AI summary by TwinMind
Pixel 3 XL vs iPhone XS Max vs Galaxy Note 9 CAMERA TEST Comparison
Mrwhosetheboss
10m 2s
Device Setup and Overview
- Comparison between Google Pixel 3 XL, Samsung Galaxy Note 9, iPhone XS Max
- Screen indicators show audio source from each device
- Front camera footage recorded at 1080p for initial comparison
Front Camera Video Performance
- Google Pixel 3 XL features exclusive group selfie mode with wider angle
- Software corrects fisheye effect normally seen in wide-angle cameras
- Pixel 3 XL captures more in frame than other two devices
- Android phones (Pixel 3 XL, Note 9) struggle with consistent vibrant color profile
- iPhone XS Max has "Beauty gate" problems making skin tone too even
- Both Android phones couldn't balance face lighting with background visibility
- Either face bright with blown out background or face dark with visible background
Rear Camera Video Capabilities
- All phones record 4K video
- Google Pixel 3 XL notably doesn't record 4K at 60fps
- Less disparity between rear cameras compared to front cameras
- iPhone has deeper sky color and high contrast look
- Note 9 has high contrast in dark areas
- Color and contrast largely personal preference for standard video
Slow Motion Features
- All three phones shoot 240fps at 1080p
- Samsung Note 9 has super slow motion: 960fps at 720p (short clips only)
- Super slow motion is luxury feature despite lower resolution and short duration
Video Stabilization
- Google Pixel 3 introduces "fused video stabilization"
- More effective at 1080p but visible even at 4K
- More stable than Note 9 and iPhone XS Max (already top performers)
- At 1080p resolution, Pixel 3 stabilization is exceptional
- Samsung Note 9 stabilization too aggressive, swings side to side
Low-Light Video Performance
- Galaxy Note 9 loses control of highlights in bright areas
- Note 9 exposure dialed down making blacks very dark
- Pixel 3 edges out iPhone in road detail
- iPhone has better highlight control (blue neon lighting example)
- Note 9 consistently dark and soft
- Pixel 3 has sharpest of three images
- Pixel 3 pulls ahead of iPhone in grain performance
- iPhone tries too hard for even lighting, creating visual noise in dark sky areas
Front Camera Photo Performance
- Samsung has wider lens fitting more in image
- Pixel 3 has dark, grungy aesthetic across all photo types
- Samsung slightly brighter and more flattering
- iPhone appears to have beauty filter effect
- iPhone maintains well-lit sky in selfies
Google Pixel 3 Exclusive Features
- Top Shot: corrects for shaking/blinking by offering alternative shots after capture
- Group selfie mode: pinch out display for dramatically wider field of vision
- Selfie focus mode: portrait mode on front camera
- Pixel 3 has sharpest output among three phones
- Note 9 weakest in portrait mode with background disappearing and soft face focus
Low-Light Selfie Performance
- Samsung selfie camera catches up in low-light, matches Pixel sharpness
- iPhone maintains flat image with highlight control like rear camera
- iPhone increases shutter time for low-light, increasing blur likelihood
- Pixel 3 has Playground mode for AR emojis but image processing turns off, creating grainy photos
Portrait Mode Testing
- Challenging scenario with difficult background differentiation
- All three phones struggle with complex backgrounds
- All have adjustable background blur levels
- iPhone loses body focus when adjusting blur but allows much more background blur
- Pixel can refocus after shot taken
- Note 9 loses highlight detail in lighter shirt areas
Landscape Photography
- Google Pixel 2 established reputation for best smartphone camera in this category
- Pixel 3 XL aces landscape photography as expected
- Photos have distinctive character, recognizable without labels
- Pixel overcompensates in saturation and contrast
- 8 out of 10 times would choose Pixel photos
- Pixel 3 photos feel as good as Pixel 2 but not significantly better
- Processing advantage remains unchanged from Pixel 2
Low-Light Photography
- Only iPhone has consistent color profile between photos and videos
- Note 9: darkest videos but lightest photos due to F1.5 aperture
- Pixel has darker, higher contrast feel preferred by reviewer
- Note 9 captures more detail due to wide aperture
- Google announced upcoming night shot mode (not yet available for testing)
- Expected to dramatically change low-light performance similar to Huawei P20 Pro
Zoom Performance and Super Res Zoom
- Note 9 and iPhone have telephoto lenses for closer objects without detail loss
- Google uses single lens with innovative "super res zoom"
- Pixel 3 takes series of slightly different shots using natural hand movement
- Pieces shots together for higher resolution picture
- Samsung slightly clearer in details but Pixel surprisingly close
- Note 9 and iPhone: 12MP sensors, Pixel 3: 12.2MP
- Megapixel difference doesn't translate to higher detail
- Pixel 3 and iPhone have smoother pictures when zoomed in
Motion Autofocus Feature
- Google's new motion autofocus mode tracks objects to maintain focus
- Testing showed no significant improvement to video recording experience
- Pixel 3 had more focus failures than other two phones
- Feature may improve over time but currently not impressive
