AI summary by TwinMind
Not Everyone Should Code
PolyMatter
8m 47s
Programming Salary and Market Demand
- Average computer programmer salary: $79,840 in America
- Even lowest paid 10% make more than average American
- High pay due to high demand and growing importance
- Programming treated differently than other high-paying professions (surgeons make 3x more, dentists, psychologists, lawyers also well-paid)
Political and Corporate Motivations Behind "Everyone Should Code"
- Politicians promote coding because:
- More programming jobs = more taxes, spending, economic activity
- Technology companies have international influence
- Regulatory power over tech companies = global influence
- America's power tied to hosting global tech giants
- Technology companies promote "everyone should code" to:
- Flood market with needed skills
- Increase supply of programmers
- China recognizes strategic importance, considers price too high to pay
Economic Reality and Specialization Principles
- Specialization is foundation of civilization and economic efficiency
- People have different talents and abilities
- Economic laws dictate specialization as long as jobs exist
- Programming is one good career path among many, not universal skill
- Comparison to surgery: high demand but not for everyone
Programming vs Computer Science Distinction
- 14-week coding bootcamps teach basic programming
- Programming: memorizing what to type to make computer do things
- Computer science: solving efficient, creative, mathematical problems
- Companies pay six-figure salaries for computer science skills, not basic programming
- Red flag: if you can become developer in 14 weeks, either companies overpay or there's much more to it
Market Saturation and Salary Effects
- Unrealistic job promotion increases supply
- Increased supply leads to falling salaries
- Instagram example: 7 million users with only 4 employees
- Demand for programming exists but not unlimited
- Attracting wrong people (money-motivated only) leads to job dissatisfaction
Educational Considerations
- Programming teaches problem-solving and creative thinking
- But other subjects also provide these benefits
- If 60 minutes of school time available, better options might be:
- Personal finance
- Critical media consumption
- Public speaking
- Debate and critical thinking
- Coding classes should be available for interested students, not required
- People learn differently, at different paces, like different things
Accessibility vs Oversimplification Problem
- Good teaching makes complex topics accessible through simplification
- Risk of oversimplification that misleads rather than educates
- "Everyone should code" movement oversimplifies programming reality
- Shows programming as "tap-tap-tap" rather than long hours solving problems
- Attracts people who may end up hating the actual work
