AI summary by TwinMind
Samsung S24 Ultra Review - Goodbye iPhone?
Mrwhosetheboss
25m 7s
Design and Build Quality
- Controversial launch with mixed reactions to AI features, camera changes, 7-year software support, thermal issues
- Frame swapped from aluminum to titanium with new 4x stronger glass
- Still susceptible to damage despite claims - small scuffs expose thin matte layer becoming glossy
- Screen shows wear and tear like other phones, not miracle durability solution
- No pre-installed screen protector anymore
- Design aesthetically pleasing with great texture, even screen borders, flat screen works well with curved body
- Biggest upgrade: massive reduction in screen glare, almost completely kills reflections
- Best phone screen experience - retains color accuracy/brightness regardless of lighting conditions
Software Experience and One UI
- Major improvements from previous Samsung issues that drove reviewer to iPhone 3.5 years ago
- Voice notes now crystal clear (previously muffled)
- Fluidity significantly improved, feels smoother than iPhone 15 Pro Max in many ways
- Scrolling acceleration creates gliding feel, consistent smooth animations
- First Samsung phone that's gorgeous out of box
- Quick panel well-organized with rounded corners, precise spacing
- Lock screen customization: widgets, style changes, scalable clock, flexible but structured
- New dark mode: dark gray instead of black, less straining, more pleasant
- Video call effects: background blur, colored/image backgrounds, face smoothing, works across all apps
- Excellent haptics, typing feels better than any phone
- Good Lock Suite for deep customization (titanium animated volume rocker example)
- 7 years of OS updates (industry standard was 2-3 years) - insane promise, helps resale value
Software Issues
- Instagram/Snapchat stories still look subpar (videos not photos) - 50% processing/stabilization lost
- Workaround: record in native camera app at 1080p vs 4K to avoid compression
- Face scanner slow and problematic:
- Alternate appearance option for glasses
- Screen brightening at night (undesirable)
- Fine in middle lighting but slow overall
- Needs infrared 3D scanning like iPhone
- Audio quality slightly worse than iPhone - less loud and full
- No MagSafe - major downgrade for wireless charging while propped up
- Software aggressively pushes Samsung services (Samsung Pass example)
- Multiple setup steps frustrating for simple tasks
- Signal issues: 2-3 bars outside, 0-1 bars inside, poor hotspot performance during storm
Camera Performance
- Pretty big improvement over S23 Ultra but not in expected ways
- No significant detail/low-light/zoom improvements - disappointing for Ultra phone
- Purpose of Ultra should be breaking new ground, showcasing cutting-edge tech
- Doesn't create excitement or new toy feeling
- Building on already strong foundation
- Camera app improvements: better looking, organized, smoother animations, faster capture
- Extremely bright screen eliminates shooting visibility problems
- Wished for new 400MP main sensor but other improvements compensate
- Editor highlights powerful technology:
- Portrait mode on photos of photos
- Instant effects more useful than generative editor
- Generative image editor: cool party trick but rarely needed, feels inauthentic
- Bordering on digital art vs rewarding photography
- Still requires effort: multiple steps, 10-second processing, not suitable for 30+ photos
Galaxy AI Features - Positive
- Translation features genuinely impressive:
- Instant translation in messaging apps
- Preloaded for specific chats, works across SMS/WhatsApp/Instagram
- Enables better communication with non-English speakers
- Family member thought phone was hacked due to sudden Italian fluency
- Translation limitations:
- Not instant, Samsung quality inferior to Google
- Struggles with abbreviations (BTW), question detection without punctuation
- Dialect problems, literal translation issues
- AI summarization surprisingly useful:
- Switched to Samsung browser for summaries
- Forum discussion summaries, note organization
- Grammar checker makes notes feel more composed
- Automatic formatting (holiday destinations by continent)
- AI-generated note covers create distinct novel feeling
- Reads handwritten text for titles
S Pen Functionality
- Forgotten 99% of time, wished for bigger battery instead
- Critical 1% usage makes it invaluable
- Free-form writing vs typing for ideation
- Replaced remarkable tablet functionality
- Write when phone locked without distractions
- Complaint: should be on right side for right-handed users
- Current left placement due to camera space limitations
Circle to Search
- Hold bottom screen, enter search mode
- Zoom, move around, circle objects for Google identification
- Forgot feature existed first 5 days - requires conscious behavior shift
- When clicked, became incredible tool:
- Product identification, phone recognition, flower identification, hotel location
- Continuously surprised by accuracy
- Based on old Google "Now on Tap" but much improved
- Seamless integration, doesn't exit current app
- Fluid interaction: circle, scribble, tap recognition
- Intelligent results make it game-changing
- Example: kitchen snack identification and Amazon ordering in 5 seconds
- Opens floodgates to searchable content
- Makes phone feel like interactive world interface
- iPhone feels old school without it
Additional AI Features
- Instant slow-mo: great idea, good execution, needs polish
- Occasional video lag or artifacts when creating in-between frames
- Live call translation significantly worse than text translation
- Real-time processing challenges
- Example conversation shows translation errors and delays
- Glad Samsung made it but needs improvement
AI Caveats and Concerns
- Much Samsung AI based on Google tech - exclusivity temporary
- Many features coming to older phones, not clearly communicated
- Hidden subscription model: online AI features free only until end of 2025
- Misleading pricing - expensive phone should include advertised features
- 24-month contract users will hit subscription period
- Additional monthly fees on top of data costs and phone price
- Should either run without servers or not sell as phone feature
Performance and Gaming
- Fastest Samsung ever used
- PlayStation 2 emulation possible - very resource intensive task
- Simulates different hardware, upscales to HD
- Handles entire childhood PS2 library
- Top 3 smartphone performance currently
- Synthetic stress tests show thermal throttling after prolonged use
- Performance dips noticeable for gaming 1+ hours
- Normal/gaming/emulator use shows no noticeable issues
- Best battery life ever in Samsung flagship
- Battery not bigger, just more efficient
- High difference between drain states:
- Gaming: 5-8% drop in 30 minutes
- Browsing: feels like lasts forever
- Average 8-9 hours screen time per charge
- Evenings with 25-50% remaining, better than iPhone
Final Verdict
- iPhone relegated to secondary phone
- Samsung fixed longer-running issues
- Software looks and feels great
- Camera smooth operation
- Fundamentals fixed, allowing appreciation of extras
- Anti-reflective screen, materials, AI features feel next-generation
- Uncertainty about features coming to older Samsung phones
- S23 users should wait for software updates before upgrading
