AI summary by TwinMind
“New Evidence” That CO2 Doesn’t Cause Global Warming? I Don’t Think So.
Sabine Hossenfelder
9m 0s
Paper Overview and Background
- Recent publication titled "Climatic Consequences of the Process of Saturation of Radiation Absorption in Gases" published March, circulated by science denier outlets
- Abstract claims continued experimental work needed to determine if additional CO2 is greenhouse gas
- Conclusions state "serious doubts" about CO2's climate influence despite majority of publications depicting catastrophic future
- No data used for research described in article
- Published in Elsevier engineering journal by three researchers from Institute of Opto-Electronics (not climate scientists)
- Actually republication of earlier papers, including one published in Polish few years ago
Experimental Method and Claims
- Authors measured infrared light absorption by CO2 multiple times (done thousands of times before)
- New approach: measured infrared light from Moon passing through entire atmosphere
- Placed glass tube with CO2 in front of telescope
- Found additional absorption of infrared light "practically negligible"
- Concluded additional CO2 doesn't absorb thermal radiation, therefore emissions can continue without climate impact
Fundamental Misunderstanding of Greenhouse Effect
- Authors misunderstood how greenhouse effect actually works
- Earth receives energy from Sun as visible light, converted to infrared at surface
- Infrared light trapped in atmosphere by CO2, keeping planet warm
- Problem: rapidly increasing CO2 concentration from burning fossil fuels makes it harder for planet to give off heat
- Issue isn't warming per se, but rapid adaptation requirements consuming resources
Atmospheric Absorption Reality
- Water vapor provides biggest part of atmospheric absorption
- Human activity has no direct influence on water vapor concentration (determined by air-ocean equilibrium)
- CO2 emissions partly in same range as water vapor
- For most part, absorption is saturated - infrared light from Earth's surface never reaches top of atmosphere
- Typical travel distance: few hundred meters depending on wavelength and weather conditions
Correct Greenhouse Effect Mechanism
- Greenhouse effect doesn't work by stopping individual light quanta from passing through entire atmosphere undisturbed
- Increasing CO2 concentration moves average altitude where infrared light can escape into space further up
- Higher atmosphere is colder on average, making cooling less efficient
- Net effect: CO2 reduces infrared emissions until atmosphere below warms up again
- Effect depends on average altitude of emission
Scientific Validation
- William Happer (physicist, former climate change denier) published 2020 paper
- Redid entire calculation of infrared emission dependence on altitude
- Concluded same as climate scientists
- Happer's paper helped explain how greenhouse effect actually works
Common Misconceptions
- People misinterpret IPCC radiation flux images
- Think arrows show individual light quanta paths
- Images actually show total flux amounts going out
- Infrared light escapes at top of atmosphere after scattering many times
Publication Quality Assessment
- Paper described as "embarrassment" that got published
- Recommendation: Elsevier should retract or add explanation that authors misunderstood global warming causes
- Alternative: rebrand as "spot the mistake" puzzle
