AI summary by TwinMind
Paul Slovic | Confronting the Deadly Arithmetic of Compassion | Talks at Google
Talks at Google
50m 22s
Speaker Introduction & Background
- Paul Slovic: Stanford bachelor's, University of Michigan PhD in psychology (1976)
- Founded Decision Research institute with Sarah Lichtenstein and Baruch Fishoff (1976)
- Professor of psychology at University of Oregon since 1986
- 60 years researching risk perception, starting with simple gambling experiments
- Research evolved from casino gambling prototypes to real-life risks (genocides, nuclear war, climate change)
- Extensive mentoring worldwide, organizes virtual get-togethers for community building
Evolution from Gambling to Risk Research
- Started 1959 at University of Michigan studying personality theory
- Got involved with professor testing economic theories about utility maximization in gambling decisions
- Professor skeptical that people maximize utility through calculations
- 60 years later still studying "gambles" - now real-life risks we face daily
- Journey from abstract gambling experiments to humanitarian problems
Individual Risk Perception - System 1 vs System 2 Thinking
- Initial assumption: people do mental calculations (probability × payoff = expectation)
- Reality: most people rely on intuitive gut feelings, not calculations
- Risk is mostly represented as a feeling, not result of calculation
- System 1 (Stanovich & West, popularized by Kahneman 2011): fast, intuitive, gut feeling
- Easy, feels natural, seems right, usually works
- System 2: analytic, uses reasons, calculations, logic (taught in school)
- Most time spent in System 1 mode because it's easy and efficient
- Focus on when System 1 fails and how to defend against feeling-based mistakes
Community Risk Perception & Bystander Effect
- Individual life valued very highly - people risk own lives to save others
- As numbers increase, response doesn't increase proportionally
- First life most important, second doesn't feel twice as important
- By 6-7 lives, additional lives don't feel different
- Feelings can't do math - arithmetic of compassion is flawed
- Example: 200,000 vs 400,000 deaths in genocide feels the same (psychic numbing)
- Large numbers bounce off without creating feelings
- Failure to feel reality of large numbers leads to tolerating massive harms
The Deadly Arithmetic of Compassion - Three Components
1. Psychic Numbing
- Concept originated with psychiatrist Robert Lifton studying atomic bomb rescue workers
- Workers had to turn off feelings to function (good side of psychic numbing)
- Dark side: insensitivity to large numbers of victims
- Donation experiments: response declines as number of children needing help increases
- Rwanda refugee camp experiment:
- Scenario: official deciding whether to send pumping equipment for clean water
- Could save 4,500 people indefinitely
- Group 1: 4,500 out of 11,000 total in camp
- Group 2: 4,500 out of 250,000 total in camp
- Much higher willingness to help when saving 4,500 out of 11,000 vs 250,000
- People respond to proportion saved, not absolute number
2. Pseudo Inefficacy (False Inefficacy)
- Linked to sense of efficacy in making difference
- Going from 250,000 to 245,000 doesn't feel effective
- Even small numbers of people you can't help dampens response
- Experiment: helping one child when six others can't be helped reduces donations
- Even helping one of two children (instead of just one) reduces response
- Warm glow effect: satisfaction from helping someone diminished when others can't be helped
- False sense of inefficacy prevents helping even when you really can make difference
3. Prominence Effect (Security Prominence)
- Occurs when values conflict (e.g., stopping genocide vs national security)
- Moral obligation to stop genocide conflicts with:
- National security concerns
- Military costs
- Political relationships with other nations
- When facing conflict, people focus on most defensible dimensions
- Security, homeland protection, cost-cutting more defensible than protecting "statistical lives"
- Security dominates choices regardless of lives lost
- Makes people choose in ways that violate stated values
Climate Change Application
- Scientists warning for half century, only paying attention when consequences hit personally
- All three elements apply to climate change:
- Psychic numbing: problem seems distant, happening to others, lacks emotional connection
- Pseudo inefficacy: individual actions feel like "drop in bucket"
- Prominence effect: near-term comforts/convenience outweigh long-term planetary benefits
- Solutions require government/industry action:
- Can't rely only on warnings (like UN reports)
- Need carrots and sticks - rewards for right behavior, costs for wrong behavior
- Provide options to satisfy needs with less climate harm
- Higher costs for flood insurance, fossil fuel use
- Renewable energy technologies and alternatives
Communication Strategies for Climate Change
- Abstract numbers (1.5-2.5°C temperature rise) don't create emotional connection
- Need translation to experiential terms:
- Percentage of days over 40°C in specific regions
- Visual representations of sea level rise effects on familiar cities/beaches
- Make information come alive with feeling rather than abstract statistics
COVID-19 as Behavioral Problem
- Exponential growth misunderstanding: people extrapolate linearly, vastly underestimate exponential curves
- Early action most effective for exponential spread, but people didn't grasp urgency
- Reward/punishment backwards:
- Doing right things (masks, isolation): immediate punishment (restrictions), no immediate reward
- Doing wrong things (parties, no masks): immediate reward (freedom), no immediate punishment
- COVID as much behavioral problem as medical problem
- Need to combine behavioral knowledge with medical knowledge
Resources & Websites
- decisionresearch.org: Decision Research institute publications (free access)
- arithmeticofcompassion.org: specialized site with:
- Information on psychic numbing, pseudo inefficacy
- Blogs connecting psychological factors to current world events
- Take action section with practical steps
- Welcome contributions for blog section
Personal Well-being & Research Approach
- Finds purpose and excitement in learning things that may be helpful
- Works collaboratively with community of researchers (not alone)
- Admits to own psychic numbing - discusses problems from statistical distance
- Wife works directly with refugees locally, experiences emotional reality
- Contrasts abstract statistical work with personal, emotional refugee assistance work
