AI summary by TwinMind

Ryan Phelan: The intended consequences of helping nature thrive | TED

TED

15m 48s

Introduction to Elizabeth Ann - Black-footed Ferret Cloning

  • Elizabeth Ann: cloned black-footed ferret, America's most endangered animal
  • Cloned using cells from ferret that lived 33 years ago
  • New hope for species restoration, chance to restore lost genetic diversity
  • Born for intended consequence of genetic rescue

Conservation Biotechnology Background

  • Speaker: 10 years working in conservation with innovative scientists worldwide
  • Bringing biotechnology to wildlife conservation
  • Addressing escalating threats: climate change, habitat loss, fragmented populations, wildlife diseases
  • Unintended consequences of human-dominated time
  • Need new tools for conservation toolbox
  • Genetic rescue can help stop species crossing extinction line

Black-footed Ferret Case Study

  • Historical range: Great Plains North America, Canada to Mexico
  • Habitat conversion to ranches/farmland caused decline
  • By 1981: only one colony in Wyoming
  • Brought into captivity, US Fish and Wildlife Service breeding/releasing 30 years
  • Current population: 600 living ferrets
  • All descendants of just 7 ancestors
  • Inbreeding jeopardizes long-term wild survival
  • Solution: reached back in time using banked cells

San Diego Zoo Bio Banking Initiative

  • Started 1975: Dr. Oliver Ryder and team banking endangered species
  • Used banked cell lines for genetic rescue
  • Elizabeth Ann has 3x more genetic variation than any living ferret
  • When breeds in next couple years, offspring will create greater species resilience

Przewalski's Horse Project

  • Only true wild horse species remaining in world
  • Historical range: Central Asia, Pacific to Atlantic Ocean for centuries
  • Extinct in wild, only several horses left in captivity
  • Reintroduction since 1960
  • Current population: 2,000 horses at risk of inbreeding
  • Extinction vortex: small fragmented populations lose genetic variation, risk extinction spiral

Kurt the Przewalski's Foal

  • Genetic rescue example reversing extinction vortex
  • Surrogate mother: American Quarter Horse (different species)
  • Kurt's genome: all wild horse
  • One year later (August): wild, healthy, vibrant Przewalski's horse

Biotechnology Tools for Conservation

  • Essential tool: genomic sequencing, bringing information to light for species management
  • Bio banking, cell culturing, in vitro technologies enable genetic rescue
  • Technologies not widely adopted by conservation
  • Hope to change adoption rates

Emerging Technologies and Climate Adaptation

  • Genetic engineering promise: help species adapt climate change, solve wildlife disease, invasive species problems
  • Often technologies never get out of starting gate
  • Fear of unintended consequences stymies basic innovation

Coral Conservation Crisis

  • Most diverse/rich ecosystems in world
  • Provide biodiversity for reef-dwelling fish, ocean life
  • 50% Great Barrier Reef lost to climate change/environmental degradation
  • Estimates: by 2050 could lose 90% world's coral
  • Hope: scientists utilizing new technologies
  • Cryopreserving living coral fragments for artificial reef transplantation
  • Stem cell development for genome editing thermal resilience to warming oceans

Addressing Unintended Consequences Concerns

  • Question: "Genetically modified corals? What about unintended consequences?"
  • Research on human intervention disasters vs successes
  • Classic disaster examples: rodents on islands from colonial ships
  • Invasive species caused >60% extinctions worldwide since early 1500s
  • Cane toad Australia 1935: sugar cane industry brought poisonous invasive toad for beetle control
  • Didn't help beetles, spread across Australia killing native species
  • Disasters happened in era with little environmental ecosystem regard
  • Some done for profit, not conservation benefit

Conservation Intervention Success Stories

  • Never hear about success stories
  • Research on conservation interventions shows different story
  • Over century globally: scientists introducing/reintroducing plants/animals with no environmental harm
  • Classic success: wolves to Yellowstone
  • Over 1,000 species introduced across North America last 125 years
  • Only 1 documented case causing local extinction: native freshwater fish, small spring Alabama
  • 99% interventions succeeded in achieving intended consequence
  • Success often invisible to public

Great Smoky Mountains Management Example

  • America's most visited national park
  • Appears pristine wilderness, actually very managed environment
  • Elk: absent 200 years, reintroduced
  • Meadow: result of repeated controlled burns
  • Non-native insects used controlling pathogens/invasive pests

American Chestnut Tree Restoration

  • Historically: majestic tree rained sweet nuts, fed humans/animals centuries
  • Thousands of years: most abundant tree species eastern deciduous forest
  • Lumber used: fine musical instruments, hardwood furniture
  • Until 1800: 4 billion trees across forest
  • Fungal blight (imported invasive species) wiped out trees
  • By 1950: all 4 billion trees decimated
  • Scientists tried decades creating blight-resistant chestnut
  • Success: State University of New York identified single gene from wheat conveying blight resistance
  • Genetically modified trees: first chance 100 years restoring majestic trees
  • US Department of Agriculture reviewing trees for wild release

Call for Public Engagement

  • Bold initiatives require public engagement/support:
    • Engineering coral withstand warming waters
    • Restoring American chestnut tree
    • Genetic rescue black-footed ferret
  • Matters how people think about intervention
  • Need balance thinking about risk
  • Always unexpected outcomes to innovation
  • Have tools/technology/protocols minimize risks, maximize benefits

Conclusion and Philosophy

  • Think first about intended consequences for bold new ideas
  • Don't have luxury of time to wait and see
  • Thousands plants/animals at risk today
  • Doing nothing can cause extinction
  • Carefully/intentionally plan with all tools in toolbox
  • Create future we want, not overreact to future we fear

Q&A with Chris Anderson

  • Moral question at heart of work
  • Moral philosophers: no difference between intentional action and intentional inaction leading to same thing
  • Public policy/environmental movement: huge distinction between action/inaction
  • People prefer not acting and seeing something go wrong vs taking risk of acting
  • Scientists face public pressure, don't want to get it wrong
  • Risk losing jobs, funding, security, public shame
  • Easier to stand by, do nothing, not take ownership
  • Advantage of inaction: less likely to be blamed, but don't get credit either

De-extinction Projects Discussion

  • Technologies allow actual de-extinction of species planet hasn't seen for years
  • American chestnut tree almost extinct (sprouts appear but fail within 15 years)
  • Working on: woolly mammoth, passenger pigeon
  • De-extinction is big, hairy, audacious goal
  • Getting there: genetic rescue tools/technology can save endangered species
  • Fundamental tool kit approach

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome