AI summary by TwinMind

MEMS: The Second Silicon Revolution?

Asianometry

14m 25s

Historical Development & Key Milestones

  • Feynman's 1959 lecture "There's Plenty of Room at the Bottom" - offered $1,000 prize for motor fitting in 0.4mm cube
    • Prize claimed <1 year later by Caltech engineer using conventional tools
  • 1967: Harvey Nathanson at Westinghouse created resonant gate transistor
    • ~1mm long, made of gold, electrically controlled gate-electrode distance
    • First real MEMS product as frequency filter
  • 1979: HP developed silicon micro-machined inkjet nozzle
    • Enabled thermal inkjet technology
    • Most successful MEMS application up to that point

Inkjet Technology Mechanics

  • Rapidly heats ink to ~100°C creating bubbles
  • Bubbles push ink through micro-machined nozzle onto paper
  • Bubble collapse creates vacuum sucking in more ink
  • Nozzles don't move but MEMS enabled tiny size
  • Allowed multiple nozzles together for increased printer resolution

1990s Sensor Revolution

Automotive Airbag Sensors

  • Original sensors: mechanical balls in tube - large, heavy, complex, expensive ($100s)
  • 1991: Analog Devices created first commercial acceleration MEMS sensor
    • <1 square centimeter size
    • 60 capacitive sense fingers, 60 microns deep
    • Fingers attached to mass that moves during acceleration
    • Touching fingers change capacitive value sensed by chip
    • ADXL50 chip (50G acceleration capability)
    • Complete monolithic system: smaller, more reliable, $5 vs $20-100
  • >60 million MEMS airbag sensors made/sold
  • Cars now have dozens of MEMS sensors: anti-lock brakes, active suspension, navigation, rollover detection

Medical Pressure Sensors

  • Monitor blood pressure via intravenous line
  • Early external sensors: >$600, required sterilization/recalibration per use
  • MEMS version: $10, majority cost from packaging, disposable
  • Mechanics: silicon thin membrane diaphragm with 4 stress-sensitive polysilicon/piezo resistors at edges
  • Diaphragm suspended over vacuum cavity for absolute pressure sensing
  • Pressure changes silicon band structure, changes crystal resistivity
  • Medical MEMS sensor industry: >$6 billion, blood pressure sensors largest segment

Consumer Electronics Applications

  • Nintendo Switch: ultra-low power inertial sensors with gyroscope/accelerometer (STMicroelectronics SH-627)
  • Visual displays, optical switches using micro mirrors
  • Micro mirrors redirect light between optical fibers

Manufacturing Technologies & Approaches

  • Primary approach: high-volume IC techniques (photolithography, etching)
  • Add/remove layers on 2D substrate to produce 3D shapes
  • No one-size-fits-all methodology
  • Alternative approaches:
    • Electrochemical micro machining (ECM) - originally for PC boards
    • Laser beam machining
    • Electrode discharge machining
    • LIGA (unpronounceable acronym)

Design Challenges vs Traditional ICs

Fundamental Differences

  • Cannot simply miniaturize and expect same performance
  • Friction forces much stronger than inertia at micro scale
  • Tiny flow spaces prone to fluid blockages
  • Electro-osmotic effects enable electric field pumping at micrometer scale

Design Philosophy Differences

  • VLSI uses modular approach with generic modules/standardized cell libraries
  • Libraries designed independently from product (e.g., TSMC nodes)
  • Mechanical design lacks standardization except bolts, fasteners, pipe fittings, paint
  • Mechanical components must accommodate weight/space/energy restrictions for specific products
  • VLSI objects process signals (logic only)
  • Mechanical objects: contain liquids, rotate, slide, support loads simultaneously
  • Makes MEMS design extremely custom

Design Tools

  • CAD/design automation software: Coventreware, Intellicad
  • Help designers understand microstructure design and electromechanical behaviors

Packaging & Cost Structure Issues

Cost Breakdown

  • Packaging: 75-80% of final MEMS cost (reversal from IC situation)
  • HVAC pressure sensor: $20-30 total price
  • Raw die from foundry: <$0.50 (unusable without packaging)

Fundamental Packaging Challenges

  • ICs are self-contained systems - packaging provides protection/interface
  • MEMS must intimately interact with outside world
  • Cannot encase pressure sensor in hard plastic - wouldn't sense pressure
  • Each MEMS type needs different packaging:
    • Pressure sensor ≠ micro mirror array
    • Microfluidic ≠ electrostatic actuator
  • Adds substantial cost and engineering overhead

Economic Challenges & Market Dynamics

Analog Devices Case Study

  • Started MEMS research 1980s targeting airbag sensors
  • Built in-house manufacturing facility
  • Took 9 years for facility to become profitable
  • Marketed significant price advantage over competition
  • First automotive deal with Siemens: automatic price declines over 6 years
    • $11/unit declining to $6/unit
  • Expected efficiency gains similar to IC industry

Yield & Pricing Issues

  • Yield is biggest cost factor - 10% yield means 90% unusable products
  • Doubling yield halves cost
  • Difficult to achieve, leads to overly optimistic projections
  • Market prices don't reflect actual investment in development/production/packaging/testing
  • Relentless price erosion: 3-5% per quarter
  • Erodes margins, disincentivizes investment in new applications

Missed Opportunities

  • Micropropulsion for cube satellites
  • MEMS-based LIDAR mirrors for autonomous cars
  • IoT sensors

Industry Structure & Future Outlook

  • Called "second silicon revolution" - microscopic moving parts, smaller/cheaper/better performance
  • Victim of own success - creativity/diversity makes standardization harder
  • No industry coordination like SEMATECH or DARPA
  • ~50 players: designers, foundries, vendors, end-users
  • Need closer collaboration for standards and solutions to under-invested issues
  • Required for realizing full technical/commercial potential

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome