AI summary by TwinMind

Science is in trouble and it worries me.

Sabine Hossenfelder

24m 32s

Scientific Growth Metrics vs. Productivity Decline

  • Number of scientists worldwide increased rapidly, continuing to grow
    • Both absolute numbers and share of population rising
    • Past 30 years: steep increases in EU, North America, parts of Asia
    • Scientists per 1 million people data shows dramatic growth
  • Scientific publications increasing exponentially across fields
    • Physics literature doubles every ~18 years
    • Electrical engineering literature doubles every ~9 years
  • Despite growth, fewer results from increased effort

Economic Impact Analysis

  • Total Factor Productivity measures inputs (labor, capital, technology/R&D) vs outputs (goods/services)
  • 2016 economists paper "Are Ideas Getting Harder to Find?"
    • US factor productivity growth remained constant despite steep researcher increase
    • More effort in research (money + people) barely maintains stable growth
  • Specific sector analysis shows declining returns:
    • Agricultural yields: researcher numbers up, results flat
    • New FDA drug approvals declining vs researcher numbers

Patent and Innovation Studies

  • US patent novelty analysis: quantified by new connections between technology sectors
    • Patent novelty declining since 1960s
  • Invention narrowness has increased
  • 2022 study: research productivity by top researchers per community
    • Steep decrease since 1960s
  • 2023 Nature study: 45 million papers analyzed worldwide
    • Disruptiveness measured by papers made redundant
    • Disruptive ideas noticeably decreased across physical sciences, chemistry, computer science, biomedicine
    • Even top journals (Nature, Science) showing decline

Historical Context and Trends

  • Jonathan Hubner 2005: innovation rate declining since industrialization
    • Rate = technological events ÷ number of people
    • Extrapolation suggests no progress or infinite population by century end
  • Multiple studies using different metrics consistently show same pattern
  • Technologies like AI, quantum computing, fusion, autonomous vehicles based on decades-old breakthroughs
    • Slow pace + enormous investments illustrate rather than contradict the problem

Potential Causes Analysis

  • R&D Funding: Not the cause
    • R&D as share of GDP roughly constant past decades
    • Absolute terms increased, federal contribution decreased
    • Not exclusively American phenomenon
  • Scaling Issues: Hiring more researchers has worked to some extent
    • Largely compensated for decreased productivity per researcher
    • Companies wouldn't invest if no returns
    • Doesn't explain qualitative change in knowledge discovery
  • Low-Hanging Fruit Theory: Implausible as primary cause
    • Effect happened simultaneously across disciplines, countries, sectors
    • Agriculture, drug development, chemistry, biomedicine, physics
    • Systemic problem starting 1960s-70s globally

Academic Research Organization Issues

  • Most R&D privately funded (US + EU)
  • Most basic research (long-term breakthrough potential) happens in publicly funded academia
  • World War II/Apollo missions had shared purpose + enormous pressure
  • Academia has growing fraud/misconduct problem but not major factor yet

Bureaucracy Problems

  • Elon Musk examples: SpaceX shark/whale impact studies, underwater explosion whale hearing damage analysis
  • Peter Thiel: Large bureaucratic institutions from moon program slowed innovation
  • Patrick Collison Fast Grants during COVID
    • No scientific grantmaking designed for decisions in hours/days
    • NIH proposals: specific font requirements, narrow criteria, months to prepare
    • Fast grants: most researchers complete form within 1 hour
  • Academic bureaucracy: grant applications → accounting → reports → reports on reports

Publish or Perish Culture

  • Problem of valuing quantity over quality
  • Rewarding by paper numbers, journal prestige, citations
  • Known for decades but persists
  • Not in anyone's interest to fund useless research

Risk Aversion in Academic Research

  • High competition for funding/jobs creates incentives for reliable results
  • Encourages low-risk mainstream research vs novel/disruptive ideas
  • Funding agencies explicitly want "transformative" or "high-risk high-payoff" research
  • Yet consistently fund "same old boring stuff"

Public Perception and Trust Impact

  • Scientists declare much research "boring" to excuse lack of tangible benefits
  • Author calls it "bullshit research": underpowered trials, irreproducible psychology studies, crappy meta-analyses
  • Examples: airport noise affects sleep, better photovoltaics claims, unmeasured particles
  • Most bullshit research invisible to average person
  • Fox News examples of questionable federal spending on research
  • People will question why taxes fund academic jobs with no societal benefit

Researcher Satisfaction Data

  • Fast Grants survey: 78% of biomedical researchers would change research agenda significantly if given flexibility
  • Author's unpublished 20-year-old physics survey: majority would change topics if possible
  • Substantial number of scientists feel forced to work on research they don't consider worthwhile
  • Researchers know they're doing bullshit research

Existential Concerns

  • Scientific progress feeds technological progress needed for species protection
  • Future threats: super volcano eruptions, asteroid impacts, solar mega flares
  • Could kill billions without technological protection
  • Technological progress stalling due to academic problems
  • First step: acknowledging the problem exists

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome