AI summary by TwinMind
Physics Update January 2020
Sabine Hossenfelder
5m 9s
Gravitational Wave Detection Issues
- Missing electromagnetic counterparts to gravitational wave detections remain problematic
- Russian physicists claimed evidence for gamma ray event coincident with gravitational wave detection
- Found in binary neutron star merger data from INTEGRAL satellite mission
- Analysis quickly criticized informally by field experts
- No formal correspondence published yet
- Current status: Still missing confirmation that LIGO and Virgo interferometers detect actual outer space signals
Dark Energy Evidence Under Question
- New supernova data analysis showed observations can be explained without dark energy
- Supernova data = major evidence physicists have for dark energy
- Dark energy discovery awarded Nobel Prize in 2011
- Swift criticism of new analysis by another group
- Criticism focused on coordinate system use (which was the original analysis's main point)
- Original paper authors debunked the criticism
- Current status: Authors maintain their position
- Quanta Magazine quoted astrophysicists claiming supernova evidence for dark energy is sound
- No further reasons provided
- Common pattern: Challenges to accepted results get criticized, then everyone quotes criticism to avoid thinking about problem
Upcoming Interview
- Lead author Zu Berserker located in Oxford
- Interview scheduled for next month visit to Oxford
- Will explain work directly
Additional Supernova Research
- New paper (few days ago) claims supernovae not good standard candles
- Luminosity may depend on average age of star going supernova
- Distant supernovae = younger stars (light traveled longer to reach us)
- Younger vs older stars have different luminosities when exploding
- Creates bias that can mimic dark energy effects
- Author claims dark energy not needed to explain observations
- Complication: Two different reasons why dark energy might not exist
- Question: What happens if both effects combined?
- Emphasis: Supernova data not only evidence for dark energy
- Need global fit of all available data before drawing conclusions
Particle Physics Status Update
- Mikhail Schiffman published opinion piece on arXiv
- Title: "Musings on Current Status of High-Energy Physics"
- Key points:
- Low-energy supersymmetry ruled out and gone
- Naturalness concept (basic principle theorists followed for decades) also gone
- Footnote: Principle never substantiated by arguments other than aesthetical
- Naturalness was main reason physicists expected Large Hadron Collider to see new particles besides Higgs boson
- This has not happened
- Principle of naturalness now dead due to conflict with observation
- Particle physics community has not analyzed how large group based research on obviously non-scientific arguments for so long
- Something seriously wrong occurred - if not understood, can happen again
