AI summary by TwinMind

Microsoft Cracks Down On VS Code Forks

Theo - t3․gg

38m 46s

Background: Evolution of Code Editors

  • Sublime Text started minimal extensible editor revolution
    • Community-driven marketplace, free to use, fast, minimal
    • Not open source, paid editor with popup every 20 saves
    • Built foundation for community extensibility concept
  • GitHub created Atom as open source alternative
    • Built on Electron (invented for Atom distribution)
    • Fully free/open source, JavaScript-based extensions
    • Slower than Sublime, missing traditional IDE features
    • Poor startup times, less polished experience
  • Microsoft developed VS Code as response
    • Visual Studio team recognized community shift toward minimal editors
    • Positioned as "Visual Studio for webdevs"
    • Built on Electron, community extensible, fully free/open source
    • Better performance than Atom, strong TypeScript integration
    • TypeScript success drove initial VS Code adoption
    • Eventually led to Atom being deprecated/shut down

Current Extension Restriction Issue

  • April 2025: Users seeing error blocking Microsoft extensions in non-MS editors
    • C++ extension: "may only be used within Microsoft Visual Studio, Visual Studio for Mac, Visual Studio Code, Azure DevOps"
    • Also affects .NET and other Microsoft extensions
    • Impacts Cursor, Windsurf, and other VS Code forks
  • Problem particularly affects C++ developers using Cursor
    • Basic syntax highlighting and language features broken
    • Install specific version dropdown also removed
    • Workarounds involve downgrading to older extension versions

Cursor's Technical Evolution Timeline

  • April 2023: Cursor moved from CodeMirror to VS Code base
  • September 2023: Cursor introduced "Cursor marketplace"
    • Speculation: Likely wrapper around official VS Code marketplace
    • Previously used Open VSX marketplace from Eclipse
  • November 2024: Cursor marketplace switched back to Open VSX
    • Official Microsoft extensions no longer searchable in editor
    • Published guide: "How to install any VS Code extension in Cursor"
  • Most Cursor users imported extensions from existing VS Code setups
    • Didn't encounter marketplace issues initially
    • Extensions likely outdated but users unaware

Microsoft's Terms of Service Changes

  • 2021 VS Code marketplace terms: Vague restrictions on scraping/harvesting
  • January 2025: Much stricter terms published
    • "You may not import, install, or use offerings published by Microsoft or GitHub or Microsoft affiliates in any product or services except for the in-scope products and services"
    • Very explicit callout targeting wrapper implementations
  • February 2025: Microsoft removed download button from browser marketplace
    • Official reason: Issues with pre-release vs stable version downloads
    • Made manual extension installation much harder
    • Cursor's installation guide became obsolete

Extension Licensing Complexity

  • Many Microsoft extensions have confusing dual licensing
    • Source code: MIT licensed
    • Binary runtime components: Microsoft proprietary license
    • Easy to misunderstand actual usage restrictions
  • .NET extension requires paid Visual Studio subscription
    • Paying customers now blocked from using in alternative editors
  • C++ extension: Source available but not truly open source
    • Runtime components under restrictive proprietary licenses

Author's Conspiracy Theory Assessment

  • Believes restrictions result from 3 separate team decisions, not coordinated attack:
    1. Download button removal: Technical fix for version branching issues
    2. Extension restrictions: Language teams tired of bug reports from outdated forks
    3. VS Code agent mode: Competitive response to Cursor's AI features
  • Microsoft teams likely getting support burden from fork users
    • Forks based on 2-year-old VS Code versions
    • Important improvements may not be backported to forks
    • Results in compatibility issues and bug reports
  • Analogy: Author's own experience blocking Brave browser due to reCAPTCHA issues
    • Single browser causing disproportionate support burden
    • Similar to .NET team potentially blocking problematic forks

VS Code's Strategic Purpose

  • Never intended as revenue generator for Microsoft
  • Part of developer sentiment improvement strategy
    • Similar to TypeScript: improve dev experience and reputation
    • First good cross-platform editor from Microsoft
  • Goal: Make developers love Microsoft again
    • Position for future revenue opportunities
    • Not direct monetization of editor itself

Future Implications and Predictions

  • VS Code forks will adapt through:
    • Better import workflows from VS Code
    • Encouraging developers to publish on Open VSX marketplace
    • Development of open alternatives to proprietary language runtimes
  • .NET development particularly impacted
    • .NET developers frustrated by Cursor restrictions
    • Unlikely to see good .NET experience in Cursor going forward
  • Microsoft unlikely to pursue aggressive legal action
    • Would damage developer relations they've worked to rebuild
    • Bad optics similar to historical Netscape lawsuit
  • Open source alternatives to proprietary components likely to emerge

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome