AI summary by TwinMind
Samsung Foundry vs TSMC
Asianometry
10m 7s
Samsung Foundry Market Position & Recent Wins
- Samsung foundry arm of sprawling Samsung group, pushed into top echelon of standalone foundry industry
- Aggressively taking client business from market leader TSMC in recent months
- Last 3 months won business from major fabless semiconductor companies:
- Qualcomm: middle class mobile chip 750 (8nm process), higher end 875 (5nm process)
- Nvidia: RTX 380/390 graphics card (8nm process)
- IBM: Power 10 (7nm process)
- Google and Cisco: products unreported
- All these companies previously worked with TSMC, some were core TSMC customers
Market Share Evolution
- Q2 2020: Samsung foundry leapfrogged competitors (UMC, Global Foundries) into 2nd place behind TSMC
- Market share growth: 3.7% (2016) → 19.1% (Q2 2020)
- Q3 2020: TSMC beat back competition, took share from Samsung and whole industry
- TSMC settled at 54% industry share according to Trend Force
- Movement likely due to big purchases by Huawei and Apple
Samsung Foundry Strategy & Advantages
- Entered foundry industry 2005, first major customer was Qualcomm
- Already strong position in memory chip market (DRAM)
- DRAM world highly cyclical: revenues fluctuate ~35% year-to-year
- Built foundry capacity initially for internal smartphone/devices businesses
- Created new business line servicing other companies using former internal division
- Parent Samsung Electronics doesn't break out foundry revenues/earnings individually
- Rolled up with memory chips business
- Foundry somewhat shielded from pressures of making money
- TSMC publicly traded, stock scrutinized by shareholders (sometimes monthly)
- Samsung foundry can undercut TSMC on pricing per wafer for advanced nodes
- Every dollar saved = dollar profits earned for fabless companies
Samsung Technology & Investment Approach
- Pushes hard on adopting latest/greatest technologies as sales pitch
- One of last leading edge foundries in market
- Executive VP ES Jung: "need technology that can wow clients, without advanced technology difficult to win back customers from rivals"
- One of few foundries with good number of EUV machines (built by ASML)
- Second probably only to TSMC
- Samsung group capital expenditures: $18B (2019), estimated $23B (2020)
- Most spend going towards memory business
- Unknown amount dedicated to foundry business
Samsung Market Position Advantage
- Position as "last leading edge foundry" more critical than people think
- Fabless semiconductor makers wanting leading edge process: only TSMC or Samsung
- Global Foundry stopped all 7nm development (2018)
- UMC focuses on specialty processes
- SMIC has own issues
- Market pretty small, not being TSMC gives Samsung place in foundry market
- Keeps Taiwanese giant from complete stranglehold, prevents monopoly
TSMC Competitive Advantages
- Dedicated foundry, literally invented the industry
- Don't compete with customers (core marketing tactic)
- First mover advantage allowed majority market share grab
- Consistently over 50% market share for entire dedicated foundry industry
- Ecosystem core strength:
- Manufacture 10,000+ different products
- Using 260 distinct technologies
- For 500+ customers
- Feedback loops from close customer relationships increase technical/business competitive advantages
TSMC Investment & Financial Performance
- Capital expenditures as big or bigger than Samsung's
- Regularly spends $15B+ annually on foundries
- TSMC alone makes 50%+ of Taiwan's entire R&D spend
- Higher sales per wafer than Samsung:
- TSMC: ~$3,338 per wafer (average across all technologies)
- Samsung: ~$2,490 per wafer
- Higher number due to product mix - cutting edge tech wafers cost more
- Market estimates: 5nm nodes ~$17,000 per 300mm wafer
- 36% of TSMC revenues from 7nm or smaller nodes
- Samsung: ~20% of sales from such nodes
- TSMC more profitable selling more high-end wafers
Technology Development Approaches
- TSMC style more conservative than Samsung's
- TSMC takes step-by-step approach, partly because need to deliver for customers without fail (especially Apple)
- Conservative approach means fall behind in adopting cutting-edge technologies
- Example: 7nm process generation
- Samsung first to adopt new EUV lithography
- TSMC first generation 7nm stuck with older DUV process
- EUV only came later in that process node
- Conservative approach means better product quality, more apt to scale
Technical Performance Comparison
- Transistor density comparison (not end-all metric, other factors like yield matter):
- Samsung 5nm EUV process: ~126M transistors per square mm
- TSMC comparable 5nm EUV process (making Apple A14): ~173M transistors per square mm
Future Market Outlook
- Samsung likely to capture more market share in future
- Can keep taking share from rest of competition
- Samsung group good market track record (only recall failing in automobiles)
- Money from memory chips business
- Captive customer in handsets business
- Determined to make market impact
Market Constraints & Challenges
- Forces keeping TSMC in first place for foreseeable future
- Leading edge nodes only getting more expensive for foundries and fabless companies
- Cost of developing single 3nm node chip: ~$1.5B all-in
- Technologies/nodes not exactly one-to-one interchangeable
- Costs increasingly shrink market of customers who can afford
- Raises costs of switching for companies wanting to switch foundries
- Results in solidified circle of luxury customers and luxury providers at leading edge
Apple as Market Wild Card
- Apple biggest single most important foundry customer in world
- Probably even more so after Huawei got booted
- Apple's checks fund wave of R&D development other companies can ride
- TSMC allowed entire 5nm output to go to single client (Apple)
- As long as Apple stays with TSMC, TSMC stays number one and keeps market share
- Competitive market pushes both companies
