AI summary by TwinMind

Samsung S24 Ultra Review - Goodbye iPhone?

Mrwhosetheboss

25m 7s

Design and Build Quality

  • Controversial launch with mixed reactions to AI features, camera changes, 7-year software support, thermal issues
  • Frame swapped from aluminum to titanium with new 4x stronger glass
  • Still susceptible to damage despite claims - small scuffs expose thin matte layer becoming glossy
  • Screen shows wear and tear like other phones, not miracle durability solution
  • No pre-installed screen protector anymore
  • Design aesthetically pleasing with great texture, even screen borders, flat screen works well with curved body
  • Biggest upgrade: massive reduction in screen glare, almost completely kills reflections
  • Best phone screen experience - retains color accuracy/brightness regardless of lighting conditions

Software Experience and One UI

  • Major improvements from previous Samsung issues that drove reviewer to iPhone 3.5 years ago
  • Voice notes now crystal clear (previously muffled)
  • Fluidity significantly improved, feels smoother than iPhone 15 Pro Max in many ways
  • Scrolling acceleration creates gliding feel, consistent smooth animations
  • First Samsung phone that's gorgeous out of box
  • Quick panel well-organized with rounded corners, precise spacing
  • Lock screen customization: widgets, style changes, scalable clock, flexible but structured
  • New dark mode: dark gray instead of black, less straining, more pleasant
  • Video call effects: background blur, colored/image backgrounds, face smoothing, works across all apps
  • Excellent haptics, typing feels better than any phone
  • Good Lock Suite for deep customization (titanium animated volume rocker example)
  • 7 years of OS updates (industry standard was 2-3 years) - insane promise, helps resale value

Software Issues

  • Instagram/Snapchat stories still look subpar (videos not photos) - 50% processing/stabilization lost
  • Workaround: record in native camera app at 1080p vs 4K to avoid compression
  • Face scanner slow and problematic:
    • Alternate appearance option for glasses
    • Screen brightening at night (undesirable)
    • Fine in middle lighting but slow overall
    • Needs infrared 3D scanning like iPhone
  • Audio quality slightly worse than iPhone - less loud and full
  • No MagSafe - major downgrade for wireless charging while propped up
  • Software aggressively pushes Samsung services (Samsung Pass example)
  • Multiple setup steps frustrating for simple tasks
  • Signal issues: 2-3 bars outside, 0-1 bars inside, poor hotspot performance during storm

Camera Performance

  • Pretty big improvement over S23 Ultra but not in expected ways
  • No significant detail/low-light/zoom improvements - disappointing for Ultra phone
  • Purpose of Ultra should be breaking new ground, showcasing cutting-edge tech
  • Doesn't create excitement or new toy feeling
  • Building on already strong foundation
  • Camera app improvements: better looking, organized, smoother animations, faster capture
  • Extremely bright screen eliminates shooting visibility problems
  • Wished for new 400MP main sensor but other improvements compensate
  • Editor highlights powerful technology:
    • Portrait mode on photos of photos
    • Instant effects more useful than generative editor
  • Generative image editor: cool party trick but rarely needed, feels inauthentic
  • Bordering on digital art vs rewarding photography
  • Still requires effort: multiple steps, 10-second processing, not suitable for 30+ photos

Galaxy AI Features - Positive

  • Translation features genuinely impressive:
    • Instant translation in messaging apps
    • Preloaded for specific chats, works across SMS/WhatsApp/Instagram
    • Enables better communication with non-English speakers
    • Family member thought phone was hacked due to sudden Italian fluency
  • Translation limitations:
    • Not instant, Samsung quality inferior to Google
    • Struggles with abbreviations (BTW), question detection without punctuation
    • Dialect problems, literal translation issues
  • AI summarization surprisingly useful:
    • Switched to Samsung browser for summaries
    • Forum discussion summaries, note organization
    • Grammar checker makes notes feel more composed
    • Automatic formatting (holiday destinations by continent)
    • AI-generated note covers create distinct novel feeling
    • Reads handwritten text for titles

S Pen Functionality

  • Forgotten 99% of time, wished for bigger battery instead
  • Critical 1% usage makes it invaluable
  • Free-form writing vs typing for ideation
  • Replaced remarkable tablet functionality
  • Write when phone locked without distractions
  • Complaint: should be on right side for right-handed users
  • Current left placement due to camera space limitations

Circle to Search

  • Hold bottom screen, enter search mode
  • Zoom, move around, circle objects for Google identification
  • Forgot feature existed first 5 days - requires conscious behavior shift
  • When clicked, became incredible tool:
    • Product identification, phone recognition, flower identification, hotel location
    • Continuously surprised by accuracy
  • Based on old Google "Now on Tap" but much improved
  • Seamless integration, doesn't exit current app
  • Fluid interaction: circle, scribble, tap recognition
  • Intelligent results make it game-changing
  • Example: kitchen snack identification and Amazon ordering in 5 seconds
  • Opens floodgates to searchable content
  • Makes phone feel like interactive world interface
  • iPhone feels old school without it

Additional AI Features

  • Instant slow-mo: great idea, good execution, needs polish
  • Occasional video lag or artifacts when creating in-between frames
  • Live call translation significantly worse than text translation
  • Real-time processing challenges
  • Example conversation shows translation errors and delays
  • Glad Samsung made it but needs improvement

AI Caveats and Concerns

  • Much Samsung AI based on Google tech - exclusivity temporary
  • Many features coming to older phones, not clearly communicated
  • Hidden subscription model: online AI features free only until end of 2025
  • Misleading pricing - expensive phone should include advertised features
  • 24-month contract users will hit subscription period
  • Additional monthly fees on top of data costs and phone price
  • Should either run without servers or not sell as phone feature

Performance and Gaming

  • Fastest Samsung ever used
  • PlayStation 2 emulation possible - very resource intensive task
  • Simulates different hardware, upscales to HD
  • Handles entire childhood PS2 library
  • Top 3 smartphone performance currently
  • Synthetic stress tests show thermal throttling after prolonged use
  • Performance dips noticeable for gaming 1+ hours
  • Normal/gaming/emulator use shows no noticeable issues
  • Best battery life ever in Samsung flagship
  • Battery not bigger, just more efficient
  • High difference between drain states:
    • Gaming: 5-8% drop in 30 minutes
    • Browsing: feels like lasts forever
  • Average 8-9 hours screen time per charge
  • Evenings with 25-50% remaining, better than iPhone

Final Verdict

  • iPhone relegated to secondary phone
  • Samsung fixed longer-running issues
  • Software looks and feels great
  • Camera smooth operation
  • Fundamentals fixed, allowing appreciation of extras
  • Anti-reflective screen, materials, AI features feel next-generation
  • Uncertainty about features coming to older Samsung phones
  • S23 users should wait for software updates before upgrading

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome