AI summary by TwinMind
Samsung S10 Plus vs iPhone XS Max / Mate 20 Pro EXTREME Camera Test
Mrwhosetheboss
13m 25s
Video Background & Setup
- Follow-up to previous S10 Plus vs iPhone XS Max vs Mate 20 Pro camera comparison
- Original video processing screwed up by YouTube after 2 sleepless nights of work
- Enhanced testing with speedboat and helicopter footage
- Giveaway: 5 S10 phones with Everything Apple Pro (rules in description)
Front Camera Testing
- Speedboat test scenario: All 3 phones handled stabilization well despite fast movement
- S10 Plus advantages:
- Wide-angle front camera (noticeable amount more in frame)
- 4K front camera recording (massive leap above 1080p on other phones)
- Dual front cameras with different focal lengths
- Slightly wider angle selfie capability
- iPhone XS Max: More balanced colors and stabilization
- All phones: Good job handling harsh background lighting
Front Camera Portrait Mode
- S10 Plus:
- Rich colors like iPhone but crisper image
- Brighter skin tones, more visually pleasing to many
- Live Focus (portrait mode) works well with dual cameras
- Edge detection could be better (messed up jacket slightly)
- New background manipulation features in selfies
- iPhone XS Max: Pretty well done considering single camera, more realistic color portrayal
- Mate 20 Pro: Consistently overexposes, too much beautification causing detail loss
Video Recording Capabilities
- Slow Motion: All 3 shoot continuous 240fps, S10 & iPhone do 1080p vs 720p on Huawei
- Super Slow-Mo: S10 & Mate 20 Pro have 960fps, iPhone lacks this
- 4K 60fps: S10 & iPhone support this, Huawei limited to 4K 30fps
- iPhone: Cleanest looking slow motion
- Color processing: Completely different between phones even in same scene
Video Stabilization
- Huawei Mate 20 Pro:
- AI stabilization looks tripod-like when standing still
- Loses polish when moving, especially at 4K
- Generally good dynamic range but overexposed above buildings
- Compensates with excessive saturation
- S10 Plus Super Steady:
- Uses ultra-wide camera for computational video
- Marked improvement over Note 9
- Some drifting compared to iPhone's constant stability
- iPhone XS Max: Most consistent stabilization
Ultra-Wide Video Quality
- Both S10 Plus & Mate 20 Pro have ultra-wide lenses for video
- Quality noticeably degraded, more noticeable in video than photos
- Grain visible especially on Mate 20 Pro even without zooming
Autofocus Performance
- iPhone & Mate 20 Pro: Smooth transition between foreground/background
- S10 Plus: Jerky autofocus, takes time to figure out focus target
- Problem intensified in indoor/low-light environments
- Doesn't pick up close objects well, temperamental, often reverts to background focus
Photo Quality & Hardware
- S10 Plus: Similar hardware to Note 9, main improvements from software
- AI Scene Detection: Beefed up, colors vibrant and appropriately sharpened
- iPhone: Best most consistent high dynamic range, controls bright areas best
- Mate 20 Pro: Fast shutter, slightly warm colors, texture disappears in bright areas
Portrait Mode Photos
- iPhone: Most consistent shots, natural skin/body exposure, good subject distinction (2m vs 40m subjects)
- Huawei: Can produce cinematic shots but inconsistent, applies massive blur filter to everything
- All phones: Will make most people happy
Zoom Capabilities
- Mate 20 Pro: 3x optical zoom still unbeaten
- S10 Plus & iPhone: 2x optical zoom (standard)
- 10x zoom test: Huawei more comfortable, S10 not far behind due to higher contrast color palette
Ultra-Wide Photo Quality
- Both S10 Plus & Mate 20 Pro: Have ultra-wide lenses
- Quality not as good as primary lens but disparity not noticeable with plenty of light
- Samsung: Wider ultra-wide (0.5x magnification vs 0.6x on Mate 20 Pro)
Night Mode & Low Light
- S10 Plus Bright Night Mode:
- Tied to scene detection algorithm (not manual activation)
- Must wait for phone to decide it's dark enough
- Can't use in medium lighting conditions
- Variable aperture opens up in low-light for more light
- Standard non-night mode photos actually really good in dark
- Realistic color representation
- Mate 20 Pro: Can take night mode shots at will, helps control bright areas
- iPhone: Controls white areas best, stops overexposure, images risk being soft
- Detail capture: S10 Plus normal photo captures as much detail as Mate 20 Pro night mode
- Noise: S10 Plus less smooth due to weaker noise reduction but less grainy than iPhone
Night Mode Performance
- Samsung Bright Night Mode: Hold steady for few seconds, AI stabilization, very bright results but low sharpness
- Stabilization: Not as good as Huawei's
- Potential: Early days, might get update soon
Flash Quality
- iPhone XS Max: Better color readjustment for flash, more true to life and aesthetically pleasing
- S10 Plus & Mate 20 Pro: Greenish looking images with flash
- All phones: Pretty good flash modules overall
Night Video Recording
- Toughest smartphone camera challenge
- S10 Plus: No new next-generation technologies but keeps up with others
- Performance: At least as good as iPhone XS Max and Mate 20 Pro
- Ultra-wide: Don't use at night, quality sucks
Overall Assessment
- iPhone: Best for consistent results, dynamic range, stabilization
- S10 Plus: Best front camera, good software improvements, variable aperture advantage
- Mate 20 Pro: Best zoom, good AI stabilization when still, night mode flexibility
