AI summary by TwinMind

Samsung S10 Plus vs iPhone XS Max / Mate 20 Pro EXTREME Camera Test

Mrwhosetheboss

13m 25s

Video Background & Setup

  • Follow-up to previous S10 Plus vs iPhone XS Max vs Mate 20 Pro camera comparison
  • Original video processing screwed up by YouTube after 2 sleepless nights of work
  • Enhanced testing with speedboat and helicopter footage
  • Giveaway: 5 S10 phones with Everything Apple Pro (rules in description)

Front Camera Testing

  • Speedboat test scenario: All 3 phones handled stabilization well despite fast movement
  • S10 Plus advantages:
    • Wide-angle front camera (noticeable amount more in frame)
    • 4K front camera recording (massive leap above 1080p on other phones)
    • Dual front cameras with different focal lengths
    • Slightly wider angle selfie capability
  • iPhone XS Max: More balanced colors and stabilization
  • All phones: Good job handling harsh background lighting

Front Camera Portrait Mode

  • S10 Plus:
    • Rich colors like iPhone but crisper image
    • Brighter skin tones, more visually pleasing to many
    • Live Focus (portrait mode) works well with dual cameras
    • Edge detection could be better (messed up jacket slightly)
    • New background manipulation features in selfies
  • iPhone XS Max: Pretty well done considering single camera, more realistic color portrayal
  • Mate 20 Pro: Consistently overexposes, too much beautification causing detail loss

Video Recording Capabilities

  • Slow Motion: All 3 shoot continuous 240fps, S10 & iPhone do 1080p vs 720p on Huawei
  • Super Slow-Mo: S10 & Mate 20 Pro have 960fps, iPhone lacks this
  • 4K 60fps: S10 & iPhone support this, Huawei limited to 4K 30fps
  • iPhone: Cleanest looking slow motion
  • Color processing: Completely different between phones even in same scene

Video Stabilization

  • Huawei Mate 20 Pro:
    • AI stabilization looks tripod-like when standing still
    • Loses polish when moving, especially at 4K
    • Generally good dynamic range but overexposed above buildings
    • Compensates with excessive saturation
  • S10 Plus Super Steady:
    • Uses ultra-wide camera for computational video
    • Marked improvement over Note 9
    • Some drifting compared to iPhone's constant stability
  • iPhone XS Max: Most consistent stabilization

Ultra-Wide Video Quality

  • Both S10 Plus & Mate 20 Pro have ultra-wide lenses for video
  • Quality noticeably degraded, more noticeable in video than photos
  • Grain visible especially on Mate 20 Pro even without zooming

Autofocus Performance

  • iPhone & Mate 20 Pro: Smooth transition between foreground/background
  • S10 Plus: Jerky autofocus, takes time to figure out focus target
  • Problem intensified in indoor/low-light environments
  • Doesn't pick up close objects well, temperamental, often reverts to background focus

Photo Quality & Hardware

  • S10 Plus: Similar hardware to Note 9, main improvements from software
  • AI Scene Detection: Beefed up, colors vibrant and appropriately sharpened
  • iPhone: Best most consistent high dynamic range, controls bright areas best
  • Mate 20 Pro: Fast shutter, slightly warm colors, texture disappears in bright areas

Portrait Mode Photos

  • iPhone: Most consistent shots, natural skin/body exposure, good subject distinction (2m vs 40m subjects)
  • Huawei: Can produce cinematic shots but inconsistent, applies massive blur filter to everything
  • All phones: Will make most people happy

Zoom Capabilities

  • Mate 20 Pro: 3x optical zoom still unbeaten
  • S10 Plus & iPhone: 2x optical zoom (standard)
  • 10x zoom test: Huawei more comfortable, S10 not far behind due to higher contrast color palette

Ultra-Wide Photo Quality

  • Both S10 Plus & Mate 20 Pro: Have ultra-wide lenses
  • Quality not as good as primary lens but disparity not noticeable with plenty of light
  • Samsung: Wider ultra-wide (0.5x magnification vs 0.6x on Mate 20 Pro)

Night Mode & Low Light

  • S10 Plus Bright Night Mode:
    • Tied to scene detection algorithm (not manual activation)
    • Must wait for phone to decide it's dark enough
    • Can't use in medium lighting conditions
    • Variable aperture opens up in low-light for more light
    • Standard non-night mode photos actually really good in dark
    • Realistic color representation
  • Mate 20 Pro: Can take night mode shots at will, helps control bright areas
  • iPhone: Controls white areas best, stops overexposure, images risk being soft
  • Detail capture: S10 Plus normal photo captures as much detail as Mate 20 Pro night mode
  • Noise: S10 Plus less smooth due to weaker noise reduction but less grainy than iPhone

Night Mode Performance

  • Samsung Bright Night Mode: Hold steady for few seconds, AI stabilization, very bright results but low sharpness
  • Stabilization: Not as good as Huawei's
  • Potential: Early days, might get update soon

Flash Quality

  • iPhone XS Max: Better color readjustment for flash, more true to life and aesthetically pleasing
  • S10 Plus & Mate 20 Pro: Greenish looking images with flash
  • All phones: Pretty good flash modules overall

Night Video Recording

  • Toughest smartphone camera challenge
  • S10 Plus: No new next-generation technologies but keeps up with others
  • Performance: At least as good as iPhone XS Max and Mate 20 Pro
  • Ultra-wide: Don't use at night, quality sucks

Overall Assessment

  • iPhone: Best for consistent results, dynamic range, stabilization
  • S10 Plus: Best front camera, good software improvements, variable aperture advantage
  • Mate 20 Pro: Best zoom, good AI stabilization when still, night mode flexibility

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome