AI summary by TwinMind
Most People Don't Realize Just HOW Concentrated The Economy Has Become
How Money Works
12m 3s
Economic Concentration Overview
- Big companies getting bigger, rich people getting richer
- Vital resources (housing, business equity, food, water) owned by smaller share of people than ever
- Private equity controls 20% of entire US economy
- Top index funds own 20-30% of all major US listed companies
- Fraud also becoming bigger and more concentrated
- Economies of scale encouraging businesses to become "too big to fail"
Private Equity Market Transformation
- Changed from small niche for select families to biggest asset holders globally in 15 years
- McKinsey report: over $13 trillion controlled as of June last year, likely higher now
- Private equity = any investment in business/security not listed on public markets
- Growth not due to amazing returns but result of overly concentrated financial system
Decline in Public Companies
- Number of publicly listed companies almost halved while economy tripled in size since 1990s
- Bigger companies acquiring smaller ones at record rates
- Fewer IPOs because no need anymore - general public lacks money
- Wealthiest 10% of Americans own 93% of all publicly listed stocks
- Majority of capital flowing into public markets comes from people/institutions rich enough for private equity
- Regulatory/reporting burden of public companies not worth accessing 90% of people who own just 7% of market
- 93% stock ownership held through retirement accounts managed by funds that can invest in private equity
Micro-Monopolies Problem
- Private equity creating small local monopolies
- Example: Youth sports leagues - $3 billion industry becoming more expensive as consolidated
- Buy up all sports in local area, create monopoly on competitive team activities
- Federal Trade Commission lacks manpower to identify/enforce thousands of local issues
- Can't even address most obvious monopolies due to resource constraints
Market Transparency Issues
- Hard to see what's happening in economy when businesses owned by small group of investment firms
- Public companies must release regular financial statements, market value updated continuously
- Private equity makes it harder to tell how businesses performing/being run
- John Coates (Harvard): "The Problem of 12" - when few financial institutions control everything
- Pension funds investing in private equity on behalf of regular people
- Two financial institutions between people and actual business investments
- Makes normal price discovery much harder
Index Fund Concentration
- Vanguard, BlackRock, State Street concentration issues
- Vanguard VOO ETF mindlessly invests in weighted average of 505 stocks in S&P 500
- Large share of investors just investing in whatever has most investors
- Contributes to immense valuations of companies at top of market
- Investment managers have significant influence over shareholder votes
- ESG/green ETFs can have more board influence than they should
Corporate Debt Crisis
- Most biggest private equity firms use leveraged buyouts
- Buy companies, make them take big loans, use borrowed money to pay themselves back
- Involves cost cutting so businesses can make repayments
- Contributed to record levels of corporate debt in America
- Corporate debt as % of GDP only higher during first wave of PPP loans and after 2008 financial crisis
Employment and Competition Impact
- Corporate concentration makes finding competitive job opportunities extremely difficult
- Especially affects people in smaller communities with local businesses rolled up by investment funds
- Best way to get higher salary is switching jobs, but if all local businesses owned by same holding company, no negotiation power
- Example: All plumbing businesses in area owned by same holding company
Barriers to New Business Creation
- Lilian Salo (healthcare entrepreneur): Difficulty bringing safer medical syringe to market
- Supply chain businesses highly consolidated, didn't want to work with potential competitor
- Anti-competitive practice but regulators understaffed/underfunded
- Worse in scalable industries like technology
Startup Investment Problems
- Early stage investors look for "exit strategy" - who will buy successful company
- Buyers are either few industry top players or private equity firms
- Only companies with highest scale potential and best acquisition opportunity get funded
- Silicon Valley shifted from solving world's problems to writing algorithms for extra 20 seconds phone engagement
- Ross Bears (VC firm president): "stagnant pool of American entrepreneurship"
Entrepreneurship Challenges
- Difficult to start company and raise capital from professional investors
- Programs like Y Combinator highly competitive
- People with connections/experience know best strategy is building for acquisition
- Tech workers told coding would provide stable career became "giant casino"
- Workers either get life-changing payouts or face record layoffs
