AI summary by TwinMind
Michael Schur | How to be Perfect: The Correct Answer To Every Moral Question | Talks at Google
Talks at Google
1h 2m 5s
Introduction and Background
- Michael Schur introduced as creative force behind Parks & Recreation, Brooklyn Nine-Nine, The Good Place
- Currently executive producing Rutherford Falls, Hacks, Q-Force
- Discussing his New York Times bestselling book "How to Be Perfect: The Correct Answer to Every Moral Question"
- Book distills 2000+ years of philosophical wisdom from Aristotle to Fast & Furious franchise into 300-page guidebook
Schur's Journey into Moral Philosophy
- Always been rule-follower since kindergarten
- Early memory of immediately following teacher's line-up instruction while other kids goofed around
- Adult life events where he "blundered through" situations, felt whatever he did would cause harm
- Realized smartest people in history spent lives writing about ethics and right/wrong
- Started reading moral philosophy as hobby
- When creating The Good Place, needed legitimate understanding of topic or show would fall apart
- Contacted professionals: Todd May (professor who helped write book), Pamela Hieronomy (UCLA)
- Writer's room had "red phone" like Reagan-Kremlin hotline for philosophical emergencies
Three Major Ethical Frameworks
Virtue Ethics (Aristotle)
- Good person has certain qualities (generosity, magnanimity, courage) in exact right amount
- Example: Too courageous soldier charges hill alone and dies; not courageous enough runs away screaming
- Goal: find perfect amount of courage (golden mean)
- Process called "habituation" - trial and error, lifetime process of getting closer to exact mean
- Unique among theories - asks "what kind of person should you be" vs "what should you do"
Utilitarianism (Jeremy Bentham, J.S. Mill)
- Right thing = whatever creates most total good, least total bad/sadness/pain/suffering
- Bentham was socialist, wanted to eliminate classism, treat everyone's happiness equally
- Not just how many people happy/sad, but depth, intensity, lasting nature, purity of emotions
- Bentham left body to be preserved and displayed at university for future generations to revere
- Problems: Can lead to conclusions like murdering one innocent person to save five others
- Very data-driven approach
Deontological Ethics (Immanuel Kant)
- Happiness/emotion irrelevant to morality
- Humans have big brains and reasoning ability - that's what makes us special
- Right/wrong discernible using pure reason
- Encounter problem, pause, think of rule you could will to be universal
- If world where everyone does what you're about to do is okay, act only out of duty to follow rule
- Called this "categorical imperative"
- Results completely irrelevant - if you follow correct rule and bad result occurs, you're morally off the hook
- Exact opposite of utilitarianism: cares only about rule and intention, not result
Contractualism (T.M. Scanlon)
- Offshoot of deontological thought, "Kant Lite"
- Everyone sits at table pitching rules, assuming everyone reasonable
- Rules that pass are ones no one can reasonably reject
- Must constrain your needs/desires to same degree as everyone else
- Like "good deal if no one is happy" - everyone reigns in what they want a little
- More practical than pure Kantian thought
Applying Different Theories - "Should I Lie About Friend's Ugly Shirt?"
- Kant: Cannot lie to anyone for any reason, even to save brother from murderer at door
- Could say true things that don't reveal location, but not "I don't know where he is"
- Utilitarian: If friend feels good about shirt, lie to maximize happiness
- But must consider long-term consequences - what if she wears it for year and people mock her?
- Impossible calculus of trying to figure out all future happinesses/sadnesses
Philosophy as Tools in Toolbox
- Derek Parfit described theories as "scaling same mountain from different cliff faces"
- All aiming at same thing - goodness or ethical life, just different approaches
- Different theories useful in different situations vs always using one theory
- Understanding basics of all theories allows choosing right method for situation
Effective Altruism and Utilitarian Applications
- Movement uses data-driven utilitarian calculations for charitable giving
- Examines how much good per dollar donated to different charities
- Problem: Becomes judgmental about "less effective" charities like art museums, orchestras
- Unfair to scold people for pursuing charitable donations for things that aren't maximal good
- Humans are specific, dimensional, have layers to their lives
- Vaccine distribution was utilitarian calculation - elderly/comorbidities got doses first before healthy young people
Moral Exhaustion - Schur's Coined Term
- Fatigue from "trying to do the right thing all the time is huge pain in the ass"
- Information age means knowing everything about everyone
- Constantly assaulted/criticized for consumer choices, professional associations
- Labor practices of sneaker companies, domestic violence charges against rock stars, CEO voting patterns
- Exhausting to move through world knowing you'll accidentally do 15 wrong things daily
- Need to care about being good person AND let yourself off the hook when you fail
- Can't strive for perfection - not reasonable goal, will run out of gas in days
- Difference between letting yourself off hook vs not caring at all
Susan Wolf's "Moral Saints"
- "There seems to be a limit to how much morality we can stand"
- Don't have to make everything about morality
- Sometimes just want to sit on couch, eat Doritos, go to movies with friends
- Don't become like Chidi from Good Place - paralyzed by making everything deeply about morality
- Can't understand and evaluate every single aspect of life to avoid doing anything wrong
Aristotelian Balance
- Can't be too perfect because then you're too far on spectrum
- Qualities we think of as bad (like cowardice) sometimes needed to pull back from being too courageous
- Okay to be angry - just right amount of angry at right moments toward right people
- Doesn't have all answers about who are right people, when are right moments
- Feels very humane - knows you're human being who occasionally gets angry
- Very forgiving philosophy compared to Kant
Personal Ethical Journey - Hurricane Katrina Story
- Wife in fender bender, $836 damage claim for minor crease
- During Hurricane Katrina, Schur deeply affected by disaster
- Told other guy: "I'll give $836 to Red Cross, we'll call it even"
- Story went viral, $25,000 pledged to Red Cross if guy wouldn't fix bumper
- Suddenly felt "this is wrong and bad" but couldn't explain why
- Started reading moral philosophy, cold-calling philosophy professors
- Realized was doing "whataboutism" - using unrelated global tragedy to avoid local responsibility
- If everyone could do this, nothing would get solved - always something more important happening
- Eventually mailed guy check, apologized, came clean about whole story
- Key moment that sent him on philosophical path
Ethics as Muscle Development
- Ethics like muscle you can develop and practice
- Okay to fail - valid and productive way to get better
- Aristotelian approach: attempt virtue, fail, examine situation, debrief
- Understand if you were too much or not enough of something
- Use that information for next time
- Virtue ethics as data-driven as utilitarianism - collecting data on your own behavior
Questions Checklist for Ethical Decisions
- What am I doing?
- Why am I doing it?
- Is there something I could be doing that would be better?
- Why is it better?
- Quick, efficient checklist for slowly unfolding situations
- Usually pretty easy to answer if you take time for self-interrogation
Philosophy and Comedy Connection
- Main characters in his shows want to be good people
- Leslie Knope faced political ethical dilemmas
- Good Place explicitly about "how do I be a good person"
- Ron Swanson as proto-Kantian with strict code of ethics
- Had intense libertarian code but also valued honor, self-reliance, ethical behavior
- Didn't lie - "skim milk is water that's lying about being milk"
- Let him and Leslie find common ground despite opposite political views
Contemporary Philosophy and Accessibility
- Anyone engaged in philosophical ideas should be considered philosopher
- Tear down barriers to entry for being considered philosopher
- Should apply to anyone who actively grapples with ideas philosophers have offered
- World should be filled with philosophers
- "Call yourself a philosopher - if I can, anyone can"
Audience Q&A Highlights
- Passive harm reduction approach fits across frameworks but creates contradictions
- Pain from doing right thing is significant, real, needs factoring into equation
- Sometimes conclude right thing would cause too much pain - find next best alternative
- Example: confronting relatives with problematic worldviews vs ignoring
- Balance between small ongoing pain vs larger confrontational pain
- Some of ethics is gut feeling - theories provide scaffolding, then integrity and gut take over
- Would want philosophical debate with Ron Swanson, Captain Holt, Janet, or Jason Mendoza
- Brent Norwalk inspired by Robert Frank's book on luck and privilege
- People undervalue role of luck in their success
- Michael Jordan example - incredible athlete but lucky to be 6'6"
- Brent had no concept he was fortunate - "earned my spot just like my father and his father before him"
