AI summary by TwinMind
Selects: How Lizzie Borden Worked | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
42m 9s
Introduction and Setting
- Stuff You Should Know podcast episode on Lizzie Borden case
- Hosts: Josh Clark, Charles W Chuck Bryant, producer Jerry back from maternity leave
- Setting: Fall River, Massachusetts, August 4th, 1892
- Extremely hot day - over 100°F by noon
- Famous nursery rhyme inaccurate: no ax, not real mother, not 40/41 whacks (actually 18-19 and 11)
The Borden Family and Household
- Andrew Jackson Borden: wealthy man worth $7-12 million in today's dollars
- Lived at 92 Second Street in immigrant neighborhood (Irish Catholics, Portuguese, Chinese)
- House lacked indoor plumbing and electric lighting despite wealth
- Kept doors locked due to previous burglary (likely committed by Lizzie)
- Unusual house layout: converted two-family home with maze-like locked rooms
- No common spaces or hallways - rooms led directly into each other
- Lizzie Borden: born 1860, third child
- Sister Emma: 10 years older
- Sister Alice: died at age 2 from hydrocephaly
- Mother Sarah Morse: died 1863 from "uterine congestion" when Lizzie was 2
- Stepmother Abby Gray: married Andrew when Lizzie was 5
- Bridget Sullivan: maid (called "Maggie" by family)
Pre-Murder Tensions
- Daughters stopped calling stepmother "mother," started using "Mrs. Borden"
- Financial disputes over property gifts to Abby's sister
- Andrew gave daughters rental property for $1, they sold back for $2,400
- June 1892: Andrew killed Lizzie's pet pigeons for pigeon pie
- Uncle John Morse visited night before murders for business discussion
- Whole family sick from eating 5-day-old mutton in heat
- Abby told doctor she suspected poisoning by business rivals
- Days before murder: Lizzie attempted to buy prussic acid (cyanide) for "cleaning"
- Lizzie told friend Alice she felt "something hanging over me" day before murders
The Murders - August 4th, 1892
- 10:45 AM: Andrew Borden returns home, locked out, let in by Bridget
- Andrew lies down on couch for nap
- Mrs. Borden killed around 9:30 AM with 18-19 hatchet blows (13 crushed skull)
- Andrew killed around 10:45 AM with 11 hatchet blows, face "cut clean away"
- 11:10 AM: Lizzie calls Bridget saying "Something's happened to father"
- Bodies discovered: Andrew still bleeding, Mrs. Borden upstairs
- Only Lizzie in house during both murders
- Bridget outside during stepmother's murder
- Emma 15 miles away
- Uncle John at post office
- Andrew in town on business
Lizzie's Alibi and Suspicious Behavior
- Claims she was in barn loft eating pears, getting lead for fishing sinkers
- Stayed in 100°F barn loft for 15-20 minutes
- Police found no footprints in barn despite her claimed presence
- Story changed multiple times during questioning
- Burned dress 3 days after murders (claimed paint stains)
- Friend Alice Russell witnessed dress burning, testified against Lizzie
Evidence and Investigation
- Police investigation botched: most force at annual picnic
- Crime scene contaminated by neighbors and onlookers
- Found 2 axes, 2 hatchets, 1 hatchet head with broken handle in basement
- Hatchet head appeared "planted" and covered with dust/ash
- Never found murder weapon handle
- No conclusive blood evidence on suspected weapon
- Bodies autopsied in dining room, then decapitated
- Heads sent to Harvard, eventually buried at foot of graves
Trial and Legal Proceedings
- Multiple hearings and inquests before formal indictment
- Indicted on 3 counts of murder (stepmother, father, both together)
- Two-week trial, "trial of the century"
- Key evidence ruled inadmissible:
- Prussic acid purchase (too inflammatory)
- Lizzie's testimony (given under morphine influence)
- Prosecution case entirely circumstantial with major holes
- Defense argued 5'1" woman couldn't commit such brutal murders
- Lizzie never testified, fainted when skulls presented
- Jury deliberated 90 minutes, verdict: not guilty
Theories About the Murders
- Fugue state theory (dismissed due to 90-minute timeframe and concealment)
- Lesbian affair with maid theory (caught by stepmother)
- Sexual/physical abuse by father theory (no evidence)
- Maid's deathbed confession to sister (unverified)
- William Borden (illegitimate son/butcher) theory
- Emma committed murders with perfect alibi
- Uncle John as perpetrator
Post-Trial Life and Death
- Townspeople believed she was guilty despite acquittal
- Endured harassment: whispers, rock throwing, rotten eggs
- Bought mansion in upscale area, named it "Maplecroft"
- Lived with sister Emma until 1905
- Changed name to Elizabeth Borden
- Sisters never spoke for final 22 years until death
- Possible relationship with actress Nance O'Neal caused sister rift
- Died at 66, Emma died 9 days later
- All family members buried together in family plot
- House now operates as bed & breakfast and museum
