AI summary by TwinMind
Michael Mina: Rapid COVID Testing | Lex Fridman Podcast #235
Lex Fridman
1h 46m 47s
Introduction and Context
- Michael Mina's second appearance on podcast
- Mina: Harvard professor researching infectious disease/immunology
- Host's view: rapid at-home testing is most powerful, doable, obvious COVID-19 solution since pandemic beginning
- Accuracy high for detecting contagiousness (what matters)
- Hundreds of millions can be manufactured quickly, cheaply
- Preserves privacy and individual freedoms
- Solution was obvious in May 2020, still obvious today
Current State of Rapid At-Home Testing
- 20 months of living in anxiety, uncertainty, health fears, shutdowns, economic instability
- Tests giving people empowerment, control over their pandemic slice
- More Americans accessing tests from CVS, Walgreens
- Shifting discussion tenor - was "me and few others against world" in 2020
- Most of 2020-2021 spent educating scientists, public health leaders, physicians
- Need to understand different reason to test in pandemic vs. purely diagnostics
- Goal: transmission blockade, severing transmission chains
- Biden COVID-19 action plan now includes testing as main pillar
- Rapid test scaling finally happening
Rapid At-Home Test Mechanics
- Paper strip tests - simple design
- Swab front of nose (not deep brain swab)
- Put swab in liquid tube
- Pour drops on paper strip or drop strip in tube
- Like pregnancy test: two lines positive, one line negative
- Takes 30 seconds hands-on time, wait 10 minutes for result
- Extraordinarily effective at answering: "Am I infectious?"
- This is the public health question needed during pandemic
PCR vs. Rapid Test Comparison
- PCR much more analytically sensitive (detects 1 molecule vs. 100,000)
- But for public health, don't want test detecting 1 molecule
- Has created net negative for public health
- Only need to know if infectious (high viral load like 1 million)
- Virus grows zero to billion in one day
- Don't need better sensitivity if trade-off is 1-3 day delay
- Absolutely want rapid result telling you "yes, infectious right now"
- PCR requires lab, takes 4+ days minimum (order, ship, result)
- At that point, not even infectious anymore if you were initially
Sensitivity Analysis Graphic
- Rapid antigen test answers: "Am I currently infectious?"
- Shows 7 different tests based on viral load
- Likelihood of infectiousness across different viral loads
- Can't ask "what's sensitivity of test" without specifying "to detect what"
- Different viral loads: 1 vs. trillion - PCR positive for both
- How sensitive is rapid test to detect if infectious: ~97%
- If super spreader (extraordinarily high viral loads): ~100% sensitive
- If no longer infectious: might have 0% sensitivity vs. PCR (this is good)
- FDA averages together, says "only 40% sensitive compared to PCR"
- Should create weighted average based on transmissibility potential
- Need 80-90% sensitive if infectious - they achieve 95-100% when most infectious
FDA Regulatory Issues
- Rapid tests classified as medical devices
- FDA evaluates as medical devices, compares to gold standard (PCR)
- As medical device for physician: want absolute best sensitivity regardless of transmissibility
- One patient at a time, time not of essence, insurance pays, don't care about resources
- Public health testing different: must account for all people, all days
- Accessibility central theme, frequency of tests
- Real purpose: answer "am I infectious?" to know when to isolate
- Don't want to isolate PCR-positive individuals no longer infectious
- Bad public health practice - huge disincentive to test
- People only infectious 3-7 days but PCR positive 30-70 days
- Mathematical fact: perfect public health test (100% sensitive/specific for contagious people) can't achieve 80% sensitivity at population level against medical device
- Only infectious ~20% of time when PCR positive, so theoretically 20% sensitivity while being perfect public health test
Why We Don't Have Tests - Systemic Issues
- Every agency deferential to FDA
- Government hasn't been creative
- White House response: "sounds interesting but no tests at scale, so can't act"
- Defeatist attitude instead of solving scale problem
- Everything happening today was 100% predictable last year
- FDA doing exactly what supposed to do - authorize medical devices
- Companies forced to skew clinical trials to favor rapid tests
- FDA truly believes doing right thing
- Issue may be higher level - no public health pathway exists
- Defunded/devalued public health so long, no language for public health tests
- No laws, definitions for public health tests vs. medical devices
Proposed Solution - Executive Action
- FDA clearly states they don't authorize/review public health tools
- Need President to use executive powers for one line:
- "Any tools used for public health testing during public health emergency designated as public health tools"
- Would take FDA off hook - not cramming square peg through round hole
- CDC could take over, set appropriate metrics
- Interested in: high viral load detection, fast, scalable
- If test used in Europe for months with good performance, give certificate immediately
- Could get hundreds of millions additional tests tomorrow
Precedent Issues and Inconsistencies
- Pooled testing exists as precedent during pandemic
- Companies like Ginkgo working with 100+ labs, millions of kids
- 5-25 kids per pool, distributed across country
- FDA doesn't care, no regulatory authority needed
- Collection on site, shipped to lab, no oversight
- But rapid test for exact same purpose requires FDA authorization
- Ridiculous: if test alters behavior of single person = medical device
- But pooled test altering 25 people's behavior at once = not medical device
- 25 people quarantined if one positive in pool
Masks vs. Tests - Political Decisions
- Masks decided as effective tool despite tricky evidence
- Doctors don't understand fluid dynamics much
- Doctors believe they understand all aspects of tests
- Greatest barriers from physicians saying "can't use test not as sensitive as PCR"
- Physicians placed in decision-making power inappropriately
- No medical school training for public health work
- Must optimize different test qualities, sometimes at odds with medicine
- Physicians like TSA agents - focus on one lane, not systematic gaps
- Physician duty: do no harm to this patient
- Time, scale, county/country test capacity not physician training
- Doctors early on said "hell no" to antigen tests, pissing matches over PCR sensitivity
Who Should Lead Public Health Decisions
- Should be CDC overriding FDA, but need different tool designation
- President can designate as public health tools outside FDA jurisdiction
- CMS also designates as medical devices purely because could change behavior
- President has authority to task CDC with certification/authorization
- UK did this - laid out clear regimen for rapid antigen tests as public health tools
- Outside normal medical diagnostic regulatory agencies
- Fast screening, ranked tests, deployed in weeks not years
- CDC really needs to take charge
Vaccines and Testing Relationship
- Vaccines evaluated on stopping disease, not transmission
- Most trials didn't evaluate transmission prevention at all
- Short-sighted vision: might not stop transmission, variants might break through, measuring peak performance first few months
- CDC went "all in" saying breakthrough cases rare, transmission doesn't happen if vaccinated
- Delta + waning immunity = breakthrough cases
- Vaccines still working to keep people out of hospital
- But not working to stop transmission
- Until society decides different goals (okay with illness, letting transmission go), need other avenues
- Herd immunity not happening
- Letting spread happen in vaccinated people gives virus bootcamp to mutate around vaccine-derived antibodies
Proposed Dynamic Testing Program
- Not every person tested every day
- Every household has box of tests in cupboard
- No cases in community long time = stop testing
- Wastewater testing to detect RNA
- If RNA appears in wastewater: households use 1 test per week
- If cases get worse: identify outbreak pockets
- Everyone in zip code test every 2 days for 7 days or every day for 7 days
- Get rid of outbreak quickly
- Week or two with no cases = stop testing again
- Dynamic based on community need
- Send text message "take your test today"
- Only goal: get R below 1, stop outbreak
- Don't need near perfect compliance - 50-98% testing much better than none
Mathematical Reality of Outbreak Control
- To completely stop outbreak: get 100 infected people to infect 95 (not 100+)
- Most people think this sounds horrible/like failure
- But if sustained multiple days, couple weeks goes from big outbreak to very small
- Without testing: 100 people infect 140 people
- After 4 weeks: 20 people with testing vs. 600 without testing
- Massive difference, only goal is R below 1
Test Manufacturing and Costs
- Manufacturing process could be 50 cents per test, maybe less
- Germany: 60-70 different authorized high-quality rapid tests
- Can buy for 80 cents with companies still making profit
- Market competition drives costs way down
- Most important feature: what do you do with result?
- Entry to school/work, reporting to public health agencies
- Primary mode: just let people test
- For workplace "vaccinate or test": need verification, not honor system
Test Verification Technology
- E-med service provides test verification
- Scan QR code, proctor appears on phone/computer
- Videotape test usage, verify results
- Get verified laboratory report from home/car
- Can be considered proof of negative test
- CDC uses e-med for US entry via antigen test
- Sitting in airport, use e-med test, get negative, TSA accepts for US entry
- Super simple process
Privacy and Verification Balance
- Tension between verification needs and privacy concerns
- People should have right to know their status
- Travesty that made it hard for people to know status on their terms
- Prioritized "us knowing" at expense of "you knowing your status"
- If public health can't know, then you can't know - wrong approach
- Need to engage public; if some don't want public health participation but want to know status, that's still public health benefit
- Can create systems where individuals form relationships based on status without centralized reporting
- Could have opt-in/opt-out for public health reporting
- Private companies don't want to fall out of favor with CDC/FDA
- Problem: private companies as public health agents lose control, must do what makes money
Biden Action Plan Analysis
- Multiple pillars: companies 100+ employees require unvaccinated test weekly
- Reduce PCR test cost 35%, scale up antigen tests
- 280 million tests, $2 billion investment
- Problem: "vaccinate or test" doesn't make sense when vaccinated can transmit
- Should be "vaccinate and test"
- Coercive effort to get people vaccinated
- Disagree with tricking people like children vs. honest transparent communication
- Confusing language - implies vaccines stop transmission when they don't
- Business leaders calling asking where to get tests for 8,000 employees
- "Pandemic of unvaccinated" divisive language - it's pandemic of virus
- Unvaccinated just scared, don't know who to trust
- Haven't given them reason to trust public health
Action Plan Concerns
- 280 million tests = less than 1 per person per year
- Sounds like big number but inadequate
- Expectation set for tests in stock but won't scale well
- Vaccinate or test will bring millions to testing, overwhelm PCR labs
- 5+ day delays again with backlogs
- Only solution: scale up rapid tests that are actually scalable
- Not through production/manufacturing here, but opening doors for companies that can scale
- Biggest diagnostic companies worldwide not selling billions of tests in US because don't want to play FDA game
- Timer has been set, must deal with crisis before it happens
- Political consequences if doesn't pull through
- Rapid tests personal/emotional, give empowerment
- When can't get due to out of stock, converts to frustration then anger/blame
Testing as Bipartisan Solution
- One of only COVID solutions not yet politicized
- Masks and vaccines heavily politicized with red/blue split
- Testing fully bipartisan - talked to far right and super liberal congress
- Politicians, governors everywhere asked for support around rapid tests
- Powerful tools that didn't have to be politicized
- Concern: action plan starting to conjure emotion "now I have to get tested"
- Could have scaled up months ago, delivered to every household
- Most unpleasant thing about COVID: uncertainty leading to fear
- Testing removes uncertainty, allows confidence to operate without getting/spreading infection
Personal Empowerment Through Testing
- Heavy burden to carry worrying "am I infectious?"
- Become nicer person when tested - know not putting others in danger
- Amazing feeling in room when everyone rapid tested before entering
- Everyone relaxed vs. masked with maybe 20% protection
- Rapid test gives 95-100% protection, allows people to see others without masks indoors
- Restaurants scary because don't know who infectious, nobody masked
- Great to go to restaurant where everyone tested negative that day
- Reduces anxiety, makes individuals feel empowered
COVID as Information Problem
- Truly an information problem, not just biological
- Don't quarantine because everyone positive - quarantine because don't know if anyone positive
- Quarantine whole classroom not because all positive, but because don't know if one positive
- Not biological problem - information problem
- Have tool to solve information problem: "eyes on virus"
- If everyone glowed green when infectious, never had to close society, never had outbreaks
- Would stay away from green people
Individual Action Items
- Last year: email led to too many emails, couldn't respond
- Led to development of rapidtests.org - automated letters to congressional members
- Current recommendation: get people with sway over politicians/lobbyists
- Request President use executive powers to designate as public health tools
- Allow CDC/NIH/academic centers to evaluate tests quickly
- Appropriate metrics for public health (not medical device metrics)
- Within 2 days can have 10 new tests authorized
- X Prize judging took couple days, no clinical trials needed
- Systematized would take 1 hour
Meditation and Buddhist Monk Experience
- Meditation as active effort to quiet mind
- Exercise in quieting mind, not absence of activity
- Most people meditate for balance, sanity, control emotions
- Getting alone time to think or not think
- Active effort to detach from things - possessions, loved ones
- Buddhist goal: stop cycle of rebirth through non-attachment
- Doesn't personally believe in rebirth but found meditation extraordinarily powerful
- Feel control over different part of body never thought controllable
- Close eyes, quiet mind, achieve silence for long periods
- Can become addictive to mental quiet
- 15 hours daily practice quieting mind
Buddhist Philosophy and Detachment
- Stages of meditation leading to psychological changes
- End goal: achieve nirvana - absence of attachment
- Not attached to own body parts, could cut off foot without emotional response
- Goal through samsara (cycle of rebirth/suffering): if love hat and lose it, suffer
- If hate hat and see it, suffer
- If completely ambivalent, no emotional rise good or bad
- Balance where so detached nothing invokes negative or positive rise
- Distinct from normal American life where live for emotional rises
- Want happiness/joy, don't want sadness but sadness makes you appreciate happiness
- Either averages out (pretty happy life) or doesn't (major depressive disorder)
- Can go up/down averaging out, or straight line
Tsunami Experience and Leaving Monastery
- Indian Ocean tsunami hit while monk in Sri Lanka
- Lived in refugee camp, asked what could do to help
- Answer: "meditate" - that's how to get good karma
- Couldn't deal with that from Western perspective
- Doesn't make sense to sit and meditate when devastation happening
- Stopped meditating then, never really recovered
- But understands/aware of part of self most people never privileged to know
- Profound awareness - capacity to return if needed
- Use it when really need to settle/calm physical or emotional pain
- Possible to make pain go away but takes training like anything
Meditation Utility and Consciousness
- Looked at meditation in utilitarian way
- Minimizing thoughts, appreciating sensation
- Wasn't writing book on free will like Sam Harris
- If tsunami didn't happen, might still be sitting on mountain
- Seeing pain/suffering/cruelty while supposed to meditate through it
- Human spirit pushes to help others who suffer
- React to help vs. care less through meditation
- Don't become attached to others' suffering
- Two valid ways to live life, ingrained early in society
Minimalism and Possessions
- Find things to be massive burden
- Burden makes it hard to focus
- Ideal house: nothing on anything - peaceful
- Love idea that if needed, could pack up and move without worrying
- Don't actually have that in reality - about to have baby
- Stressful seeing boxes of baby stuff arriving
- Use meditation to say "this is okay, not permanent"
- Easy to get lost in possessions, important to remember still free
- Freedom takes work and remembering, meditation on it
- Born free
