AI summary by TwinMind
Noncompete Agreements, Come On | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
50m 3s
Introduction and Overview
- Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant discuss non-compete agreements (NCAs) on "Stuff You Should Know" podcast
- 1 in 5 Americans (20% of workers) work under non-compete agreements
- Hosts express strong opposition to NCAs, calling them "onerous," "scummy," and anti-competitive
- NCAs prevent employees from working for competitors or starting competing businesses for specified time periods (typically 6 months to 5 years)
- Include geographical restrictions and time limitations
Legitimate Business Reasons for Non-Competes
- Trade secrets protection: Preventing employees from taking proprietary information to competitors
- Example: Former Coke employees attempting to sell recipe to Pepsi
- Investment protection: Companies investing in employee training/education want return on investment
- Training costs and time investment in small businesses
- Graduate school funding with employment commitment
- Client base retention: Preventing employees from taking established customer relationships
- Common in hair salons, law firms, veterinary clinics
- Some industries (attorneys, fiduciaries) avoid NCAs due to client choice importance
Historical Development
- 15th-16th century England: Master craftsmen and apprentice system
- Dyer's case (1414): First major precedent ruling against non-competes
- Court ruled labor should remain in public domain
- People should be allowed to make living from learned skills
- Precedent lasted hundreds of years favoring employees
- Mitchell vs Reynolds (1711): Exception case involving equal parties
- Baker leased business to Mitchell with non-compete agreement
- Court upheld because parties had equal bargaining power
- Reynolds violated agreement and had to pay 50 pounds
- Industrial capitalism shift: Mid-1800s courts became more pro-employer
- "Freedom of contract" principle emerged
- Courts assumed equal footing between parties
American Legal Development
- 1851: First major US non-compete ruling
- Reconstruction Era: Legal scholar Aisha Bell Hardaway argues anti-NCA precedents established
- Black Codes and predatory business contracts
- 13th Amendment protections against wage slavery
- Federal government intervention against exploitative labor contracts
- 1872: California banned non-competes entirely
- Most of 20th century: Limited enforcement, mainly for trade secrets
Modern Prevalence and Statistics
- Executive level: 60-80% work under non-competes
- Private sector workers: 20% overall under NCAs
- Low-wage workers: 12% making under $20,000/year have NCAs
- Service/food industry: 17% under non-competes
- Average NCA worker: Hourly employee making $14/hour
- Consideration: High-level executives can negotiate additional compensation; hourly workers get only employment as "consideration"
Problematic Examples
- New York Times 2014 exposé: Lawn care workers, hair stylists, summer camp counselors signing NCAs
- Jimmy John's case: Sandwich shop employees couldn't work for competitors within 3 miles
- Dropped practice after state attorney general investigation
- No-poach agreements: Franchise owners couldn't hire from other locations of same company
- Eliminated after state investigations
Economic Impact Studies
- Oregon 2008 study: Banned NCAs for low-wage workers
- Hourly wages rose 2-3% for all workers statewide
- Workers previously under NCAs saw 14-21% wage increases
- FTC estimates: National NCA elimination would:
- Create job opportunities for 30 million workers
- Raise wages by $300 billion
- Reduce healthcare costs by $148 billion (doctor mobility)
California vs Massachusetts Case Study
- 1970s: Boston and San Francisco had comparable tech development
- California's NCA ban: Enabled Silicon Valley's dominance
- Massachusetts: NCAs hindered tech growth, finally banned in 2018
- Key factor: California allowed job mobility and startup formation
Arguments Against Non-Competes
- Stifles job churn: Prevents workers from finding optimal employer matches
- Reduces competition: Companies can't improve through employee feedback/departure
- Power imbalance: Inherent unfairness between employer and employee
- Analogy: Like ex-boyfriend preventing dating for a year after breakup
- Societal harm: Reduces innovation, competition, and consumer benefits
Pro-NCA Arguments (US Chamber of Commerce)
- Investment incentive: Companies more likely to train employees if they stay
- Equal consideration: Employees receive benefits in exchange for signing
- Freedom of contract: Adults should be able to enter any agreement
- Counter-arguments: ROI on training typically recovered quickly; power imbalance negates "freedom"
Alternative Agreements
- Non-disclosure agreements (NDAs): Protect trade secrets without employment restrictions
- Intellectual property agreements: Company owns ideas developed during employment
- Non-solicitation agreements: Can't recruit former colleagues or customers
- Garden leave/pay not to play: Company pays 50% salary during non-compete period
Current Enforcement Problems
- California companies: Still use illegal NCAs to intimidate employees
- Threat tactics: Sue employees who don't know NCAs are unenforceable
- Broad NDAs: Written so broadly they function as non-competes
- Worker shortage response: Increased lawsuit threats to retain employees
Recent Policy Developments
- Biden 2021 executive order: Encouraged FTC to ban/limit NCAs
- January 2023 FTC proposal: Would ban all non-competes and void existing ones
- Requirements: Employers must notify workers that existing NCAs are invalid
- Broad NDAs: Also banned if they effectively function as non-competes
- Public comment period: Through March 20th, 2023
- Opposition: Chamber of Commerce threatens lawsuit
- Congressional backup: Bipartisan 2021 bill introduced as alternative
Personal Anecdotes
- Chuck's hair stylist Robin (Thomas's wife, Ruby's friend's mom)
- Josh's hair stylist Michael
- John Hodgman working at Maine breakfast shop for fun
- Hosts' experience with podcast contracts and enforceability
