AI summary by TwinMind

Michael Mina: Rapid COVID Testing | Lex Fridman Podcast #235

Lex Fridman

1h 46m 47s

Introduction and Context

  • Michael Mina's second appearance on podcast
  • Mina: Harvard professor researching infectious disease/immunology
  • Host's view: rapid at-home testing is most powerful, doable, obvious COVID-19 solution since pandemic beginning
  • Accuracy high for detecting contagiousness (what matters)
  • Hundreds of millions can be manufactured quickly, cheaply
  • Preserves privacy and individual freedoms
  • Solution was obvious in May 2020, still obvious today

Current State of Rapid At-Home Testing

  • 20 months of living in anxiety, uncertainty, health fears, shutdowns, economic instability
  • Tests giving people empowerment, control over their pandemic slice
  • More Americans accessing tests from CVS, Walgreens
  • Shifting discussion tenor - was "me and few others against world" in 2020
  • Most of 2020-2021 spent educating scientists, public health leaders, physicians
  • Need to understand different reason to test in pandemic vs. purely diagnostics
  • Goal: transmission blockade, severing transmission chains
  • Biden COVID-19 action plan now includes testing as main pillar
  • Rapid test scaling finally happening

Rapid At-Home Test Mechanics

  • Paper strip tests - simple design
  • Swab front of nose (not deep brain swab)
  • Put swab in liquid tube
  • Pour drops on paper strip or drop strip in tube
  • Like pregnancy test: two lines positive, one line negative
  • Takes 30 seconds hands-on time, wait 10 minutes for result
  • Extraordinarily effective at answering: "Am I infectious?"
  • This is the public health question needed during pandemic

PCR vs. Rapid Test Comparison

  • PCR much more analytically sensitive (detects 1 molecule vs. 100,000)
  • But for public health, don't want test detecting 1 molecule
  • Has created net negative for public health
  • Only need to know if infectious (high viral load like 1 million)
  • Virus grows zero to billion in one day
  • Don't need better sensitivity if trade-off is 1-3 day delay
  • Absolutely want rapid result telling you "yes, infectious right now"
  • PCR requires lab, takes 4+ days minimum (order, ship, result)
  • At that point, not even infectious anymore if you were initially

Sensitivity Analysis Graphic

  • Rapid antigen test answers: "Am I currently infectious?"
  • Shows 7 different tests based on viral load
  • Likelihood of infectiousness across different viral loads
  • Can't ask "what's sensitivity of test" without specifying "to detect what"
  • Different viral loads: 1 vs. trillion - PCR positive for both
  • How sensitive is rapid test to detect if infectious: ~97%
  • If super spreader (extraordinarily high viral loads): ~100% sensitive
  • If no longer infectious: might have 0% sensitivity vs. PCR (this is good)
  • FDA averages together, says "only 40% sensitive compared to PCR"
  • Should create weighted average based on transmissibility potential
  • Need 80-90% sensitive if infectious - they achieve 95-100% when most infectious

FDA Regulatory Issues

  • Rapid tests classified as medical devices
  • FDA evaluates as medical devices, compares to gold standard (PCR)
  • As medical device for physician: want absolute best sensitivity regardless of transmissibility
  • One patient at a time, time not of essence, insurance pays, don't care about resources
  • Public health testing different: must account for all people, all days
  • Accessibility central theme, frequency of tests
  • Real purpose: answer "am I infectious?" to know when to isolate
  • Don't want to isolate PCR-positive individuals no longer infectious
  • Bad public health practice - huge disincentive to test
  • People only infectious 3-7 days but PCR positive 30-70 days
  • Mathematical fact: perfect public health test (100% sensitive/specific for contagious people) can't achieve 80% sensitivity at population level against medical device
  • Only infectious ~20% of time when PCR positive, so theoretically 20% sensitivity while being perfect public health test

Why We Don't Have Tests - Systemic Issues

  • Every agency deferential to FDA
  • Government hasn't been creative
  • White House response: "sounds interesting but no tests at scale, so can't act"
  • Defeatist attitude instead of solving scale problem
  • Everything happening today was 100% predictable last year
  • FDA doing exactly what supposed to do - authorize medical devices
  • Companies forced to skew clinical trials to favor rapid tests
  • FDA truly believes doing right thing
  • Issue may be higher level - no public health pathway exists
  • Defunded/devalued public health so long, no language for public health tests
  • No laws, definitions for public health tests vs. medical devices

Proposed Solution - Executive Action

  • FDA clearly states they don't authorize/review public health tools
  • Need President to use executive powers for one line:
    • "Any tools used for public health testing during public health emergency designated as public health tools"
  • Would take FDA off hook - not cramming square peg through round hole
  • CDC could take over, set appropriate metrics
  • Interested in: high viral load detection, fast, scalable
  • If test used in Europe for months with good performance, give certificate immediately
  • Could get hundreds of millions additional tests tomorrow

Precedent Issues and Inconsistencies

  • Pooled testing exists as precedent during pandemic
  • Companies like Ginkgo working with 100+ labs, millions of kids
  • 5-25 kids per pool, distributed across country
  • FDA doesn't care, no regulatory authority needed
  • Collection on site, shipped to lab, no oversight
  • But rapid test for exact same purpose requires FDA authorization
  • Ridiculous: if test alters behavior of single person = medical device
  • But pooled test altering 25 people's behavior at once = not medical device
  • 25 people quarantined if one positive in pool

Masks vs. Tests - Political Decisions

  • Masks decided as effective tool despite tricky evidence
  • Doctors don't understand fluid dynamics much
  • Doctors believe they understand all aspects of tests
  • Greatest barriers from physicians saying "can't use test not as sensitive as PCR"
  • Physicians placed in decision-making power inappropriately
  • No medical school training for public health work
  • Must optimize different test qualities, sometimes at odds with medicine
  • Physicians like TSA agents - focus on one lane, not systematic gaps
  • Physician duty: do no harm to this patient
  • Time, scale, county/country test capacity not physician training
  • Doctors early on said "hell no" to antigen tests, pissing matches over PCR sensitivity

Who Should Lead Public Health Decisions

  • Should be CDC overriding FDA, but need different tool designation
  • President can designate as public health tools outside FDA jurisdiction
  • CMS also designates as medical devices purely because could change behavior
  • President has authority to task CDC with certification/authorization
  • UK did this - laid out clear regimen for rapid antigen tests as public health tools
  • Outside normal medical diagnostic regulatory agencies
  • Fast screening, ranked tests, deployed in weeks not years
  • CDC really needs to take charge

Vaccines and Testing Relationship

  • Vaccines evaluated on stopping disease, not transmission
  • Most trials didn't evaluate transmission prevention at all
  • Short-sighted vision: might not stop transmission, variants might break through, measuring peak performance first few months
  • CDC went "all in" saying breakthrough cases rare, transmission doesn't happen if vaccinated
  • Delta + waning immunity = breakthrough cases
  • Vaccines still working to keep people out of hospital
  • But not working to stop transmission
  • Until society decides different goals (okay with illness, letting transmission go), need other avenues
  • Herd immunity not happening
  • Letting spread happen in vaccinated people gives virus bootcamp to mutate around vaccine-derived antibodies

Proposed Dynamic Testing Program

  • Not every person tested every day
  • Every household has box of tests in cupboard
  • No cases in community long time = stop testing
  • Wastewater testing to detect RNA
  • If RNA appears in wastewater: households use 1 test per week
  • If cases get worse: identify outbreak pockets
  • Everyone in zip code test every 2 days for 7 days or every day for 7 days
  • Get rid of outbreak quickly
  • Week or two with no cases = stop testing again
  • Dynamic based on community need
  • Send text message "take your test today"
  • Only goal: get R below 1, stop outbreak
  • Don't need near perfect compliance - 50-98% testing much better than none

Mathematical Reality of Outbreak Control

  • To completely stop outbreak: get 100 infected people to infect 95 (not 100+)
  • Most people think this sounds horrible/like failure
  • But if sustained multiple days, couple weeks goes from big outbreak to very small
  • Without testing: 100 people infect 140 people
  • After 4 weeks: 20 people with testing vs. 600 without testing
  • Massive difference, only goal is R below 1

Test Manufacturing and Costs

  • Manufacturing process could be 50 cents per test, maybe less
  • Germany: 60-70 different authorized high-quality rapid tests
  • Can buy for 80 cents with companies still making profit
  • Market competition drives costs way down
  • Most important feature: what do you do with result?
  • Entry to school/work, reporting to public health agencies
  • Primary mode: just let people test
  • For workplace "vaccinate or test": need verification, not honor system

Test Verification Technology

  • E-med service provides test verification
  • Scan QR code, proctor appears on phone/computer
  • Videotape test usage, verify results
  • Get verified laboratory report from home/car
  • Can be considered proof of negative test
  • CDC uses e-med for US entry via antigen test
  • Sitting in airport, use e-med test, get negative, TSA accepts for US entry
  • Super simple process

Privacy and Verification Balance

  • Tension between verification needs and privacy concerns
  • People should have right to know their status
  • Travesty that made it hard for people to know status on their terms
  • Prioritized "us knowing" at expense of "you knowing your status"
  • If public health can't know, then you can't know - wrong approach
  • Need to engage public; if some don't want public health participation but want to know status, that's still public health benefit
  • Can create systems where individuals form relationships based on status without centralized reporting
  • Could have opt-in/opt-out for public health reporting
  • Private companies don't want to fall out of favor with CDC/FDA
  • Problem: private companies as public health agents lose control, must do what makes money

Biden Action Plan Analysis

  • Multiple pillars: companies 100+ employees require unvaccinated test weekly
  • Reduce PCR test cost 35%, scale up antigen tests
  • 280 million tests, $2 billion investment
  • Problem: "vaccinate or test" doesn't make sense when vaccinated can transmit
  • Should be "vaccinate and test"
  • Coercive effort to get people vaccinated
  • Disagree with tricking people like children vs. honest transparent communication
  • Confusing language - implies vaccines stop transmission when they don't
  • Business leaders calling asking where to get tests for 8,000 employees
  • "Pandemic of unvaccinated" divisive language - it's pandemic of virus
  • Unvaccinated just scared, don't know who to trust
  • Haven't given them reason to trust public health

Action Plan Concerns

  • 280 million tests = less than 1 per person per year
  • Sounds like big number but inadequate
  • Expectation set for tests in stock but won't scale well
  • Vaccinate or test will bring millions to testing, overwhelm PCR labs
  • 5+ day delays again with backlogs
  • Only solution: scale up rapid tests that are actually scalable
  • Not through production/manufacturing here, but opening doors for companies that can scale
  • Biggest diagnostic companies worldwide not selling billions of tests in US because don't want to play FDA game
  • Timer has been set, must deal with crisis before it happens
  • Political consequences if doesn't pull through
  • Rapid tests personal/emotional, give empowerment
  • When can't get due to out of stock, converts to frustration then anger/blame

Testing as Bipartisan Solution

  • One of only COVID solutions not yet politicized
  • Masks and vaccines heavily politicized with red/blue split
  • Testing fully bipartisan - talked to far right and super liberal congress
  • Politicians, governors everywhere asked for support around rapid tests
  • Powerful tools that didn't have to be politicized
  • Concern: action plan starting to conjure emotion "now I have to get tested"
  • Could have scaled up months ago, delivered to every household
  • Most unpleasant thing about COVID: uncertainty leading to fear
  • Testing removes uncertainty, allows confidence to operate without getting/spreading infection

Personal Empowerment Through Testing

  • Heavy burden to carry worrying "am I infectious?"
  • Become nicer person when tested - know not putting others in danger
  • Amazing feeling in room when everyone rapid tested before entering
  • Everyone relaxed vs. masked with maybe 20% protection
  • Rapid test gives 95-100% protection, allows people to see others without masks indoors
  • Restaurants scary because don't know who infectious, nobody masked
  • Great to go to restaurant where everyone tested negative that day
  • Reduces anxiety, makes individuals feel empowered

COVID as Information Problem

  • Truly an information problem, not just biological
  • Don't quarantine because everyone positive - quarantine because don't know if anyone positive
  • Quarantine whole classroom not because all positive, but because don't know if one positive
  • Not biological problem - information problem
  • Have tool to solve information problem: "eyes on virus"
  • If everyone glowed green when infectious, never had to close society, never had outbreaks
  • Would stay away from green people

Individual Action Items

  • Last year: email led to too many emails, couldn't respond
  • Led to development of rapidtests.org - automated letters to congressional members
  • Current recommendation: get people with sway over politicians/lobbyists
  • Request President use executive powers to designate as public health tools
  • Allow CDC/NIH/academic centers to evaluate tests quickly
  • Appropriate metrics for public health (not medical device metrics)
  • Within 2 days can have 10 new tests authorized
  • X Prize judging took couple days, no clinical trials needed
  • Systematized would take 1 hour

Meditation and Buddhist Monk Experience

  • Meditation as active effort to quiet mind
  • Exercise in quieting mind, not absence of activity
  • Most people meditate for balance, sanity, control emotions
  • Getting alone time to think or not think
  • Active effort to detach from things - possessions, loved ones
  • Buddhist goal: stop cycle of rebirth through non-attachment
  • Doesn't personally believe in rebirth but found meditation extraordinarily powerful
  • Feel control over different part of body never thought controllable
  • Close eyes, quiet mind, achieve silence for long periods
  • Can become addictive to mental quiet
  • 15 hours daily practice quieting mind

Buddhist Philosophy and Detachment

  • Stages of meditation leading to psychological changes
  • End goal: achieve nirvana - absence of attachment
  • Not attached to own body parts, could cut off foot without emotional response
  • Goal through samsara (cycle of rebirth/suffering): if love hat and lose it, suffer
  • If hate hat and see it, suffer
  • If completely ambivalent, no emotional rise good or bad
  • Balance where so detached nothing invokes negative or positive rise
  • Distinct from normal American life where live for emotional rises
  • Want happiness/joy, don't want sadness but sadness makes you appreciate happiness
  • Either averages out (pretty happy life) or doesn't (major depressive disorder)
  • Can go up/down averaging out, or straight line

Tsunami Experience and Leaving Monastery

  • Indian Ocean tsunami hit while monk in Sri Lanka
  • Lived in refugee camp, asked what could do to help
  • Answer: "meditate" - that's how to get good karma
  • Couldn't deal with that from Western perspective
  • Doesn't make sense to sit and meditate when devastation happening
  • Stopped meditating then, never really recovered
  • But understands/aware of part of self most people never privileged to know
  • Profound awareness - capacity to return if needed
  • Use it when really need to settle/calm physical or emotional pain
  • Possible to make pain go away but takes training like anything

Meditation Utility and Consciousness

  • Looked at meditation in utilitarian way
  • Minimizing thoughts, appreciating sensation
  • Wasn't writing book on free will like Sam Harris
  • If tsunami didn't happen, might still be sitting on mountain
  • Seeing pain/suffering/cruelty while supposed to meditate through it
  • Human spirit pushes to help others who suffer
  • React to help vs. care less through meditation
  • Don't become attached to others' suffering
  • Two valid ways to live life, ingrained early in society

Minimalism and Possessions

  • Find things to be massive burden
  • Burden makes it hard to focus
  • Ideal house: nothing on anything - peaceful
  • Love idea that if needed, could pack up and move without worrying
  • Don't actually have that in reality - about to have baby
  • Stressful seeing boxes of baby stuff arriving
  • Use meditation to say "this is okay, not permanent"
  • Easy to get lost in possessions, important to remember still free
  • Freedom takes work and remembering, meditation on it
  • Born free

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome