AI summary by TwinMind
REALLY Big Experiments That Physicists Dream Of
Sabine Hossenfelder
8m 12s
Current State: Large Hadron Collider (LHC)
- Nearly 100,000 subscribers milestone reached
- LHC: currently biggest experiment in operation
- 27 kilometer circular tunnel
- Accelerates protons using powerful magnets
- Magnets cooled to few degrees above absolute zero
- Collision energies: 14 TeV (Tera Electron Volt)
- Tests structures 10^-19 meters (1000x smaller than proton diameter)
- Proton size: 10^-15 meters, atom size: 10^-10 meters
- Restarted operations May 2021
Future Circular Collider (FCC)
- CERN announced plans for bigger collider
- 100 kilometer tunnel length
- Target: 100 TeV collision energy (6x LHC capability)
- Purpose: measure particle properties more precisely
- Criticism: particles live only microseconds, mainly keeps physicists employed
Extreme Collider Proposals
- Prof Sir David King (former UK Chief Scientific Advisor) warning: "draw line somewhere, otherwise collider around equator"
- Gulf of Mexico proposal: 1,900 kilometer circumference collider
- Milky Way-sized collider deemed unrealistic
- James Beachman (particle physicist): interstellar space 3°C above absolute zero still too warm for magnets
- Would require massive helium cooling system
- Earth equator collider challenges:
- Altitude differences
- Earth diameter pulses every 21 minutes (fundamental vibrational mode)
- Constant earthquake excitation of vibrational modes
Moon-Based Experiments
- Moon advantages: minimal seismic activity, no life, quiet except asteroid impacts, no atmosphere
Radio Telescope on Far Side of Moon
- Study "dark ages" of early universe
- Period: after cosmic microwave background emission, before first stars
- Could reveal normal matter and dark matter behavior
- 21 centimeter astronomy:
- Hydrogen atoms emit 21cm wavelength light when colliding
- Wavelength stretches with universe expansion
- Signal very weak, hard to measure from Earth
- Few telescopes already searching for dark ages signal
Neutrino Beam Experiment
- February 2021 proposal: neutrino source on moon beaming to Earth
- Study neutrino oscillation during travel
- Known: neutrinos oscillate between types (electron-neutrino ↔ muon-neutrino)
- Existing measurements show oddities suggesting missing information
Gravitational Wave Interferometer
- Recent proposal (originally from 1990s)
- Moon less noisy than Earth (densely populated, seismically active)
- Downside: no people on moon to build machine
Solar System Gravitational Wave Detection
- Harvard University physicists' proposal
- Trail of atomic clocks along Earth's annual solar orbit
- Gravitational waves change signal travel time between clocks and Earth
- Advantages:
- Detect much longer wavelength gravitational waves than Earth/moon interferometers
- Long wavelengths created by supermassive black hole collisions
- Could reveal galactic core processes
Economic Reality Assessment
- Common traits: great for physicists, big scale, expensive
- Slim chances of realization due to cost
- Physicist tendency: ignore economic reality, think bigger rather than smaller/cheaper
- Critique: "bigger isn't always better"
