positions

Women Economists and Research

  • Research built on work by women economists
  • Historical pattern: women thinkers often ignored across disciplines
  • Women economists often put life at center of theory:
    • Eleanor Ostrom: common good approaches
    • Stephanie Kelton: ask what problem is first, then create money (like with war funding)
    • Kate Raworth: circular economy
    • Carlota Perez: long waves of technological change, intersection of finance/productive capacity/state
  • Need new theory to guide new practice
  • Uncover "useless economic theory" currently guiding policy making

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome