AI summary by TwinMind
Memestocks Won't Make You Rich (Probably)
The Plain Bagel
17m 34s
Introduction & Context
- Richard from Plain Bagel revisiting "investing won't make you rich" topic
- Third video on this theme (first 5 years ago about get-rich-quick schemes, second 2 years later during crypto/NFT height)
- Triggered by James Janney's GameStop documentary where Richard contributed research
- Focus on MOASS (Mother of All Short Squeezes) believers vs. general GameStop supporters
Historical Context of Meme Stocks
- Peak meme stock activity in 2021 with GameStop short interest >100%
- Short squeeze mechanism: rising prices force short sellers to buy back stock, creating positive feedback loop
- Recent price jumps occurred but short interest now well below 2021 peaks
- Persistent belief among some that hedge funds never closed positions, just hid them using complex instruments
Investment Mathematics Reality Check
- Example: turning $10,000 into $1 million
- With 9% annual return (5.8% real after 3% inflation)
- 40 years: need $6,100/year additional savings ($500/month)
- 20 years: need $27,000/year additional savings ($2,200/month)
- 10 years: need 63.2% annual returns with no additional savings
- Keith Gil's 2021 success created false perception of feasibility
- Exceptional returns extremely rare; most who try to beat market fail
Meme Stock Track Record Analysis
- GameStop stands out as exception, not rule
- Other meme stocks performance:
- Bed Bath & Beyond: 100% loss, bankruptcy extinguished investor shares
- AMC: down 90% over 5 years
- Nokia: down 10%
- Blackberry: down 50%
- Yellow & Tupperware: filed bankruptcy
- GameStop survival aided by $4.6 billion cash raised from share issuances when price was high
Problems with MOASS Theory
Share Dilution Impact
- GameStop increased shares outstanding by 71% since first rally
- Makes retail ownership of float even less feasible
- Contradicts theory that retail could control share supply
Lack of Evidence for Hidden Short Interest
- Public short interest much lower than 2021 levels
- Claims of massive hidden shorts lack extraordinary evidence
- Self-reported data has limitations but no proof of deception
- "Weird market activity" cited as evidence:
- High dark pool activity
- Options trading waves
- XRT ETF high short interest (retail ETF containing GameStop)
XRT ETF Analysis
- GameStop represents <1.5% of XRT fund
- Theory: hedge funds short ETF, hedge other positions to create net GameStop short
- Alternative explanations exist:
- Buggy short interest reporting
- Authorized participant ETF creation activity
- Current XRT short interest less than 2011 levels (pre-GameStop rally)
Key Figure Analysis
Ryan Cohen Assessment
- Not taking salary, successfully sold businesses before
- No demonstrated track record turning companies around
- Recently sued for insider trading around Bed Bath & Beyond
- Settled lawsuit for Wells Fargo stake purchase without regulatory disclosure
- Actions contradict transparency calls from GameStop movement
Keith Gill (Roaring Kitty)
- Never explicitly promoted MOASS narrative
- Explicitly told people not to follow his trades
- Recent call options exercise didn't trigger expected squeeze
Online Influencer Concerns
- Many prioritize narrative maintenance over truth
- Example: Trey Trades (AMC promoter) later admitted being wrong, promoted without disclosure
- People still claim Bed Bath & Beyond shareholders will get money back despite share extinction
- No financial consequences for wrong predictions
Evolving MOASS Goalpost Movement
- Share vote theory (prove fake shares) - didn't happen
- Direct registration strategy (reduce short supply) - no effect
- Keith Gill return/options exercise - no squeeze
- Current focus: company cash for acquisitions
- Having cash not inherently valuable if poor capital allocation
- Better ROI available in savings accounts/treasury bills than poorly managed companies
Broader Market Corruption Context
- Wall Street corruption exists and frustrations are valid
- CNBC talking heads and firms not without sin
- Nefarious actors likely abuse retail investors
- However: corruption evidence ≠ evidence of massive GameStop short interest
- Most money managers likely don't care about GameStop 3 years later
Investment Philosophy Conclusion
- Normal market performance (9% annually) can be incredibly helpful over time
- Investing can't solve all problems or make up for spending issues without decent salary
- Prudent investing still valuable tool
- Distinguish between supporting company vs. expecting get-rich-quick returns
- Be careful with online personalities promoting overconfidence
- People promoting MOASS bear no consequences for wrong predictions
