AI summary by TwinMind

Selects: How Lizzie Borden Worked | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

42m 9s

Introduction and Setting

  • Stuff You Should Know podcast episode on Lizzie Borden case
  • Hosts: Josh Clark, Charles W Chuck Bryant, producer Jerry back from maternity leave
  • Setting: Fall River, Massachusetts, August 4th, 1892
  • Extremely hot day - over 100°F by noon
  • Famous nursery rhyme inaccurate: no ax, not real mother, not 40/41 whacks (actually 18-19 and 11)

The Borden Family and Household

  • Andrew Jackson Borden: wealthy man worth $7-12 million in today's dollars
  • Lived at 92 Second Street in immigrant neighborhood (Irish Catholics, Portuguese, Chinese)
  • House lacked indoor plumbing and electric lighting despite wealth
  • Kept doors locked due to previous burglary (likely committed by Lizzie)
  • Unusual house layout: converted two-family home with maze-like locked rooms
  • No common spaces or hallways - rooms led directly into each other
  • Lizzie Borden: born 1860, third child
  • Sister Emma: 10 years older
  • Sister Alice: died at age 2 from hydrocephaly
  • Mother Sarah Morse: died 1863 from "uterine congestion" when Lizzie was 2
  • Stepmother Abby Gray: married Andrew when Lizzie was 5
  • Bridget Sullivan: maid (called "Maggie" by family)

Pre-Murder Tensions

  • Daughters stopped calling stepmother "mother," started using "Mrs. Borden"
  • Financial disputes over property gifts to Abby's sister
  • Andrew gave daughters rental property for $1, they sold back for $2,400
  • June 1892: Andrew killed Lizzie's pet pigeons for pigeon pie
  • Uncle John Morse visited night before murders for business discussion
  • Whole family sick from eating 5-day-old mutton in heat
  • Abby told doctor she suspected poisoning by business rivals
  • Days before murder: Lizzie attempted to buy prussic acid (cyanide) for "cleaning"
  • Lizzie told friend Alice she felt "something hanging over me" day before murders

The Murders - August 4th, 1892

  • 10:45 AM: Andrew Borden returns home, locked out, let in by Bridget
  • Andrew lies down on couch for nap
  • Mrs. Borden killed around 9:30 AM with 18-19 hatchet blows (13 crushed skull)
  • Andrew killed around 10:45 AM with 11 hatchet blows, face "cut clean away"
  • 11:10 AM: Lizzie calls Bridget saying "Something's happened to father"
  • Bodies discovered: Andrew still bleeding, Mrs. Borden upstairs
  • Only Lizzie in house during both murders
    • Bridget outside during stepmother's murder
    • Emma 15 miles away
    • Uncle John at post office
    • Andrew in town on business

Lizzie's Alibi and Suspicious Behavior

  • Claims she was in barn loft eating pears, getting lead for fishing sinkers
  • Stayed in 100°F barn loft for 15-20 minutes
  • Police found no footprints in barn despite her claimed presence
  • Story changed multiple times during questioning
  • Burned dress 3 days after murders (claimed paint stains)
  • Friend Alice Russell witnessed dress burning, testified against Lizzie

Evidence and Investigation

  • Police investigation botched: most force at annual picnic
  • Crime scene contaminated by neighbors and onlookers
  • Found 2 axes, 2 hatchets, 1 hatchet head with broken handle in basement
  • Hatchet head appeared "planted" and covered with dust/ash
  • Never found murder weapon handle
  • No conclusive blood evidence on suspected weapon
  • Bodies autopsied in dining room, then decapitated
  • Heads sent to Harvard, eventually buried at foot of graves

Trial and Legal Proceedings

  • Multiple hearings and inquests before formal indictment
  • Indicted on 3 counts of murder (stepmother, father, both together)
  • Two-week trial, "trial of the century"
  • Key evidence ruled inadmissible:
    • Prussic acid purchase (too inflammatory)
    • Lizzie's testimony (given under morphine influence)
  • Prosecution case entirely circumstantial with major holes
  • Defense argued 5'1" woman couldn't commit such brutal murders
  • Lizzie never testified, fainted when skulls presented
  • Jury deliberated 90 minutes, verdict: not guilty

Theories About the Murders

  • Fugue state theory (dismissed due to 90-minute timeframe and concealment)
  • Lesbian affair with maid theory (caught by stepmother)
  • Sexual/physical abuse by father theory (no evidence)
  • Maid's deathbed confession to sister (unverified)
  • William Borden (illegitimate son/butcher) theory
  • Emma committed murders with perfect alibi
  • Uncle John as perpetrator

Post-Trial Life and Death

  • Townspeople believed she was guilty despite acquittal
  • Endured harassment: whispers, rock throwing, rotten eggs
  • Bought mansion in upscale area, named it "Maplecroft"
  • Lived with sister Emma until 1905
  • Changed name to Elizabeth Borden
  • Sisters never spoke for final 22 years until death
  • Possible relationship with actress Nance O'Neal caused sister rift
  • Died at 66, Emma died 9 days later
  • All family members buried together in family plot
  • House now operates as bed & breakfast and museum

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome