AI summary by TwinMind
Risk - Understanding Investment Uncertainty
The Plain Bagel
9m 21s
Introduction to Investment Risk and Human Psychology
- Basic financial theory: risk correlated to return - can't have reasonable payoff without uncertainty
- 53% of Millennials don't have investments, 6 out of 10 cite fear of losing money as reason
- Human brain is risk-averse by nature - result of survival of the fittest
- Ancestors who valued security lived to pass on genes and preference for safety
- Loss aversion: people feel more strongly about losing money than gaining same amount
- Example: finding $20 feels good, losing $20 can ruin your day
- Many refuse to accept slightly better odds to avoid risk
The Problem with Low-Risk Investments
- Hard to earn reasonable return without taking on risk
- Low-risk investments like savings accounts typically don't offer returns needed to reach goals
- Money barely keeps up with inflation
- Often need higher risk investments to achieve objectives
Defining Investment Risk
- Risk = exposure to loss, chance of investments decreasing in value
- Amount of risk depends on specific investments held
- Many use securities volatility as proxy for risk (price fluctuations result from investor uncertainty)
- Better approach: qualitative standpoint understanding types of events that could hurt investment value
Specific Risk Types
- Interest rate risk: central banks (Federal Reserve, Bank of Canada) increasing interest rates, increasing business costs
- Credit risk: company defaulting on debt
- Inflation risk: inflation higher than expected, reducing value of invested money
Two Main Categories of Investment Risk
Market/Systemic Risk
- Impacts all companies operating in certain country
- Example: economy entering recession reduces overall spending, hurts company values
- Harder to predict and avoid since impacts larger number of companies
Idiosyncratic/Company-Specific Risk
- Hazards specific to small number of organizations
- Examples: new competitor opening, negative regulatory changes in specific industry, CEO scandal
- Every investment faces unique set of these risks
- Can be reduced through diversification
Diversification Strategy
- Holding different companies from different geographies and sectors
- Averages out impacts of specific company issues
- Example: holding 5 car companies instead of 1 reduces impact of one firm's emissions test cheating
- Financial theory: diversified investors achieve better total returns and lower overall risk
- Clear benefit to spreading out holdings
Limitations of Diversification
- Far from perfect strategy
- Power strongest when investments are uncorrelated (performance moves independently)
- Research shows during recessions correlation between investments increases
- Investments begin moving together, reducing diversification benefit when needed most
- Even safe investments like gold (theoretically uncorrelated) tend to move with stock returns as market volatility increases
- Can't immunize investor from risk, only adjust level of uncertainty
Risk Tolerance Components
Willingness to Take Risk
- Heavily influenced by personality type and financial literacy level
- Someone kept awake by 5% market drop has lower willingness vs. someone checking holdings once yearly
- Subjective but very important for managing emotions
- Gut-wrenching anxiety at every decline inhibits ability to rationally govern holdings
Ability to Bear Risk
- Related to financial situation with many moving parts:
- Time horizon
- Level of wealth
- Expected future income
- Generally: less money and less time = less risk tolerance
- Many market risks are short-term in nature (recession may last few years, company may recover after replacing troubled executive)
- Constrained time horizon increases likelihood of being hit in returns
Historical Market Recovery Data
- S&P 500 analysis shows every decline from financial crises (2005 bubble, 2008 mortgage crisis) fully recovered within 10-year timeframe
- Not guarantee losses always recovered, but timing important factor
- Someone forced to sell at bottom of crash doing so at worst possible time
Portfolio Risk Adjustment Strategies
Stock vs. Bond Allocation
- Primary method: altering money invested in stock market vs. other securities
- Stocks generally higher risk investment
- Higher risk tolerance = larger percentage in stocks
- Rest in bonds or cash securities (more legal safety nets, limited value fluctuations)
- Young adult saving for retirement: more stocks than bonds
- Individual living off savings: may have no stock market exposure
Individual Holdings Risk Adjustment
- Owning junk bonds instead of government bonds
- Investing in emerging markets instead of developed countries
- Both increase risk and return potential
Long-term Investment Perspective
- Most risks are short-term in nature
- For retirement savings, doesn't matter if stock went down 3% on Tuesday
- Focus only on permanent issues posing serious threat to holdings
- Being aware of risk exposure important, but obsessing over day-to-day changes gets caught up in market mood swings
- Focus on long-term performance and diversify when possible
Final Recommendations
- If easily affected by fluctuations, seek advisor help through ups and downs
- Accept that risk is necessity of investing
- Many greatest investment opportunities arise during downturns
- Chance to buy low during market downs
- With steady hand and disciplined approach, investment returns likely outweigh risks over time
