AI summary by TwinMind
Selects: How Tabloids Work | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
50m 39s
Introduction and Batboy Story
- Josh introduces batboy character from Weekly World News
- Captured on Mississippi rooftop during flood
- Became ward of state, volunteered to search for Osama bin Laden in Afghanistan caves
- Used sonar hearing abilities, flew back to US as hero
- Weekly World News called itself "world's only reliable newspaper"
- Chuck subscribed in high school with friend Radford
- Shut down in print 2008, moved online due to massive profit losses
- Perfect analogy for tabloid industry decline over 20 years
Etymology and Definition of Tabloids
- Two origin stories for word "tabloid":
- Burroughs Welcome pharmaceutical company (late 1800s) compressed powder medicines into pills called "tabloids"
- Word meant small dose of anything, came 10 years before newspaper size
- Tabloid refers to smaller, more compact newspaper format vs broadsheet
- Also called "rags," "gutter publications," "gossip sheets"
- Slightly shifty, underhanded newspapers that exist in comparison to legitimate press
Historical Development
- Early 19th century newspapers: extremely stuffy, expensive (6 cents = half day's pay), dry factual reporting
- Penny press emerged as cheaper alternative for working class
- Changed from boring political/business stories to human interest
- Shorter sentences, paragraphs, injected emotion
- Laid groundwork for modern mainstream newspaper style
Yellow Journalism Era
- William Randolph Hearst's New York Journal (later New York Journal American)
- First in US to do celebrity coverage, murder, sensational gore
- Sold well until Depression when nothing sold
- Post-Depression: Generoso Pope Jr. (Gene Pope) bought New York Inquirer for $75,000
- Changed to tabloid size, inspired by people staring at car crashes
- Printed gory crime scene photos from photographer Weegee (Louis Felig)
Rupert Murdoch Influence
- Proved wide circulation possible with News of the World in England (millions of copies, sex scandals)
- Pope renamed paper National Enquirer, initially featured:
- Interracial sex, lesbianism, horrible violence
- Headlines like "teen ripping head off corpse for gold teeth"
- Always with gory crime scene photos
Transition to Supermarkets
- Competition faced problem: newsstands drying up
- Pope's solution: get into supermarkets at checkout lines
- Had to clean up content to be acceptable to respectable supermarkets
- Transitioned from crime scene photography to astrology, celebrity sex scandals
- Staff reaction: "like asking experienced grave robbers to take up gardening"
- This 1960s decision explains why tabloids are at supermarket checkouts today
Modern Tabloid Evolution
- Star tabloid switched to glossy magazine format (late 90s)
- People magazine adopted tabloid content with glossy format
- Mainstream magazines now feature "who wore it better," cellulite photos, plastic surgery disasters
Corporate Consolidation
- 1999: American Media Inc purchased National Enquirer, Star, Globe, National Examiner, Weekly World News
- AMI posted $160 million loss in 2006, faced $1 billion debt
- Weekly World News shut down, moved online
- Consolidation never good for media diversity
What Makes a Tabloid
- Key principle: story doesn't need to be true, just that someone said it's true
- Focus on person making claim rather than actual story
- Trick readers into thinking they're reading about celebrities when actually reading about former maids, random witnesses
- Use unqualified "experts" (like "Bigfoot enthusiasts") without proper credentials
- Leading questions to create quotes: "Did she look strung out?" becomes "Witnesses say she looks strung out"
Tabloid Techniques
- Make huge deal out of small stories other newspapers would ignore
- Find quasi-interesting stories in other papers, blow up to front page features
- Add multiple quotes, expert opinions to expand minimal content
- Transform story focus from event to what people think about event
Celebrity Information Sources
- Three celebrity categories regarding tabloids:
- Fight constantly
- Stay low profile, avoid being subjects
- Play ball - provide some information in exchange for favorable treatment
- Information sources include:
- Security personnel, venue workers
- Hair stylists, nail salon employees
- Anyone who can provide dirt gets into rotation
- Movie studios leak information for publicity
- Symbiotic relationship: celebrities need public awareness to maintain star status
Paparazzi Development
- Named after character Paparazzo in Fellini's "La Dolce Vita"
- Fellini said word came from Italian word for mosquito buzzing sound
- Became aggressive in 1970s due to Gene Pope's obsession with Jackie O and Aristotle Onassis
- Pope paid so much money for photos that photographers became relentless
- Worse in Europe, connected to Princess Diana's death (chased by paparazzi on motorcycles)
Legal Challenges
- Early tabloids (1950s-60s) rarely faced lawsuits because:
- Legitimate stars didn't want to stoop to their level
- Lawsuits would draw more attention to original story
- Publishers had no money to pay damages
- Gene Pope and Rupert Murdoch changed this with enormous circulation (Enquirer went from 15,000-100,000 to 5 million at peak in 1980s)
Carol Burnett Case (1976)
- Sued over article claiming she was drunk at Washington restaurant with Henry Kissinger
- Won $1.6 million (reduced by appeals court to $200,000, settled out of court for less)
- First major star to win defamation lawsuit against tabloid
- Established precedent but remains rare occurrence
Tabloid Legal Defense Strategies
- "Scorpion defense" - make suing not worth the trouble
- Drag plaintiff's entire life into spotlight through discovery
- Example: Elizabeth Taylor lawsuit led to subpoena of 30 years medical records
- File motions to delay and increase costs
- Most articles pre-screened by attorneys on retainer
- Walk right up to line of libel without crossing it
Recent Legal Cases
- Aretha Franklin, Tom Cruise, Arnold Schwarzenegger settled cases
- Katie Holmes sued Star magazine (March 2012) for $50 million over drug problem story
- Settled for donation to her charity
- Scientology connection noted in multiple cases involving Tom Cruise, John Travolta
Phone Hacking Scandal
- Rupert Murdoch's News of the World hacking scandal
- Parliamentary panel declared Murdoch unfit to run News Corp
- 4,000 celebrities/politicians/athletes had emails hacked
- Another 1,000 likely hacked
- Included kidnapped girl whose voicemail was hacked and deleted, affecting police investigation
- News of the World shut down
- Email hacking potentially more serious than phone hacking under British law
Tabloid Successes
- National Enquirer legitimate scoops:
- O.J. Simpson case: Bruno Magli shoes evidence, knife dealer story
- Found 1993 footage of O.J. wearing shoes he claimed never to own
- Ennis Cosby murder: $100,000 reward led to killer's capture
- Jesse Jackson's illegitimate child (2001)
- Gary Hart's "Monkey Business" affair with Donna Rice (1988) - ended presidential campaign
- Rush Limbaugh's OxyContin addiction (30,000 pills from maid, 20-80 pills per day)
Tabloid Decline
- Peak: National Enquirer sold 5 million copies
- Current: All leading US tabloids combined sell 5.4 million
- Decline reasons:
- Mainstream media became more tabloid-like
- Competition increased as everyone did similar content
- During Lewinsky scandal, CNN was as salacious as tabloids
- Mainstream media adopted tabloid techniques while maintaining respectability
International Perspective
- England leading edge of tabloid decline
- Argentina lacks podcast culture - US podcasts used for English learning
- Tabloids serve as cultural export, teaching colloquialisms and US culture
