AI summary by TwinMind
New startup wants to build a conscious quantum computer
Sabine Hossenfelder
7m 44s
Nanic Startup Overview
- Vancouver-based startup founded by Suzanne Gildart
- Goal: build first conscious AI on quantum computer using Roger Penrose's consciousness theories
- Gildart background:
- PhD in quantum field from University of Birmingham
- Previously worked on robotics, sold company for several hundred million dollars
- Worked with D-Wave quantum computing company
Google Connection & Hartmut Neven
- Website claims alignment with "top people at Google" on consciousness research
- Hartmut Neven (VP Engineering, Google Quantum):
- Believes quantum information science may answer consciousness questions
- Conjecture: consciousness emerges from single classical world out of multiverse
- Started experimental program testing conjecture using quantum neurobiology methods
- Same person who wrote Google Willow chip blog post claiming parallel universe evidence
- Co-author of "wormhole on quantum computer" paper
Penrose-Hameroff Orchestrated Objective Reduction (Orch-OR) Theory
- Nanic's approach inspired by Penrose-Hameroff theory
- Claims consciousness aligns with quantum mechanics properties:
- Entanglement
- Superposition
- Measurement
- Goal: create conscious agentic AI systems aligned with human values
Penrose's Consciousness Arguments
- Penrose argues consciousness is not computable
- Reasoning: humans understand Gödel's theorem while algorithms cannot (would contradict Gödel's theorem)
- Counter-argument: computer algorithms have proven Gödel's theorem using symbolic reasoning
- Irony: Nanic wants to build conscious computer based on Penrose's "non-computable" consciousness theory
Microtubule Theory Problems
- Penrose-Hameroff theory: consciousness created in brain microtubules
- Microtubules create coherent superpositions that collapse, creating consciousness
- Issues with theory:
- Microtubules present throughout body, not brain-specific
- Not specific to humans
- Controversial whether significant quantum effects exist
- Unclear connection between quantum effects and consciousness
- Computer simulations already model microtubule behavior on classical computers
Red Flags on Website
- Claims "first-person experience and free will are properties of consciousness unexplainable by classical physics"
- States "superposition creates feeling of choice"
- Both statements highly questionable and empirically unsupported
Consciousness Research Landscape
- Recent review paper listed 200+ consciousness theories
- Most theories have nothing to do with quantum mechanics
- Current state: "better chances finding consciousness in fridge than quantum computer"
- Carrots have microtubules too
Quantum Computing Use Case Contradiction
- If Penrose-Hameroff correct: either consciousness non-computable OR computable on classical computer
- Neither scenario supports quantum computing as necessary for consciousness
- No clear quantum advantage demonstrated for consciousness simulation
