AI summary by TwinMind
Please Stop Asking For Mentorship
Theo - t3․gg
9m 56s
Personal Experience with Mentorship
- Never had traditional mentor as software dev
- Had helpful managers at moments but no consistent go-to person
- Believes lack of mentor contributed to success
- Software dev success = handling failure well, not who you know
The Mentorship Request Problem
- Receives couple DMs weekly asking "will you be my mentor"
- Two valid interpretations:
- Already mentoring through content (valid)
- Requesting dedicated personal time (unrealistic)
- Can't dedicate individual time to random audience members
Cost and Economics of Mentorship
- Video content = efficient: one creation helps thousands/hundreds of thousands
- Individual mentorship = expensive: more time, often less results
- Requires understanding individual needs, communication styles
- Takes ton of time to figure out what individual needs
- Current content creation motivated by desire to help, not money
- Could make more money in engineering career or business
Learning Through Peer Exposure vs Mentorship
- Best learning at Twitch through lunch conversations
- Surrounded by smarter, more experienced engineers
- Heard thoughts on new tech, outages, current projects
- Value came from exposure to different perspectives
- Seeing experienced people debate/push back on ideas
- Helped build own stances rather than copying one person
- Traditional mentorship would have limited this growth
Problems with Traditional Mentor-Mentee Relationships
- Both sides get screwed
- Mentee just follows mentor's advice without questioning
- Even with disagreement, not mentee's place to push back
- Reduces likelihood of finding what's right for them
- Example: 1 hour solving problem vs 2 hours call + 3 days code review
Quality Issues with Free Mentorship
- High-quality mentors won't work for free due to expense
- Available free mentors often lower quality
- Still valuable to participate in communities
- Can ask specific project questions and get responses
The Failure Problem
- Software dev involves constant failure
- Need to get good at pushing through failures independently
- Shouldn't lean on others when failures happen
- Support groups valuable (why university/bootcamps work)
- Mentorship shouldn't be solution for loneliness or feeling lost
Goal Setting and Self-Direction
- Bad goals: "want to be programmer" or "learn JavaScript"
- Need specific goals around things you understand
- Theo's example: hosting Minecraft server for friends
- Required learning git, Java, server hosting, SSH, tmux, screen
- Knew what success looked like even without understanding parts
- Could join communities and ask informed questions
Show Your Work Philosophy
- Don't spam random commits
- Build demos with interesting technologies
- Post online with context about what you built
- Example: "built demo with TanStack Router for X purpose"
- When asking for help, show effort and provide specific code links
- "Can you be my mentor" = someone fallen behind asking to be caught up
Success Story: Ethan Niser Example
- Early community member who shared cool projects
- Built next-type-safe-URL bringing type safety to router
- Created Beth stack and YouTube channel
- Didn't ask permission or how-to questions
- Asked if Theo would make video, when told no, did it himself
- Success came from learning lessons and applying them creatively
- Responded because of exciting work, not mentor-seeking
Key Principles for Success
- Excitement and energy must come from within
- People seeking mentors often lack internal drive
- Another person will never be reason for developer success
- Others can be tools in toolbox but you define the path
- Need to realize path is wrong and change course multiple times
- Must find interesting things that drive you through hard parts
- Learn to lean into failure rather than avoid it
- Share lessons learned from failures
Final Message
- Stop seeking mentorship, start seeking interesting projects
- Need to push through failure instinct independently
- Once you do that, you'll naturally work on interesting things
- Don't need permission to learn - just go build and learn
- Come back when you have cool things to share
