AI summary by TwinMind
Ryan Phelan: The intended consequences of helping nature thrive | TED
TED
15m 48s
Introduction to Elizabeth Ann - Black-footed Ferret Cloning
- Elizabeth Ann: cloned black-footed ferret, America's most endangered animal
- Cloned using cells from ferret that lived 33 years ago
- New hope for species restoration, chance to restore lost genetic diversity
- Born for intended consequence of genetic rescue
Conservation Biotechnology Background
- Speaker: 10 years working in conservation with innovative scientists worldwide
- Bringing biotechnology to wildlife conservation
- Addressing escalating threats: climate change, habitat loss, fragmented populations, wildlife diseases
- Unintended consequences of human-dominated time
- Need new tools for conservation toolbox
- Genetic rescue can help stop species crossing extinction line
Black-footed Ferret Case Study
- Historical range: Great Plains North America, Canada to Mexico
- Habitat conversion to ranches/farmland caused decline
- By 1981: only one colony in Wyoming
- Brought into captivity, US Fish and Wildlife Service breeding/releasing 30 years
- Current population: 600 living ferrets
- All descendants of just 7 ancestors
- Inbreeding jeopardizes long-term wild survival
- Solution: reached back in time using banked cells
San Diego Zoo Bio Banking Initiative
- Started 1975: Dr. Oliver Ryder and team banking endangered species
- Used banked cell lines for genetic rescue
- Elizabeth Ann has 3x more genetic variation than any living ferret
- When breeds in next couple years, offspring will create greater species resilience
Przewalski's Horse Project
- Only true wild horse species remaining in world
- Historical range: Central Asia, Pacific to Atlantic Ocean for centuries
- Extinct in wild, only several horses left in captivity
- Reintroduction since 1960
- Current population: 2,000 horses at risk of inbreeding
- Extinction vortex: small fragmented populations lose genetic variation, risk extinction spiral
Kurt the Przewalski's Foal
- Genetic rescue example reversing extinction vortex
- Surrogate mother: American Quarter Horse (different species)
- Kurt's genome: all wild horse
- One year later (August): wild, healthy, vibrant Przewalski's horse
Biotechnology Tools for Conservation
- Essential tool: genomic sequencing, bringing information to light for species management
- Bio banking, cell culturing, in vitro technologies enable genetic rescue
- Technologies not widely adopted by conservation
- Hope to change adoption rates
Emerging Technologies and Climate Adaptation
- Genetic engineering promise: help species adapt climate change, solve wildlife disease, invasive species problems
- Often technologies never get out of starting gate
- Fear of unintended consequences stymies basic innovation
Coral Conservation Crisis
- Most diverse/rich ecosystems in world
- Provide biodiversity for reef-dwelling fish, ocean life
- 50% Great Barrier Reef lost to climate change/environmental degradation
- Estimates: by 2050 could lose 90% world's coral
- Hope: scientists utilizing new technologies
- Cryopreserving living coral fragments for artificial reef transplantation
- Stem cell development for genome editing thermal resilience to warming oceans
Addressing Unintended Consequences Concerns
- Question: "Genetically modified corals? What about unintended consequences?"
- Research on human intervention disasters vs successes
- Classic disaster examples: rodents on islands from colonial ships
- Invasive species caused >60% extinctions worldwide since early 1500s
- Cane toad Australia 1935: sugar cane industry brought poisonous invasive toad for beetle control
- Didn't help beetles, spread across Australia killing native species
- Disasters happened in era with little environmental ecosystem regard
- Some done for profit, not conservation benefit
Conservation Intervention Success Stories
- Never hear about success stories
- Research on conservation interventions shows different story
- Over century globally: scientists introducing/reintroducing plants/animals with no environmental harm
- Classic success: wolves to Yellowstone
- Over 1,000 species introduced across North America last 125 years
- Only 1 documented case causing local extinction: native freshwater fish, small spring Alabama
- 99% interventions succeeded in achieving intended consequence
- Success often invisible to public
Great Smoky Mountains Management Example
- America's most visited national park
- Appears pristine wilderness, actually very managed environment
- Elk: absent 200 years, reintroduced
- Meadow: result of repeated controlled burns
- Non-native insects used controlling pathogens/invasive pests
American Chestnut Tree Restoration
- Historically: majestic tree rained sweet nuts, fed humans/animals centuries
- Thousands of years: most abundant tree species eastern deciduous forest
- Lumber used: fine musical instruments, hardwood furniture
- Until 1800: 4 billion trees across forest
- Fungal blight (imported invasive species) wiped out trees
- By 1950: all 4 billion trees decimated
- Scientists tried decades creating blight-resistant chestnut
- Success: State University of New York identified single gene from wheat conveying blight resistance
- Genetically modified trees: first chance 100 years restoring majestic trees
- US Department of Agriculture reviewing trees for wild release
Call for Public Engagement
- Bold initiatives require public engagement/support:
- Engineering coral withstand warming waters
- Restoring American chestnut tree
- Genetic rescue black-footed ferret
- Matters how people think about intervention
- Need balance thinking about risk
- Always unexpected outcomes to innovation
- Have tools/technology/protocols minimize risks, maximize benefits
Conclusion and Philosophy
- Think first about intended consequences for bold new ideas
- Don't have luxury of time to wait and see
- Thousands plants/animals at risk today
- Doing nothing can cause extinction
- Carefully/intentionally plan with all tools in toolbox
- Create future we want, not overreact to future we fear
Q&A with Chris Anderson
- Moral question at heart of work
- Moral philosophers: no difference between intentional action and intentional inaction leading to same thing
- Public policy/environmental movement: huge distinction between action/inaction
- People prefer not acting and seeing something go wrong vs taking risk of acting
- Scientists face public pressure, don't want to get it wrong
- Risk losing jobs, funding, security, public shame
- Easier to stand by, do nothing, not take ownership
- Advantage of inaction: less likely to be blamed, but don't get credit either
De-extinction Projects Discussion
- Technologies allow actual de-extinction of species planet hasn't seen for years
- American chestnut tree almost extinct (sprouts appear but fail within 15 years)
- Working on: woolly mammoth, passenger pigeon
- De-extinction is big, hairy, audacious goal
- Getting there: genetic rescue tools/technology can save endangered species
- Fundamental tool kit approach
