AI summary by TwinMind

Noncompete Agreements, Come On | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

50m 3s

Introduction and Overview

  • Josh Clark and Chuck Bryant discuss non-compete agreements (NCAs) on "Stuff You Should Know" podcast
  • 1 in 5 Americans (20% of workers) work under non-compete agreements
  • Hosts express strong opposition to NCAs, calling them "onerous," "scummy," and anti-competitive
  • NCAs prevent employees from working for competitors or starting competing businesses for specified time periods (typically 6 months to 5 years)
  • Include geographical restrictions and time limitations

Legitimate Business Reasons for Non-Competes

  • Trade secrets protection: Preventing employees from taking proprietary information to competitors
    • Example: Former Coke employees attempting to sell recipe to Pepsi
  • Investment protection: Companies investing in employee training/education want return on investment
    • Training costs and time investment in small businesses
    • Graduate school funding with employment commitment
  • Client base retention: Preventing employees from taking established customer relationships
    • Common in hair salons, law firms, veterinary clinics
    • Some industries (attorneys, fiduciaries) avoid NCAs due to client choice importance

Historical Development

  • 15th-16th century England: Master craftsmen and apprentice system
  • Dyer's case (1414): First major precedent ruling against non-competes
    • Court ruled labor should remain in public domain
    • People should be allowed to make living from learned skills
    • Precedent lasted hundreds of years favoring employees
  • Mitchell vs Reynolds (1711): Exception case involving equal parties
    • Baker leased business to Mitchell with non-compete agreement
    • Court upheld because parties had equal bargaining power
    • Reynolds violated agreement and had to pay 50 pounds
  • Industrial capitalism shift: Mid-1800s courts became more pro-employer
    • "Freedom of contract" principle emerged
    • Courts assumed equal footing between parties

American Legal Development

  • 1851: First major US non-compete ruling
  • Reconstruction Era: Legal scholar Aisha Bell Hardaway argues anti-NCA precedents established
    • Black Codes and predatory business contracts
    • 13th Amendment protections against wage slavery
    • Federal government intervention against exploitative labor contracts
  • 1872: California banned non-competes entirely
  • Most of 20th century: Limited enforcement, mainly for trade secrets

Modern Prevalence and Statistics

  • Executive level: 60-80% work under non-competes
  • Private sector workers: 20% overall under NCAs
  • Low-wage workers: 12% making under $20,000/year have NCAs
  • Service/food industry: 17% under non-competes
  • Average NCA worker: Hourly employee making $14/hour
  • Consideration: High-level executives can negotiate additional compensation; hourly workers get only employment as "consideration"

Problematic Examples

  • New York Times 2014 exposé: Lawn care workers, hair stylists, summer camp counselors signing NCAs
  • Jimmy John's case: Sandwich shop employees couldn't work for competitors within 3 miles
    • Dropped practice after state attorney general investigation
  • No-poach agreements: Franchise owners couldn't hire from other locations of same company
    • Eliminated after state investigations

Economic Impact Studies

  • Oregon 2008 study: Banned NCAs for low-wage workers
    • Hourly wages rose 2-3% for all workers statewide
    • Workers previously under NCAs saw 14-21% wage increases
  • FTC estimates: National NCA elimination would:
    • Create job opportunities for 30 million workers
    • Raise wages by $300 billion
    • Reduce healthcare costs by $148 billion (doctor mobility)

California vs Massachusetts Case Study

  • 1970s: Boston and San Francisco had comparable tech development
  • California's NCA ban: Enabled Silicon Valley's dominance
  • Massachusetts: NCAs hindered tech growth, finally banned in 2018
  • Key factor: California allowed job mobility and startup formation

Arguments Against Non-Competes

  • Stifles job churn: Prevents workers from finding optimal employer matches
  • Reduces competition: Companies can't improve through employee feedback/departure
  • Power imbalance: Inherent unfairness between employer and employee
  • Analogy: Like ex-boyfriend preventing dating for a year after breakup
  • Societal harm: Reduces innovation, competition, and consumer benefits

Pro-NCA Arguments (US Chamber of Commerce)

  • Investment incentive: Companies more likely to train employees if they stay
  • Equal consideration: Employees receive benefits in exchange for signing
  • Freedom of contract: Adults should be able to enter any agreement
  • Counter-arguments: ROI on training typically recovered quickly; power imbalance negates "freedom"

Alternative Agreements

  • Non-disclosure agreements (NDAs): Protect trade secrets without employment restrictions
  • Intellectual property agreements: Company owns ideas developed during employment
  • Non-solicitation agreements: Can't recruit former colleagues or customers
  • Garden leave/pay not to play: Company pays 50% salary during non-compete period

Current Enforcement Problems

  • California companies: Still use illegal NCAs to intimidate employees
  • Threat tactics: Sue employees who don't know NCAs are unenforceable
  • Broad NDAs: Written so broadly they function as non-competes
  • Worker shortage response: Increased lawsuit threats to retain employees

Recent Policy Developments

  • Biden 2021 executive order: Encouraged FTC to ban/limit NCAs
  • January 2023 FTC proposal: Would ban all non-competes and void existing ones
  • Requirements: Employers must notify workers that existing NCAs are invalid
  • Broad NDAs: Also banned if they effectively function as non-competes
  • Public comment period: Through March 20th, 2023
  • Opposition: Chamber of Commerce threatens lawsuit
  • Congressional backup: Bipartisan 2021 bill introduced as alternative

Personal Anecdotes

  • Chuck's hair stylist Robin (Thomas's wife, Ruby's friend's mom)
  • Josh's hair stylist Michael
  • John Hodgman working at Maine breakfast shop for fun
  • Hosts' experience with podcast contracts and enforceability

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome