AI summary by TwinMind

Michael Schur | How to be Perfect: The Correct Answer To Every Moral Question | Talks at Google

Talks at Google

1h 2m 5s

Introduction and Background

  • Michael Schur introduced as creative force behind Parks & Recreation, Brooklyn Nine-Nine, The Good Place
  • Currently executive producing Rutherford Falls, Hacks, Q-Force
  • Discussing his New York Times bestselling book "How to Be Perfect: The Correct Answer to Every Moral Question"
  • Book distills 2000+ years of philosophical wisdom from Aristotle to Fast & Furious franchise into 300-page guidebook

Schur's Journey into Moral Philosophy

  • Always been rule-follower since kindergarten
  • Early memory of immediately following teacher's line-up instruction while other kids goofed around
  • Adult life events where he "blundered through" situations, felt whatever he did would cause harm
  • Realized smartest people in history spent lives writing about ethics and right/wrong
  • Started reading moral philosophy as hobby
  • When creating The Good Place, needed legitimate understanding of topic or show would fall apart
  • Contacted professionals: Todd May (professor who helped write book), Pamela Hieronomy (UCLA)
  • Writer's room had "red phone" like Reagan-Kremlin hotline for philosophical emergencies

Three Major Ethical Frameworks

Virtue Ethics (Aristotle)

  • Good person has certain qualities (generosity, magnanimity, courage) in exact right amount
  • Example: Too courageous soldier charges hill alone and dies; not courageous enough runs away screaming
  • Goal: find perfect amount of courage (golden mean)
  • Process called "habituation" - trial and error, lifetime process of getting closer to exact mean
  • Unique among theories - asks "what kind of person should you be" vs "what should you do"

Utilitarianism (Jeremy Bentham, J.S. Mill)

  • Right thing = whatever creates most total good, least total bad/sadness/pain/suffering
  • Bentham was socialist, wanted to eliminate classism, treat everyone's happiness equally
  • Not just how many people happy/sad, but depth, intensity, lasting nature, purity of emotions
  • Bentham left body to be preserved and displayed at university for future generations to revere
  • Problems: Can lead to conclusions like murdering one innocent person to save five others
  • Very data-driven approach

Deontological Ethics (Immanuel Kant)

  • Happiness/emotion irrelevant to morality
  • Humans have big brains and reasoning ability - that's what makes us special
  • Right/wrong discernible using pure reason
  • Encounter problem, pause, think of rule you could will to be universal
  • If world where everyone does what you're about to do is okay, act only out of duty to follow rule
  • Called this "categorical imperative"
  • Results completely irrelevant - if you follow correct rule and bad result occurs, you're morally off the hook
  • Exact opposite of utilitarianism: cares only about rule and intention, not result

Contractualism (T.M. Scanlon)

  • Offshoot of deontological thought, "Kant Lite"
  • Everyone sits at table pitching rules, assuming everyone reasonable
  • Rules that pass are ones no one can reasonably reject
  • Must constrain your needs/desires to same degree as everyone else
  • Like "good deal if no one is happy" - everyone reigns in what they want a little
  • More practical than pure Kantian thought

Applying Different Theories - "Should I Lie About Friend's Ugly Shirt?"

  • Kant: Cannot lie to anyone for any reason, even to save brother from murderer at door
  • Could say true things that don't reveal location, but not "I don't know where he is"
  • Utilitarian: If friend feels good about shirt, lie to maximize happiness
  • But must consider long-term consequences - what if she wears it for year and people mock her?
  • Impossible calculus of trying to figure out all future happinesses/sadnesses

Philosophy as Tools in Toolbox

  • Derek Parfit described theories as "scaling same mountain from different cliff faces"
  • All aiming at same thing - goodness or ethical life, just different approaches
  • Different theories useful in different situations vs always using one theory
  • Understanding basics of all theories allows choosing right method for situation

Effective Altruism and Utilitarian Applications

  • Movement uses data-driven utilitarian calculations for charitable giving
  • Examines how much good per dollar donated to different charities
  • Problem: Becomes judgmental about "less effective" charities like art museums, orchestras
  • Unfair to scold people for pursuing charitable donations for things that aren't maximal good
  • Humans are specific, dimensional, have layers to their lives
  • Vaccine distribution was utilitarian calculation - elderly/comorbidities got doses first before healthy young people

Moral Exhaustion - Schur's Coined Term

  • Fatigue from "trying to do the right thing all the time is huge pain in the ass"
  • Information age means knowing everything about everyone
  • Constantly assaulted/criticized for consumer choices, professional associations
  • Labor practices of sneaker companies, domestic violence charges against rock stars, CEO voting patterns
  • Exhausting to move through world knowing you'll accidentally do 15 wrong things daily
  • Need to care about being good person AND let yourself off the hook when you fail
  • Can't strive for perfection - not reasonable goal, will run out of gas in days
  • Difference between letting yourself off hook vs not caring at all

Susan Wolf's "Moral Saints"

  • "There seems to be a limit to how much morality we can stand"
  • Don't have to make everything about morality
  • Sometimes just want to sit on couch, eat Doritos, go to movies with friends
  • Don't become like Chidi from Good Place - paralyzed by making everything deeply about morality
  • Can't understand and evaluate every single aspect of life to avoid doing anything wrong

Aristotelian Balance

  • Can't be too perfect because then you're too far on spectrum
  • Qualities we think of as bad (like cowardice) sometimes needed to pull back from being too courageous
  • Okay to be angry - just right amount of angry at right moments toward right people
  • Doesn't have all answers about who are right people, when are right moments
  • Feels very humane - knows you're human being who occasionally gets angry
  • Very forgiving philosophy compared to Kant

Personal Ethical Journey - Hurricane Katrina Story

  • Wife in fender bender, $836 damage claim for minor crease
  • During Hurricane Katrina, Schur deeply affected by disaster
  • Told other guy: "I'll give $836 to Red Cross, we'll call it even"
  • Story went viral, $25,000 pledged to Red Cross if guy wouldn't fix bumper
  • Suddenly felt "this is wrong and bad" but couldn't explain why
  • Started reading moral philosophy, cold-calling philosophy professors
  • Realized was doing "whataboutism" - using unrelated global tragedy to avoid local responsibility
  • If everyone could do this, nothing would get solved - always something more important happening
  • Eventually mailed guy check, apologized, came clean about whole story
  • Key moment that sent him on philosophical path

Ethics as Muscle Development

  • Ethics like muscle you can develop and practice
  • Okay to fail - valid and productive way to get better
  • Aristotelian approach: attempt virtue, fail, examine situation, debrief
  • Understand if you were too much or not enough of something
  • Use that information for next time
  • Virtue ethics as data-driven as utilitarianism - collecting data on your own behavior

Questions Checklist for Ethical Decisions

  • What am I doing?
  • Why am I doing it?
  • Is there something I could be doing that would be better?
  • Why is it better?
  • Quick, efficient checklist for slowly unfolding situations
  • Usually pretty easy to answer if you take time for self-interrogation

Philosophy and Comedy Connection

  • Main characters in his shows want to be good people
  • Leslie Knope faced political ethical dilemmas
  • Good Place explicitly about "how do I be a good person"
  • Ron Swanson as proto-Kantian with strict code of ethics
  • Had intense libertarian code but also valued honor, self-reliance, ethical behavior
  • Didn't lie - "skim milk is water that's lying about being milk"
  • Let him and Leslie find common ground despite opposite political views

Contemporary Philosophy and Accessibility

  • Anyone engaged in philosophical ideas should be considered philosopher
  • Tear down barriers to entry for being considered philosopher
  • Should apply to anyone who actively grapples with ideas philosophers have offered
  • World should be filled with philosophers
  • "Call yourself a philosopher - if I can, anyone can"

Audience Q&A Highlights

  • Passive harm reduction approach fits across frameworks but creates contradictions
  • Pain from doing right thing is significant, real, needs factoring into equation
  • Sometimes conclude right thing would cause too much pain - find next best alternative
  • Example: confronting relatives with problematic worldviews vs ignoring
  • Balance between small ongoing pain vs larger confrontational pain
  • Some of ethics is gut feeling - theories provide scaffolding, then integrity and gut take over
  • Would want philosophical debate with Ron Swanson, Captain Holt, Janet, or Jason Mendoza
  • Brent Norwalk inspired by Robert Frank's book on luck and privilege
  • People undervalue role of luck in their success
  • Michael Jordan example - incredible athlete but lucky to be 6'6"
  • Brent had no concept he was fortunate - "earned my spot just like my father and his father before him"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome