AI summary by TwinMind

Michael D. Smith | Remaking Higher Education for a Digital World | Talks at Google

Talks at Google

45m 22s

Introduction and Background

  • Hal (Google Chief Economist) introduces Michael Smith
  • Smith previously appeared on Google show in 2015 discussing "Streaming Sharing and Stealing" about content market disruption
  • Current topic: "The Abundant University: Remaking Higher Education for a Digital World"
  • Presentation planned for 25 minutes followed by Q&A

Three Core Arguments for Higher Education Reform

  • Argument 1: New digital technologies will change higher education regardless of resistance
  • Argument 2: If universities care about social justice, they should embrace this change
  • Argument 3: Universities can embrace change by rediscovering their mission as educators

Technology Will Change Higher Education

  • Faculty often dismiss technology threats with eye rolls
  • Clay Christensen predicted higher education disruption in 2013 - "5 years from now these enterprises will be in real trouble"
  • 10 years later, little has changed, leading to complacency
  • Smith argues Christensen's disruption theory is brilliant but incomplete

Structural Disruption Theory

  • Developed by Smith and colleague Rahul based on entertainment industry research
  • Big Six Studio executive (2015): "My business is different, same six studios dominated for 100 years"
  • Traditional disruption theory focuses on single disruptive changes
  • Entertainment industry faced multiple simultaneous disruptive changes
  • Need to examine what defines power in industries

Entertainment Industry Power Structure

  • Studios controlled three scarce resources for 100 years:
    • Financial and technical resources for content creation
    • Access to distribution and promotional channels
    • Copyright-created artificial scarcity in consumer access
  • By 2015: simultaneous technological shifts creating abundance in these areas
  • New scarce resource emerged: customer attention (controlled by Amazon, Netflix, Google)

Higher Education's Power Structure

  • Universities control three scarce resources:
    • Access to classroom seats
    • Access to faculty experts
    • Access to valuable credentials for marketplace success
  • 2012 MOOCs created abundance in classroom seats and faculty access
  • Credentials remained scarce - "you can take as many MOOC courses as you want but without credentials won't get far"

Credential Scarcity Under Threat

  • Multiple companies deemphasizing college degree requirements in hiring
  • Headlines showing businesses saying "we're deemphasizing reliance on college degree"
  • Companies cite desire for more diverse workforce as reason
  • Can't achieve diversity while relying on four-year degrees

Social Justice Imperative

  • Truman Commission Report (1947): "Democratic community cannot tolerate society based on education for well-to-do alone"
  • Current reality contradicts this mission

Equity Statistics

  • Raj Chetty study findings:
    • Top 1% income families: 1 in 4 chance of attending highly selective college
    • Bottom 20% income families: 1 in 300 chance of same college
    • Rich kids 77 times more likely to access elite education
  • Problem exists beyond elite schools - wealth correlates with four-year graduation rates generally

Media Recognition of Problems

  • New York Times article: "Let's Smash the College Admissions Process"
  • Describes admissions as "one of truly destructive institutions in American society"

Political and Public Support Challenges

  • Obama 2012 State of Union: "Can't just keep subsidizing skyrocketing tuition...colleges on notice"
  • Gallup poll: Only 36% of Americans have confidence in higher education (down 20 percentage points in 8 years)
  • Loss of taxpayer confidence threatens legislative support

Online Education Misconceptions

  • Faculty dismiss online education based on COVID experience
  • Legal problem: Publicly stating online education was inferior increases institutional liability for tuition refund lawsuits
  • Logical problem: COVID emergency teaching doesn't represent gold standard of online education possibilities

Successful Online Education Examples

Outlier.org Calculus Course

  • Smith's daughter took course for University of Pittsburgh credit
  • Admission based on 70% score on algebra quiz, not pre-calculus transcript
  • Full refund if student puts in effort but doesn't pass
  • Three different professors (Tim Chartier, Hannah Fry, John Urschel) teaching same modules
  • Students can mix and match professors based on learning style
  • Research shows performance gaps disappear when students learn from professors who look like them

Executive Education Case Study

  • Top business school's 7-week residential exec ed program
  • Female executives underrepresented in in-person format
  • COVID online version achieved expected female participation proportions
  • Residential requirement excluded women due to family obligations ("patriarchy")

Arizona State Organic Chemistry

  • Most content delivered online effectively
  • One-week intensive on-campus lab experience (2 labs daily)
  • Online students achieved equivalent knowledge to residential students
  • Online students developed stronger scientist identity from intensive experience

Entertainment Industry Lesson

  • Studios initially opposed technology as threat to business model
  • Eventually recognized difference between business model and mission
  • Studio executive: Netflix version of his show was "superior in every way"
  • Shifted from opposing change to embracing it for mission advancement
  • Created innovative platforms as result

Higher Education Mission Clarification

  • If mission is helping rich kids get job market advantage: "doing great, no need to change"
  • If mission is helping all kids discover and develop talents for society's benefit: "can do much better"
  • Requires embracing technology to achieve true mission

Q&A Session Highlights

Classroom Constraints

  • Hal's example: Economics major bottleneck due to single classroom capacity
  • Similar constraints exist across universities (chemistry, etc.)
  • Technology should eliminate physical space as constraint

Demographics Challenge

  • Baby boomer retirement + fewer college-age children
  • Small colleges struggling with reduced student flow
  • Leaders in abundance creation: Southern New Hampshire, Arizona State, Georgia Tech
  • Not traditional elite schools (Harvard, MIT) leading innovation

Online Education Best Practices

  • Step back from traditional methods, leverage new technologies
  • Students appreciated recorded lectures for review
  • Zoom chat created parallel class discussion
  • Easier access to guest speakers from other institutions
  • Specialist professors teaching as generalists - technology enables expert collaboration

Content and Assessment Innovation

  • Hamming's advice: Design assessments first, then create content to enable those skills
  • Electronic textbooks provide immediate feedback vs. week-delayed grades
  • Adaptive learning based on specific student mistakes
  • Data collection about individual learning patterns for personalized recommendations

Curriculum Reform Discussion

  • Movement to replace calculus with probability/statistics in high school
  • Statistics more broadly applicable than calculus
  • Need flexible curriculum allowing student choice based on career interests
  • Current system forces calculus requirement regardless of student needs

PhD Program Reform

  • Economics PhD now takes 7 years (excessive)
  • Admissions overweight standardized test scores (decathletes judged by 100-yard dash time)
  • Need creative metrics beyond GRE scores
  • Consider PhD without thesis requirement for industry-bound students
  • Supply and demand will create market for appropriately trained graduates

University Mission and Wealth

  • No one in higher education excited about wealth determining access
  • System currently favors wealthy students
  • Need alternate pathways for non-privileged backgrounds
  • Some schools abolished legacy preferences (Johns Hopkins, others)

Implementation Challenges

  • Harvard X and MIT X moved slowly despite early positioning
  • Incumbent leaders struggle to adopt disruption
  • Paul LeBlanc at Southern New Hampshire succeeded because less to lose
  • MBA programs already offering evening/weekend/online options
  • US News rankings penalize reduced selectivity, discouraging innovation

Maintaining Quality While Scaling

  • Still need non-profit institutions with expert-delivered content
  • Telemedicine parallel: equivalent outcomes for most procedures
  • Use online for what it does best, in-person for what it does best
  • Preserve expertise while embracing abundance-creating changes

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome