AI summary by TwinMind
Samsung Galaxy S21 Ultra vs iPhone 12 Pro Max Camera Test Comparison.
Mrwhosetheboss
14m 2s
Camera App Interface & Features Comparison
- Samsung camera app vs Apple's: massive feature gap
- Apple focuses on simplicity, Samsung crams features into every corner
- Samsung features: portrait mode video, super steady recording, pro video mode, multiple camera shooting simultaneously, 8K video, single take feature (tap once for all photo/video types)
- iPhone features: portrait mode, slo-mo (but Samsung has same)
- Samsung gets higher starting point due to feature abundance
Zoom Performance
- Samsung significantly superior zoom functionality vs iPhone
- Samsung zoom levels: 1x ultrawide, 3x, 10x, up to 100x available
- iPhone zoom: adequate but not competitive
- Apple doesn't prioritize zoom, only mentions zoom cameras for portrait shots
- Samsung specializes in zoom but lacks seamless lens transitions (has lag unlike iPhone's smooth transitions for years)
Macro Photography
- Samsung S21 Ultra: ultrawide camera doubles as close-up macro camera, automatically switches when approaching subject
- iPhone 12 Pro Max: no macro capability, significant disparity
- Results show "before and after" level difference
- Macro not critical for main camera importance, but demonstrates potential when seeing what's possible
Portrait Mode
- iPhone wins portrait mode significantly
- Samsung portraits look fake, iPhone portraits could convince someone they're from $1,500 DSLR
- Samsung's portrait issue: since S20 Ultra, high magnification zoom cameras disabled for portraits
- S21 Ultra has 10x and 3x optical zoom but can't use for portraits
- iPhone uses dedicated 2.5x zoom lens, Samsung uses main camera with 2x digital zoom (worse quality)
- 2019 Galaxy S10 ($400) takes better portraits than 2021 S21 Ultra due to using zoom cameras
- Front camera portraits: roughly equal between phones
Selfie Performance
- Front camera quality similar between phones
- Choice between iPhone's flatter look vs Samsung's contrastier style
- Both record 4K front video
- iPhone technically slightly better (less detail loss in dark areas, smoother stabilization)
- Samsung punchier visually - 3 of 4 people preferred Samsung footage
- Audio quality excellent on both, shouldn't influence decision
Night Mode Photography
- iPhone 12 Pro Max wins night mode (bigger category weight)
- Apple jumped from middle-tier to top tier in night mode
- Samsung S21 Ultra hasn't topped iPhone despite improvements
- Samsung photos have grunginess/grittiness, iPhone wins fundamentals (texture, detail)
- Samsung overly aggressive noise reduction, results in softer images
- Samsung advantages: better nighttime zoom shots, crispy nighttime ultrawide despite low light, greater brightening ability
- iPhone better at embracing night, making night look good vs artificial daylight effect
- iPhone nighttime portraits better, more realistic color tones
- iPhone zooms better due to resistance to blurring/softening
Video Performance
- iPhone wins entire video category
- Low light video: Samsung initially impressive but iPhone significantly better
- Disparity not due to cameras themselves - Apple's custom components enable streamlined processing algorithms
- S21 Ultra new phone with new image sensor, unusually grainy, expected to improve
- Samsung stabilization advantage: slightly ahead at 4K pacing downward
- Super steady mode: extreme stabilization but severe dynamic range limits, caps at 1080p (inadequate for 4K/8K age)
Slow Motion
- Normal slo-mo: iPhone ahead (brighter, better defined)
- Samsung option for much slower speeds than iPhone
- Overall: roughly equal, called a draw
Photo Quality (Main Category)
- Samsung wins most important category
- Galaxy S20 Ultra already took better photos than iPhone
- S21 improvements: better sensor, faster shutter time, more advanced image signal processor
- Samsung advantages:
- Natural background blur due to large sensor
- More detailed (108 megapixel mode when enabled)
- Better dynamic range in photos only
- Punchier photos (extra sharpness, color, contrast)
- iPhone photos risk looking flat but more consistent
- Samsung scene optimizer occasionally produces oversaturated results
- Overall mostly good performance from Samsung
Final Verdict
- Samsung: 5 category wins, Apple: 3 category wins
- Categories have different weights and victory margins
- Phones feel like "yin and yang" - each phone's weakness is other's strength
- Samsung wins overall: more enjoyable and versatile camera
- Samsung range: 5-mile zooms to 2cm close-ups, generally brilliant photos
- Recommendation: wait for major video update if not urgent purchase
- Current video quality concern but overall Samsung preferred
