AI summary by TwinMind

Memestocks Won't Make You Rich (Probably)

The Plain Bagel

17m 34s

Introduction & Context

  • Richard from Plain Bagel revisiting "investing won't make you rich" topic
  • Third video on this theme (first 5 years ago about get-rich-quick schemes, second 2 years later during crypto/NFT height)
  • Triggered by James Janney's GameStop documentary where Richard contributed research
  • Focus on MOASS (Mother of All Short Squeezes) believers vs. general GameStop supporters

Historical Context of Meme Stocks

  • Peak meme stock activity in 2021 with GameStop short interest >100%
  • Short squeeze mechanism: rising prices force short sellers to buy back stock, creating positive feedback loop
  • Recent price jumps occurred but short interest now well below 2021 peaks
  • Persistent belief among some that hedge funds never closed positions, just hid them using complex instruments

Investment Mathematics Reality Check

  • Example: turning $10,000 into $1 million
    • With 9% annual return (5.8% real after 3% inflation)
    • 40 years: need $6,100/year additional savings ($500/month)
    • 20 years: need $27,000/year additional savings ($2,200/month)
    • 10 years: need 63.2% annual returns with no additional savings
  • Keith Gil's 2021 success created false perception of feasibility
  • Exceptional returns extremely rare; most who try to beat market fail

Meme Stock Track Record Analysis

  • GameStop stands out as exception, not rule
  • Other meme stocks performance:
    • Bed Bath & Beyond: 100% loss, bankruptcy extinguished investor shares
    • AMC: down 90% over 5 years
    • Nokia: down 10%
    • Blackberry: down 50%
    • Yellow & Tupperware: filed bankruptcy
  • GameStop survival aided by $4.6 billion cash raised from share issuances when price was high

Problems with MOASS Theory

Share Dilution Impact

  • GameStop increased shares outstanding by 71% since first rally
  • Makes retail ownership of float even less feasible
  • Contradicts theory that retail could control share supply

Lack of Evidence for Hidden Short Interest

  • Public short interest much lower than 2021 levels
  • Claims of massive hidden shorts lack extraordinary evidence
  • Self-reported data has limitations but no proof of deception
  • "Weird market activity" cited as evidence:
    • High dark pool activity
    • Options trading waves
    • XRT ETF high short interest (retail ETF containing GameStop)

XRT ETF Analysis

  • GameStop represents <1.5% of XRT fund
  • Theory: hedge funds short ETF, hedge other positions to create net GameStop short
  • Alternative explanations exist:
    • Buggy short interest reporting
    • Authorized participant ETF creation activity
    • Current XRT short interest less than 2011 levels (pre-GameStop rally)

Key Figure Analysis

Ryan Cohen Assessment

  • Not taking salary, successfully sold businesses before
  • No demonstrated track record turning companies around
  • Recently sued for insider trading around Bed Bath & Beyond
  • Settled lawsuit for Wells Fargo stake purchase without regulatory disclosure
  • Actions contradict transparency calls from GameStop movement

Keith Gill (Roaring Kitty)

  • Never explicitly promoted MOASS narrative
  • Explicitly told people not to follow his trades
  • Recent call options exercise didn't trigger expected squeeze

Online Influencer Concerns

  • Many prioritize narrative maintenance over truth
  • Example: Trey Trades (AMC promoter) later admitted being wrong, promoted without disclosure
  • People still claim Bed Bath & Beyond shareholders will get money back despite share extinction
  • No financial consequences for wrong predictions

Evolving MOASS Goalpost Movement

  • Share vote theory (prove fake shares) - didn't happen
  • Direct registration strategy (reduce short supply) - no effect
  • Keith Gill return/options exercise - no squeeze
  • Current focus: company cash for acquisitions
  • Having cash not inherently valuable if poor capital allocation
  • Better ROI available in savings accounts/treasury bills than poorly managed companies

Broader Market Corruption Context

  • Wall Street corruption exists and frustrations are valid
  • CNBC talking heads and firms not without sin
  • Nefarious actors likely abuse retail investors
  • However: corruption evidence ≠ evidence of massive GameStop short interest
  • Most money managers likely don't care about GameStop 3 years later

Investment Philosophy Conclusion

  • Normal market performance (9% annually) can be incredibly helpful over time
  • Investing can't solve all problems or make up for spending issues without decent salary
  • Prudent investing still valuable tool
  • Distinguish between supporting company vs. expecting get-rich-quick returns
  • Be careful with online personalities promoting overconfidence
  • People promoting MOASS bear no consequences for wrong predictions

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome