AI summary by TwinMind
Selects: How No-fly Zones Work | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
26m 26s
Introduction and Historical Context
- Wright Brothers offered airplane technology to US War Department 3 times, rejected each time
- Post Office Department adopted planes for mail delivery for 3 years before military use
- By 1914, aviation section of signal corps established, planes militarized
- 1937 Spanish fascists bombed Guernica with 100,000 pounds explosives, killed 1,600 civilians
- No-fly zones developed in early 1990s as method to use planes to thwart planes against civilian populations
First No-Fly Zone: Iraq (1991-2003)
- Spring 1991: Kurdish minority in Northern Iraq encouraged by American radio broadcasts to revolt
- Saddam Hussein responded with gunships, napalm, chemical weapons, helicopters
- Hundreds of thousands Kurdish civilians fled to Turkish border
- Turkey refused entry, Kurds trapped without food/water
- President George H.W. Bush and European allies went to UN for resolution
- UN authorized humanitarian aid delivery above 36th parallel
- First no-fly zone established - if Hussein sent planes, coalition would bomb them
- 1992: Second no-fly zone established south of 32nd parallel for Shiite Muslims
- Hussein repeatedly violated zones, coalition shot down aircraft and destroyed ground targets
- Northern and southern Iraq off-limits to Hussein for 12 years until 2003 invasion
Second No-Fly Zone: Bosnia (1993)
- NATO forces authorized no-fly zone over breakaway region of Bosnia and Herzegovina
- Called "Operation Deny Flight"
- Blocked Bosnian Serbs who controlled military aircraft from attacking neighbors
- Specifically protected Serbian Muslims
- More aggressive than Iraqi no-fly zone - learned from 8 years of Iraqi experience
- Targeted military installations and bases as punishment beyond just shooting down planes
- Scott O'Grady shot down by surface-to-air missile during patrol
- Survived 6 days eating ants, drinking rainwater, evading Serbian forces
- Eventually rescued by Gene Hackman-led operation
Third No-Fly Zone: Libya (2011)
- UN Security Council Resolution 1973 authorized "all necessary measures to protect Libyan civilians"
- Called "Operation Odyssey Dawn"
- Entire Libya (680,000 square miles/1.7 million square kilometers) declared no-fly zone
- US-British led NATO coalition took control
- Most aggressive implementation - lasted about 6 months
- Russia and China persuaded to abstain from Security Council vote rather than veto
Implementation Process and Tactics
- Requires UN Security Council approval (15 members, 5 permanent with veto power)
- Chapter 7 Article 42 of UN Charter governs authorization
- No standard playbook - case-by-case basis depending on countries involved
- Libya example: Day 1 - US/UK warships fired 112 Tomahawk cruise missiles at military installations
- Goal to "shape the battle space" - destroy radar, air force, military capabilities
- Surveillance drones deployed to assess damage
- Radar jamming equipment used to disable remaining ground capabilities
- Gaddafi had vintage 1960s jets, estimated 600-1500 shoulder-launched rockets
- Saddam Hussein offered $14,000 bounty for any aircraft shot down
Rules of Engagement and Effectiveness
- Banned all flights except humanitarian missions (food, water, evacuating foreign nationals)
- Patrol aircraft must identify if violation accidental or hostile before engaging
- Ground control authorization required before shooting down aircraft
- Libya: Obama chose not to do ground invasion/regime change
- Effectiveness mixed - worked in Libya, didn't prevent Srebrenica massacre (7,000 Muslim boys/men killed)
- Only 3 no-fly zones ever implemented - insufficient data to fully assess effectiveness
- Post-9/11 US airspace shutdown provided example of eerie silence without aircraft
