AI summary by TwinMind

Samsung Foundry vs TSMC

Asianometry

10m 7s

Samsung Foundry Market Position & Recent Wins

  • Samsung foundry arm of sprawling Samsung group, pushed into top echelon of standalone foundry industry
  • Aggressively taking client business from market leader TSMC in recent months
  • Last 3 months won business from major fabless semiconductor companies:
    • Qualcomm: middle class mobile chip 750 (8nm process), higher end 875 (5nm process)
    • Nvidia: RTX 380/390 graphics card (8nm process)
    • IBM: Power 10 (7nm process)
    • Google and Cisco: products unreported
  • All these companies previously worked with TSMC, some were core TSMC customers

Market Share Evolution

  • Q2 2020: Samsung foundry leapfrogged competitors (UMC, Global Foundries) into 2nd place behind TSMC
  • Market share growth: 3.7% (2016) → 19.1% (Q2 2020)
  • Q3 2020: TSMC beat back competition, took share from Samsung and whole industry
    • TSMC settled at 54% industry share according to Trend Force
    • Movement likely due to big purchases by Huawei and Apple

Samsung Foundry Strategy & Advantages

  • Entered foundry industry 2005, first major customer was Qualcomm
  • Already strong position in memory chip market (DRAM)
    • DRAM world highly cyclical: revenues fluctuate ~35% year-to-year
  • Built foundry capacity initially for internal smartphone/devices businesses
  • Created new business line servicing other companies using former internal division
  • Parent Samsung Electronics doesn't break out foundry revenues/earnings individually
    • Rolled up with memory chips business
    • Foundry somewhat shielded from pressures of making money
  • TSMC publicly traded, stock scrutinized by shareholders (sometimes monthly)
  • Samsung foundry can undercut TSMC on pricing per wafer for advanced nodes
    • Every dollar saved = dollar profits earned for fabless companies

Samsung Technology & Investment Approach

  • Pushes hard on adopting latest/greatest technologies as sales pitch
  • One of last leading edge foundries in market
  • Executive VP ES Jung: "need technology that can wow clients, without advanced technology difficult to win back customers from rivals"
  • One of few foundries with good number of EUV machines (built by ASML)
    • Second probably only to TSMC
  • Samsung group capital expenditures: $18B (2019), estimated $23B (2020)
    • Most spend going towards memory business
    • Unknown amount dedicated to foundry business

Samsung Market Position Advantage

  • Position as "last leading edge foundry" more critical than people think
  • Fabless semiconductor makers wanting leading edge process: only TSMC or Samsung
  • Global Foundry stopped all 7nm development (2018)
  • UMC focuses on specialty processes
  • SMIC has own issues
  • Market pretty small, not being TSMC gives Samsung place in foundry market
  • Keeps Taiwanese giant from complete stranglehold, prevents monopoly

TSMC Competitive Advantages

  • Dedicated foundry, literally invented the industry
  • Don't compete with customers (core marketing tactic)
  • First mover advantage allowed majority market share grab
  • Consistently over 50% market share for entire dedicated foundry industry
  • Ecosystem core strength:
    • Manufacture 10,000+ different products
    • Using 260 distinct technologies
    • For 500+ customers
    • Feedback loops from close customer relationships increase technical/business competitive advantages

TSMC Investment & Financial Performance

  • Capital expenditures as big or bigger than Samsung's
  • Regularly spends $15B+ annually on foundries
  • TSMC alone makes 50%+ of Taiwan's entire R&D spend
  • Higher sales per wafer than Samsung:
    • TSMC: ~$3,338 per wafer (average across all technologies)
    • Samsung: ~$2,490 per wafer
  • Higher number due to product mix - cutting edge tech wafers cost more
  • Market estimates: 5nm nodes ~$17,000 per 300mm wafer
  • 36% of TSMC revenues from 7nm or smaller nodes
  • Samsung: ~20% of sales from such nodes
  • TSMC more profitable selling more high-end wafers

Technology Development Approaches

  • TSMC style more conservative than Samsung's
  • TSMC takes step-by-step approach, partly because need to deliver for customers without fail (especially Apple)
  • Conservative approach means fall behind in adopting cutting-edge technologies
  • Example: 7nm process generation
    • Samsung first to adopt new EUV lithography
    • TSMC first generation 7nm stuck with older DUV process
    • EUV only came later in that process node
  • Conservative approach means better product quality, more apt to scale

Technical Performance Comparison

  • Transistor density comparison (not end-all metric, other factors like yield matter):
    • Samsung 5nm EUV process: ~126M transistors per square mm
    • TSMC comparable 5nm EUV process (making Apple A14): ~173M transistors per square mm

Future Market Outlook

  • Samsung likely to capture more market share in future
  • Can keep taking share from rest of competition
  • Samsung group good market track record (only recall failing in automobiles)
  • Money from memory chips business
  • Captive customer in handsets business
  • Determined to make market impact

Market Constraints & Challenges

  • Forces keeping TSMC in first place for foreseeable future
  • Leading edge nodes only getting more expensive for foundries and fabless companies
  • Cost of developing single 3nm node chip: ~$1.5B all-in
  • Technologies/nodes not exactly one-to-one interchangeable
  • Costs increasingly shrink market of customers who can afford
  • Raises costs of switching for companies wanting to switch foundries
  • Results in solidified circle of luxury customers and luxury providers at leading edge

Apple as Market Wild Card

  • Apple biggest single most important foundry customer in world
  • Probably even more so after Huawei got booted
  • Apple's checks fund wave of R&D development other companies can ride
  • TSMC allowed entire 5nm output to go to single client (Apple)
  • As long as Apple stays with TSMC, TSMC stays number one and keeps market share
  • Competitive market pushes both companies

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome