AI summary by TwinMind

Selects: How Tabloids Work | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

50m 39s

Introduction and Batboy Story

  • Josh introduces batboy character from Weekly World News
    • Captured on Mississippi rooftop during flood
    • Became ward of state, volunteered to search for Osama bin Laden in Afghanistan caves
    • Used sonar hearing abilities, flew back to US as hero
  • Weekly World News called itself "world's only reliable newspaper"
    • Chuck subscribed in high school with friend Radford
    • Shut down in print 2008, moved online due to massive profit losses
    • Perfect analogy for tabloid industry decline over 20 years

Etymology and Definition of Tabloids

  • Two origin stories for word "tabloid":
    • Burroughs Welcome pharmaceutical company (late 1800s) compressed powder medicines into pills called "tabloids"
    • Word meant small dose of anything, came 10 years before newspaper size
  • Tabloid refers to smaller, more compact newspaper format vs broadsheet
  • Also called "rags," "gutter publications," "gossip sheets"
  • Slightly shifty, underhanded newspapers that exist in comparison to legitimate press

Historical Development

  • Early 19th century newspapers: extremely stuffy, expensive (6 cents = half day's pay), dry factual reporting
  • Penny press emerged as cheaper alternative for working class
    • Changed from boring political/business stories to human interest
    • Shorter sentences, paragraphs, injected emotion
    • Laid groundwork for modern mainstream newspaper style

Yellow Journalism Era

  • William Randolph Hearst's New York Journal (later New York Journal American)
    • First in US to do celebrity coverage, murder, sensational gore
    • Sold well until Depression when nothing sold
  • Post-Depression: Generoso Pope Jr. (Gene Pope) bought New York Inquirer for $75,000
    • Changed to tabloid size, inspired by people staring at car crashes
    • Printed gory crime scene photos from photographer Weegee (Louis Felig)

Rupert Murdoch Influence

  • Proved wide circulation possible with News of the World in England (millions of copies, sex scandals)
  • Pope renamed paper National Enquirer, initially featured:
    • Interracial sex, lesbianism, horrible violence
    • Headlines like "teen ripping head off corpse for gold teeth"
    • Always with gory crime scene photos

Transition to Supermarkets

  • Competition faced problem: newsstands drying up
  • Pope's solution: get into supermarkets at checkout lines
  • Had to clean up content to be acceptable to respectable supermarkets
  • Transitioned from crime scene photography to astrology, celebrity sex scandals
  • Staff reaction: "like asking experienced grave robbers to take up gardening"
  • This 1960s decision explains why tabloids are at supermarket checkouts today

Modern Tabloid Evolution

  • Star tabloid switched to glossy magazine format (late 90s)
  • People magazine adopted tabloid content with glossy format
  • Mainstream magazines now feature "who wore it better," cellulite photos, plastic surgery disasters

Corporate Consolidation

  • 1999: American Media Inc purchased National Enquirer, Star, Globe, National Examiner, Weekly World News
  • AMI posted $160 million loss in 2006, faced $1 billion debt
  • Weekly World News shut down, moved online
  • Consolidation never good for media diversity

What Makes a Tabloid

  • Key principle: story doesn't need to be true, just that someone said it's true
  • Focus on person making claim rather than actual story
  • Trick readers into thinking they're reading about celebrities when actually reading about former maids, random witnesses
  • Use unqualified "experts" (like "Bigfoot enthusiasts") without proper credentials
  • Leading questions to create quotes: "Did she look strung out?" becomes "Witnesses say she looks strung out"

Tabloid Techniques

  • Make huge deal out of small stories other newspapers would ignore
  • Find quasi-interesting stories in other papers, blow up to front page features
  • Add multiple quotes, expert opinions to expand minimal content
  • Transform story focus from event to what people think about event

Celebrity Information Sources

  • Three celebrity categories regarding tabloids:
    1. Fight constantly
    2. Stay low profile, avoid being subjects
    3. Play ball - provide some information in exchange for favorable treatment
  • Information sources include:
    • Security personnel, venue workers
    • Hair stylists, nail salon employees
    • Anyone who can provide dirt gets into rotation
  • Movie studios leak information for publicity
  • Symbiotic relationship: celebrities need public awareness to maintain star status

Paparazzi Development

  • Named after character Paparazzo in Fellini's "La Dolce Vita"
  • Fellini said word came from Italian word for mosquito buzzing sound
  • Became aggressive in 1970s due to Gene Pope's obsession with Jackie O and Aristotle Onassis
  • Pope paid so much money for photos that photographers became relentless
  • Worse in Europe, connected to Princess Diana's death (chased by paparazzi on motorcycles)

Legal Challenges

  • Early tabloids (1950s-60s) rarely faced lawsuits because:
    1. Legitimate stars didn't want to stoop to their level
    2. Lawsuits would draw more attention to original story
    3. Publishers had no money to pay damages
  • Gene Pope and Rupert Murdoch changed this with enormous circulation (Enquirer went from 15,000-100,000 to 5 million at peak in 1980s)

Carol Burnett Case (1976)

  • Sued over article claiming she was drunk at Washington restaurant with Henry Kissinger
  • Won $1.6 million (reduced by appeals court to $200,000, settled out of court for less)
  • First major star to win defamation lawsuit against tabloid
  • Established precedent but remains rare occurrence

Tabloid Legal Defense Strategies

  • "Scorpion defense" - make suing not worth the trouble
  • Drag plaintiff's entire life into spotlight through discovery
  • Example: Elizabeth Taylor lawsuit led to subpoena of 30 years medical records
  • File motions to delay and increase costs
  • Most articles pre-screened by attorneys on retainer
  • Walk right up to line of libel without crossing it

Recent Legal Cases

  • Aretha Franklin, Tom Cruise, Arnold Schwarzenegger settled cases
  • Katie Holmes sued Star magazine (March 2012) for $50 million over drug problem story
  • Settled for donation to her charity
  • Scientology connection noted in multiple cases involving Tom Cruise, John Travolta

Phone Hacking Scandal

  • Rupert Murdoch's News of the World hacking scandal
  • Parliamentary panel declared Murdoch unfit to run News Corp
  • 4,000 celebrities/politicians/athletes had emails hacked
  • Another 1,000 likely hacked
  • Included kidnapped girl whose voicemail was hacked and deleted, affecting police investigation
  • News of the World shut down
  • Email hacking potentially more serious than phone hacking under British law

Tabloid Successes

  • National Enquirer legitimate scoops:
    • O.J. Simpson case: Bruno Magli shoes evidence, knife dealer story
    • Found 1993 footage of O.J. wearing shoes he claimed never to own
    • Ennis Cosby murder: $100,000 reward led to killer's capture
    • Jesse Jackson's illegitimate child (2001)
    • Gary Hart's "Monkey Business" affair with Donna Rice (1988) - ended presidential campaign
    • Rush Limbaugh's OxyContin addiction (30,000 pills from maid, 20-80 pills per day)

Tabloid Decline

  • Peak: National Enquirer sold 5 million copies
  • Current: All leading US tabloids combined sell 5.4 million
  • Decline reasons:
    • Mainstream media became more tabloid-like
    • Competition increased as everyone did similar content
    • During Lewinsky scandal, CNN was as salacious as tabloids
    • Mainstream media adopted tabloid techniques while maintaining respectability

International Perspective

  • England leading edge of tabloid decline
  • Argentina lacks podcast culture - US podcasts used for English learning
  • Tabloids serve as cultural export, teaching colloquialisms and US culture

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome