AI summary by TwinMind
Michael D. Smith | Remaking Higher Education for a Digital World | Talks at Google
Talks at Google
45m 22s
Introduction and Background
- Hal (Google Chief Economist) introduces Michael Smith
- Smith previously appeared on Google show in 2015 discussing "Streaming Sharing and Stealing" about content market disruption
- Current topic: "The Abundant University: Remaking Higher Education for a Digital World"
- Presentation planned for 25 minutes followed by Q&A
Three Core Arguments for Higher Education Reform
- Argument 1: New digital technologies will change higher education regardless of resistance
- Argument 2: If universities care about social justice, they should embrace this change
- Argument 3: Universities can embrace change by rediscovering their mission as educators
Technology Will Change Higher Education
- Faculty often dismiss technology threats with eye rolls
- Clay Christensen predicted higher education disruption in 2013 - "5 years from now these enterprises will be in real trouble"
- 10 years later, little has changed, leading to complacency
- Smith argues Christensen's disruption theory is brilliant but incomplete
Structural Disruption Theory
- Developed by Smith and colleague Rahul based on entertainment industry research
- Big Six Studio executive (2015): "My business is different, same six studios dominated for 100 years"
- Traditional disruption theory focuses on single disruptive changes
- Entertainment industry faced multiple simultaneous disruptive changes
- Need to examine what defines power in industries
Entertainment Industry Power Structure
- Studios controlled three scarce resources for 100 years:
- Financial and technical resources for content creation
- Access to distribution and promotional channels
- Copyright-created artificial scarcity in consumer access
- By 2015: simultaneous technological shifts creating abundance in these areas
- New scarce resource emerged: customer attention (controlled by Amazon, Netflix, Google)
Higher Education's Power Structure
- Universities control three scarce resources:
- Access to classroom seats
- Access to faculty experts
- Access to valuable credentials for marketplace success
- 2012 MOOCs created abundance in classroom seats and faculty access
- Credentials remained scarce - "you can take as many MOOC courses as you want but without credentials won't get far"
Credential Scarcity Under Threat
- Multiple companies deemphasizing college degree requirements in hiring
- Headlines showing businesses saying "we're deemphasizing reliance on college degree"
- Companies cite desire for more diverse workforce as reason
- Can't achieve diversity while relying on four-year degrees
Social Justice Imperative
- Truman Commission Report (1947): "Democratic community cannot tolerate society based on education for well-to-do alone"
- Current reality contradicts this mission
Equity Statistics
- Raj Chetty study findings:
- Top 1% income families: 1 in 4 chance of attending highly selective college
- Bottom 20% income families: 1 in 300 chance of same college
- Rich kids 77 times more likely to access elite education
- Problem exists beyond elite schools - wealth correlates with four-year graduation rates generally
Media Recognition of Problems
- New York Times article: "Let's Smash the College Admissions Process"
- Describes admissions as "one of truly destructive institutions in American society"
Political and Public Support Challenges
- Obama 2012 State of Union: "Can't just keep subsidizing skyrocketing tuition...colleges on notice"
- Gallup poll: Only 36% of Americans have confidence in higher education (down 20 percentage points in 8 years)
- Loss of taxpayer confidence threatens legislative support
Online Education Misconceptions
- Faculty dismiss online education based on COVID experience
- Legal problem: Publicly stating online education was inferior increases institutional liability for tuition refund lawsuits
- Logical problem: COVID emergency teaching doesn't represent gold standard of online education possibilities
Successful Online Education Examples
Outlier.org Calculus Course
- Smith's daughter took course for University of Pittsburgh credit
- Admission based on 70% score on algebra quiz, not pre-calculus transcript
- Full refund if student puts in effort but doesn't pass
- Three different professors (Tim Chartier, Hannah Fry, John Urschel) teaching same modules
- Students can mix and match professors based on learning style
- Research shows performance gaps disappear when students learn from professors who look like them
Executive Education Case Study
- Top business school's 7-week residential exec ed program
- Female executives underrepresented in in-person format
- COVID online version achieved expected female participation proportions
- Residential requirement excluded women due to family obligations ("patriarchy")
Arizona State Organic Chemistry
- Most content delivered online effectively
- One-week intensive on-campus lab experience (2 labs daily)
- Online students achieved equivalent knowledge to residential students
- Online students developed stronger scientist identity from intensive experience
Entertainment Industry Lesson
- Studios initially opposed technology as threat to business model
- Eventually recognized difference between business model and mission
- Studio executive: Netflix version of his show was "superior in every way"
- Shifted from opposing change to embracing it for mission advancement
- Created innovative platforms as result
Higher Education Mission Clarification
- If mission is helping rich kids get job market advantage: "doing great, no need to change"
- If mission is helping all kids discover and develop talents for society's benefit: "can do much better"
- Requires embracing technology to achieve true mission
Q&A Session Highlights
Classroom Constraints
- Hal's example: Economics major bottleneck due to single classroom capacity
- Similar constraints exist across universities (chemistry, etc.)
- Technology should eliminate physical space as constraint
Demographics Challenge
- Baby boomer retirement + fewer college-age children
- Small colleges struggling with reduced student flow
- Leaders in abundance creation: Southern New Hampshire, Arizona State, Georgia Tech
- Not traditional elite schools (Harvard, MIT) leading innovation
Online Education Best Practices
- Step back from traditional methods, leverage new technologies
- Students appreciated recorded lectures for review
- Zoom chat created parallel class discussion
- Easier access to guest speakers from other institutions
- Specialist professors teaching as generalists - technology enables expert collaboration
Content and Assessment Innovation
- Hamming's advice: Design assessments first, then create content to enable those skills
- Electronic textbooks provide immediate feedback vs. week-delayed grades
- Adaptive learning based on specific student mistakes
- Data collection about individual learning patterns for personalized recommendations
Curriculum Reform Discussion
- Movement to replace calculus with probability/statistics in high school
- Statistics more broadly applicable than calculus
- Need flexible curriculum allowing student choice based on career interests
- Current system forces calculus requirement regardless of student needs
PhD Program Reform
- Economics PhD now takes 7 years (excessive)
- Admissions overweight standardized test scores (decathletes judged by 100-yard dash time)
- Need creative metrics beyond GRE scores
- Consider PhD without thesis requirement for industry-bound students
- Supply and demand will create market for appropriately trained graduates
University Mission and Wealth
- No one in higher education excited about wealth determining access
- System currently favors wealthy students
- Need alternate pathways for non-privileged backgrounds
- Some schools abolished legacy preferences (Johns Hopkins, others)
Implementation Challenges
- Harvard X and MIT X moved slowly despite early positioning
- Incumbent leaders struggle to adopt disruption
- Paul LeBlanc at Southern New Hampshire succeeded because less to lose
- MBA programs already offering evening/weekend/online options
- US News rankings penalize reduced selectivity, discouraging innovation
Maintaining Quality While Scaling
- Still need non-profit institutions with expert-delivered content
- Telemedicine parallel: equivalent outcomes for most procedures
- Use online for what it does best, in-person for what it does best
- Preserve expertise while embracing abundance-creating changes
