AI summary by TwinMind
Selects: Child Labor: Not Funny | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
52m 42s
Introduction and Episode Context
- Josh introduces August 2021 episode on child labor as weekly select
- Episode contains rare mention of newsies strike that they actually covered later
- Bleak topic showing how far US has progressed
- 2021 designated as international year for elimination of child labor
- Dave Ruse helped research/write episode
Personal Work Experiences vs. Child Labor
- Josh started working at 13 at JJ's Barbecue for $3.35/hour minimum wage
- Chuck worked as paper boy at 9-10 years old, made less than $50/week
- Distinction made: their experiences were "kid having a job" not child labor
- Real child labor: dangerous conditions, little/no pay, no play time, no socialization with peers
- Child laborers would prefer not working at all rather than better jobs
Colonial America and Early Work Ethics
- Protestant work ethic: "idle hands are devil's workshop"
- Children expected to work from age 13 - either full-time jobs or unpaid apprenticeships
- Boys worked farms, girls worked in house alongside family
- Medieval England allowed play until puberty (~14), Puritans started work earlier
- Mostly family-based work for survival, not formal employment
Industrial Revolution Impact
- Cotton factories employed children as young as 4 years old
- Working 10-12 hours daily for 12-25 cents per day (not per hour)
- George Washington and Alexander Hamilton supported child factory work
- Hamilton said women/children "rendered more useful by manufacturing establishments"
- Critics like Boston mayor Josiah Quincy observed "dull dejection" in child workers
- Second industrial revolution (steam, steel, railroads) made conditions much worse
Robber Barons and Exploitation
- Unbridled capitalism exploited immigrant and child labor
- Rural farming families moved to cities
- Millions of European immigrants fleeing poverty/famine
- Robber barons got rich through innovation but also direct exploitation
- No oversight or regulation during economic growth period
Types of Child Labor Jobs
Urban/Factory Work
- Factory work in company towns
- Telegraph boys (delivering messages)
- Shoe shining
- Newspaper selling (newsies)
- Bobbin boys/girls in textile mills (replacing bobbins on machines)
- Furnace stoking
Rural/Agricultural Work
- Cotton and tobacco picking
- Stemming, deseeding, shucking crops
- Most Americans still lived on farms, so most child labor was agricultural
Mining Work (Appalachian Mountains)
- Breaker boys: breaking coal lumps into uniform pieces
- Mule handlers
- No gloves allowed for breaker boys to maintain "uniformity"
- Absorbed coal dust, cuts, calluses by age 6-8
Tenement Industries
- Basket weaving
- Making paper flowers
- Hand-rolling cigars and cigarettes
- Nicotine poisoning common from tobacco handling
- Nausea, dizziness, turning green, respiratory distress
Statistics at Peak (1900)
- 1890: 1 in 5 kids under 16 was working
- 1900 census: 1.7 million kids under 16 = 6% of total workforce
- Numbers excluded agricultural workers and home-based work
- Two-thirds of children worked in agriculture (not counted in census)
- Philadelphia 1900 education impact:
- 15% of 13-year-old boys left school to work
- Half of 15-year-old boys not in school
- Only 10% of 17-year-old boys still in school
Newsies Strike (1899)
- Boys and girls bought newspapers wholesale (50 cents per 100)
- Sold for penny each, made half-penny profit per paper
- Two-week strike reduced newspaper sales by 23%
- Brought Pulitzer and Hearst "to their knees"
- Major concession: full buybacks on unsold papers
- Mainly affected afternoon editions (morning papers were subscription-based)
Progressive Era Reform Movement
- Started 1890s with reformers like Jane Addams, Julia Lathrop, Lillian Ward
- Advocated for fair wages, maximum work hours, school-first policies
- Industry lobbied heavily against child labor restrictions
- States established some child labor commissions with minimal protections
- National Child Labor Committee formed 1904 as lobbying group
Lewis Hine Photography Campaign
- Sociologist/teacher/photographer hired by National Child Labor Committee
- Took 5,000 photographs documenting child labor conditions
- Posed as Bible salesman and industrial machinery photographer
- Wore special jacket with buttons at known measurements to estimate children's ages
- Photos showed children as "beaten down miniature adults"
- Images published in newspapers shocked national conscience
Legislative Progress
- 1906: First proposal by Senator Albert Beverage (Indiana)
- 1916: Keating Act passed but Supreme Court struck down
- Constitutional amendment passed but not ratified by states
- Great Depression changed social conditions
- Mass adult unemployment made child labor politically unacceptable
Fair Labor Standards Act (1938)
- Set first national minimum wage: 25 cents/hour
- Maximum work hours established
- Overtime pay (time and a half after 40 hours, up to 44 hours max)
- Child labor restrictions:
- Under 16: cannot work manufacturing or coal mining
- Under 14: cannot work non-agricultural jobs (exceptions: child actors, newsies, home-based evergreen wreath making)
- Minimum wage progression:
- 1939: 30 cents
- 1945: 40 cents
- 1956: $1.00
- 2008: cracked $6.00
- Current: $7.25 federal minimum
Current US Child Labor Laws
Non-Agricultural Protections
- Under 18: no hazardous work (blasting, mining, forest firefighting)
- Under 16: maximum 3 hours/day during school year
- Specific exemption: home-based mostly evergreen wreath making
Agricultural Exemptions (Shamefully Limited Protection)
- 16+ on family farms: unlimited hours, hazardous work allowed
- 14+: unlimited hours outside school
- 12+: can work with parental consent
- Up to 72 hours during school year
- Results: 55% graduation rate, 100,000 injuries annually
Global Child Labor Today
- 158 million children victims worldwide (down 30% from 20 years ago)
- 71% work in agriculture, fishing, herding
- Coal mining in spaces too narrow/dangerous for adults
- Wildcat gold mining with mercury exposure
- Tobacco farms: nicotine poisoning plus toxic pesticides
- Conditions resemble US Gilded Age
Solutions (ILO Recommendations)
- Expand Education Access
- Remove school fees
- Get kids in school reduces workforce participation
- Cooperative for Education (Co-ED) removes barriers
- Help Families Meet Basic Needs
- Universal basic income or monthly stipends
- Microloans through Kiva for capital growth
- Eliminate need to send children to work
- Improve Adult Wages and Rights
- Better adult pay reduces child labor necessity
- Western companies paying fair wages can eliminate child labor from supply chains
- Enforcement
- Fund actual enforcement of existing laws
- Germany recently passed law requiring companies to examine supply chains
- Due diligence requirements for child labor identification
Episode Credits
- Research/writing by Dave Ruse
- Prompted by young listener request (lawn-mowing son)
- Listener mail from Ellie in Louisville, Kentucky about using podcast in long-term care
