AI summary by TwinMind
PT Barnum: More Complicated Than You've Heard | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
58m 23s
Introduction and Movie Critique
- Movie "The Greatest Showman" heavily criticized as "musical whitewashing"
- Film portrayed fantasy version of P.T. Barnum's life
- Reality: Barnum was complex character who did "some good but also horrible things"
- Not first showman, but introduced America to "pure unadulterated hucksterism"
Early Life and Background (1810-1834)
- Born 1810 in Bethel, Connecticut
- Family: great-great grandfather came from England as indentured servant in 17th century
- Father Philo - unsuccessful farmer
- Hated manual farm work but loved enterprising activities
- Father died when he was 15, became family provider
- Worked as store clerk, learned swindling tricks
- Started lotteries using unsellable tin kitchenware as prizes
- Sold ~1,000 tickets in small town
- Discovered could make money expanding other people's lotteries
- Hired others to sell tickets even further out
- Married Charity Hallett - described as "fair, rosy cheeked, buxom girl, beautiful white teeth"
- Started newspaper "The Herald of Freedom"
- Exposed corruption legitimately
- Hit with libel suit, spent 60 days in jail
- Jail time boosted paper sales, hailed as hero
- 1834: Connecticut banned lotteries, moved family to New York City
Early Show Business Career (1834-1841)
- Tried various jobs: boarding house, grocery store, contracted smallpox
- 1835: Purchased Joyce Heth for $1,000
- Elderly blind slave, supposedly 161 years old
- Claimed to be George Washington's nursemaid
- Toured with her until death in 1836
- When business slow, anonymously claimed she was robot made of "whale bone, rubber and springs"
- Sold tickets to public autopsy in saloon
- Autopsy revealed she was ~80 years old, not 161
- Next act: Signor Antonio (renamed Signor Vivalla)
- Plate spinner/balancer performer
- Staged competitions with rival Roberts for $1,000 prize
- Created fake East Coast vs West Coast rivalry
- 1836: Joined traveling circus as ticket seller
- Started own "Barnum's Grand Scientific and Musical Theater"
- Tried steamboat circus on Mississippi River
- Attempted "respectable" business manufacturing grease paste and cologne
- Sold illustrated Bibles
The American Museum Era (1841-1868)
- 1841: Purchased Scudder's American Museum for $15,000
- Renamed "Barnum's American Museum"
- Charged 25 cents admission, had 4,000 visitors daily
- 850,000 pieces on display
- Featured dancers, musicians, ventriloquists, "little people," "big people," bearded ladies, robots, puppets, animals, giraffes, grizzly bears
Three Major Successes:
- Fiji Mermaid (1842)
- Rogue taxidermy: baboon head, orangutan torso, fish tail
- Made by Japanese sailor in 1820s
- Created fake Dr. J. Griffin character as British naturalist
- Wrote fake letters about touring mermaid, mailed to friends nationwide to send to NY newspapers
- General Tom Thumb (Charles Stratton)
- 4-year-old little person, stopped growing at 2 feet tall
- Claimed he was 11 years old
- Became media sensation, met royalty during tours
- Huge success for both Barnum and Stratton
- Jenny Lind "Swedish Nightingale" (1850)
- Offered $1,000 per performance
- Made ~$500,000 from tour
- Legitimized Barnum's reputation
- Lind donated entire $300,000 American earnings to Sweden's public school system
Financial Troubles and Recovery (1850s)
- Invested in East Bridgeport development, wanted to make it "Hampton Place"
- Invested in Jerome Clock Company relocation
- Company went bankrupt, Barnum went broke
- Mansion burned down after he moved out (Fire #1)
- Put museum in wife's name to avoid bankruptcy
- Spent 5 years in debt, then bought museum back
- During recovery: lecture tour "The Art of Money Getting," toured with Tom Thumb, bought dead whale, hippopotamus, two beluga whales
Political Conversion and Civil War Era
- Originally Jacksonian Democrat
- Civil War sparked total conversion to abolitionist
- Museum became segregated initially (normal for time)
- Converted to Union supporter, used museum for abolitionist cause
- Southern copperheads protested outside, threatened his life
- April 1865: Won election to Connecticut General Assembly
- Worked to ratify 13th Amendment
- Supported voting rights for black people in Connecticut
- Revised autobiography to be more contrite, less boastful
Museum Fires and Circus Transition
- 1865: Museum burned down with animals and exhibits (Fire #2)
- Opened new museum, burned down 3 years later (Fire #3)
- Didn't rebuild second museum
The Circus Years (1870s-1890)
- 1871: Partnered with William Cameron Coup
- Created "P.T. Barnum's Grand Traveling Museum, Menagerie, Caravan and Circus"
- First circus to travel by train with traditional format
- Made $400,000 first year
- Officially called "The Greatest Show on Earth"
- 1872: Fire at winter camp (site of current Madison Square Garden) killed more circus animals (Fire #4)
- Wife Charity died while he was visiting friend John Fish in England
- 3.5 months later: Secretly married Fish's 22-year-old daughter Nancy (Barnum was 63)
- Public wedding 9 months after secret ceremony
Political Career and Personal Changes
- 1875: Became mayor of Bridgeport
- Quit drinking, campaigned against Sunday sales and saloons
- Sponsored Comstock Law in Connecticut banning contraception (lasted until 1965)
- Became self-righteous about moral issues
Final Circus Partnership
- 1880: Partnered with James A. Bailey
- "P.T. Barnum's Great London Combined" (terrible name)
- Acquired Jumbo the elephant - legendary attraction
- 1885: Jumbo killed by train
- Displayed Jumbo's preserved hide and skeleton
- Barnum was benefactor to Tufts University - Jumbo became their mascot
- Barnum and Bailey split, rejoined 1887
- Stayed together until circus closed 2016
Death and Legacy
- 1890: Had stroke during performance
- Strange final wish: wanted obituary published before death
- New York Evening Sun published it while he was alive
- Died shortly after reading his own obituary
